The Little Tech Association, a new group of almost 200 companies across the startup community, like Y Combinator, urges Trump not to ban Chinese open-weight AI
Sophia Cai /Politico:
Politico Sophia Cai
Context & Ripple Effects
Y Combinator has already framed AI policy as a competition issue, warning that rules designed for safety could entrench larger incumbents in its earlier “Little Tech” lobbying push. The new association extends that organizing model to a China-linked open-weight question.
The position also aligns with the prior argument that [[a:871684|open-weight models can reduce startups’ dependence on closed developers and cloud gatekeepers]]. It matters because it puts startup access to models alongside national-policy decisions.
First-order effects
- The Little Tech Association gives roughly 200 startup-community companies, including Y Combinator, a common vehicle to press the Trump administration against a ban on Chinese open-weight AI.
- Its members publicly tie continued access to open-weight models to the competitive position of smaller AI companies, rather than leaving that case to individual firms.
Second-order effects
- A ban debate now forces AI-policy advocates to weigh startup access and competitive openness against the policy case for restrictions on Chinese models.
- Closed-model providers and cloud platforms may face sharper scrutiny from startups if restrictions narrow the pool of models those startups can build on.
Third-order effects
- If startup coalitions keep treating model access as competition policy, AI governance debates may increasingly turn on who controls the inputs for building AI products, not only on model safety.
- The episode points to a more state-mediated AI market, where trade and national-security choices can materially shape which model ecosystems startups may use.
The trend: Startup AI lobbying is broadening from opposition to domestic regulation into a campaign to preserve access to model ecosystems shaped by geopolitical policy.
Related: State-mediated AI · Frontier-lab capital concentration · The Little Tech Association · YC's Little Tech lobbying push · Open-weight AI and competition
Related Coverage
- China Weighs Locking AI Model Weights: Download What You Use Right Now Tech Times · Adrian Parham
- China's A.I. Has a Winning Formula. America, Don't Panic. New York Times · Jason Hsu
- China's Open AI Models Are Challenging Silicon Valley's Playbook Wired · Zeyi Yang
- Brockman of OpenAI Acknowledges Moonshot AI's Competitiveness The Asia Business Daily · Ryu Hyunseok
- The White House Is Trying to Figure Out What to Do About Chinese AI Wired · Hugo Lowell
- China's Moonshot AI stole from Anthropic, Trump tech adviser says BBC · Osmond Chia
- Senior White House official accuses Moonshot AI of copying Anthropic's leading frontier model SiliconANGLE · Mike Wheatley
- Experts say exploiting Anthropic's Fable isn't how Kimi K3 got so good TechCrunch · Tim Fernholz
- As China advances in AI, Trump faces a new test in the technology race Washington Post · Ian Duncan
- Runtime: OpenAI's security snafu; Google Cloud's blowout quarter; Verse is One To Watch The Stack · Tom Krazit
- Google Sets the Pace on Hefty A.I. Spending New York Times
- OpenAI's cyber test escapes the lab The Rundown AI
- A top White House official is escalating the fight over Moonshot AI's viral Kimi K3 model Business Insider · Brent D. Griffiths
- Axios interview: Jensen Huang is AI's anti-doom evangelist Axios · Mike Allen
- US claims China's Moonshot AI used Anthropic's Fable 5 to build Kimi K3 AI model Business Today
- China fires back at Trump administration claims that its AI companies steal U.S. tech NBC News · David Ingram
- U.S. accuses China's Moonshot AI of stealing from Anthropic Kyodo News
- White House Accuses Moonshot of Distilling Fable and Using Banned Nvidia Chips Implicator.ai · Marcus Schuler
- China and US spar over AI ahead of Xi visit Semafor · Tom Chivers
- US may sanction China's Moonshot for distilling Anthropic's Fable Asia Times · Jeff Pao
- US says China's Moonshot stole from Anthropic Semafor · Brendan Ruberry
- White House OSTP Director Michael Kratsios says Moonshot AI “acquired GB300-equipped servers and has accessed GB300s in Thailand, likely to train its AI models” Bloomberg · Maggie Eastland
- “We have information that Moonshot distilled Fable for the development of K3” Hacker News
- Tired of Big Tech holding all of the power...? Little Tech may be for you Portland Oregon startups … · Rick Turoczy
- White House official accuses Chinese startup of distilling Anthropic model, accessing banned Nvidia chips The Hill · Julia Shapero
- China's Kimi K3 and the rise of open-weight AI models Scientific American · Jacek Krywko
- Startup founders urge Trump not to shut off Chinese open weight AI Hacker News
- Google Sets the Pace on Hefty A.I. Spending New York Times
- Startup Founders Urge Trump Not to Shut Off Chinese Open Weight AI Slashdot · BeauHD
- How a Chinese AI model put Big Tech on notice NBC News · Rob Wile
- MVMT Labs bankruptcy lists under $1 million in assets after $38M raise CryptoSlate · Liam ‘Akiba’ Wright
- From a $3B Valuation to Bankruptcy: Movement Labs Files Chapter 11 The Crypto Times · Divya Mistry
- Movement Labs Files for Bankruptcy Following MOVE Ecosystem Restructuring CoinGape · Boluwatife Adeyemi
- Movement (MOVE) files for Chapter 11 as $141.4M in funding fails to prevent collapse Bitcoin Insider · Charles Thuo
- Movement Labs files for Chapter 11 bankruptcy after months of MOVE token turmoil Cointelegraph · Nate Kostar
- Movement Labs Files for Chapter 11 After Token Scandal Unchained
- Movement Labs Chapter 11 Filing Caps 99% MOVE Collapse CryptoNinjas · Isabella Flores
- Movement Labs collapses into bankruptcy after MOVE token scandals crypto.news · Lawrence Mondal
- Srsly Risky Biz: Knives Are Out For Open-Weight AI Models Risky Business · Tom Uren
- US Startups Urge Trump to Keep Access to Chinese AI Models Seoul Economic Daily · Park Min-Ju
Discussion
-
@andrewcurran_
Andrew Curran
on x
A new trade group, known as the Little Tech Association, which includes Proton, Replit and Y-Combinator, are urging the Trump admin to not ban Chinese open-source models, they argue that doing so would be catastrophic for US start-ups, while doing nothing to stop proliferation. […
-
@shwetarkohli
Shweta Rajpal Kohli
on x
🧐
-
@anthonyronning
Anthony Ronning
on x
Yes, our US startup protecting user privacy with TEE hosted open models would be destroyed. Which is why I pledge to ignore any unlawful orders on any open model bans.
-
@lutherlowe
Luther Lowe
on x
NEW: 🚨 in a letter that just dropped, nearly 200 companies (members of @LittleTechOrg) call upon the White House to not ban open weight models. [image]
-
r/LocalLLaMA
r
on reddit
Startup founders urge Trump not to shut off Chinese open weight AI
-
@secscottbessent
Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent
on x
We support open-source AI and the innovation it unlocks. But open source is not open season on American IP. When PRC firms conduct covert, industrial-scale distillation attacks that cross the line into IP theft, sanctions and Entity List designations will be on the table.
-
@sarahkheck
Sarah Heck
on x
Thanks @mkratsios47 for speaking out on this important issue. Illicit, adversarial distillation is IP theft and industrial espionage that supports adversary military and intelligence capabilities. It is a national challenge that creates serious national security risks for the U…
-
@undersece
@undersece
on x
This is more than a heist of invaluable American Intellectual Property. It is an assault on every economy that prizes the entrepreneur, rewards private capital, and relies on fair and honest competition. Lying, cheating, and stealing is not innovation or “win-win”. It's corros…
-
@eliebakouch
Elie
on x
there are only 15 days between fable 5 ban removal and kimi K3 release. i don't think claiming that K3's performance comes from fable distillation (even if they did it) makes sense technically
-
@parkerconrad
Parker Conrad
on x
A set of politically-connected growth investors are mobilizing to protect their bag in Anthropic. They will secure bans on chinese open source models, when no crime has been proven—or even alleged—and without any act of congress. All to protect a set of wealthy investors.
-
@hamandcheese
Samuel Hammond
on x
We urgently need to pass the Chip Security Act to enforce location verification of our advanced chip exports. By all means sanction adversarial distillation, but allowing China to illicitly or surreptitiously access racks of Hoppers and Blackwells is the far bigger own-goal.
-
@ramez
Ramez Naam
on x
Yup. The federal government signalling that they'll sanction Moonshot and make it hard for Americans to use Kimi, the lowest cost frontier AI model and de facto best cyber defense model. Foreign adversaries & hackers will still be able to use it, of course. But maybe not you.
-
@quxiaoyin
Xiaoyin Qu
on x
If U.S bans Kimi, it will actually benefit Kimi: 1. They aren't making much money in the U.S …
-
@kimmonismus
@kimmonismus
on x
„sanctions and Entity List designations will be on the table." Yeah, bans on Chinese open source are coming. Pretty sure at this point. If Scott Bessent, who pushed through similar measures against Anthropic, raises this as a possibility, we know where things are headed.
-
@joshua_saxe
Joshua Saxe
on x
1) It's going to be extremely hard to stop AI companies from training on each other's model outputs from a technical POV because ... *the model behaviors are the product the model companies are selling* and you don't need that many of them to get leveraged gains in posttraining
-
@kevinbankston
Kevin Bankston
on x
This seems like a poorly tailored content- and speaker-based restriction on speech. And while Chinese company Moonshot may not have a direct 1st amendment right to publish its weights and outputs, we in the US likely have a 1st am right to receive them.
-
@taylorlorenz
Taylor Lorenz
on x
Suddenly we have to protect the AI companies— who commit 24/7 IP theft and have built their businesses on IP theft— from IP theft? Lmao
-
@stevesi
Steven Sinofsky
on x
This makes me sad. It always makes me sad to see tech companies in litigation in general and in IP litigation specifically. This compounds when any company seeks to do so under the cover of using the whole of government, trade law, and claims of spying. Treating/calling model …
-
@ryangreenblatt
Ryan Greenblatt
on x
Many people seem to be arguing this is implausible because Fable hasn't been out for long. But Moonshot could have obtained unauthorized access before Fable was released via actors with prerelease access (Glasswing) or possibly by hacking Anthropic directly.
-
@kevinsxu
Kevin S. Xu
on x
As of today's America, an AI model's output or chain of thought is not copyrighted nor treated as trade secrets. So it is not IP. You may *feel* like it is because of something you've read. But it isn't. Thus, alleging distillation as “IP theft” is not a serious legal
-
@fujikanaeda
Eric W. Tramel
on x
Allegations like this need to get precisely technical if they are to be taken seriously. E.g. how many tokens, during what timeframe, with what inputs, used for what purpose, in what stage of training, and to what effect? What do we mean by “distillation”, even? Is it SFT, RL
-
@kevinbankston
Kevin Bankston
on x
I'd be curious to understand what IP is being stolen? According to your (C) office, LLM outputs aren't copyrightable, and courts have long held reverse engineering to be a fair use; trade secret is a stretch since the company's model is directly disclosing the info. Easy to say
-
@emollick
Ethan Mollick
on x
I have no inside information, but every sign so far is that there is growing tension about open weights models between the US & China: the US announcing that they reserve the right to act against distilled models, then saying Kimi distills. Contradictory reports from China, etc.
-
@phl43
Philippe Lemoine
on x
I think concerns about distillation from US models by Chinese companies are legitimate, although nobody really knows how much it actually matters, but it's kind of funny to see a US official complain that a Chinese company has violated export controls on chips and, in the same
-
@rakeshsfnyc
Rakesh Agrawal
on x
The funniest thing here is that he thinks the president will (or is capable of) reading a document this long. He wouldn't have the attention span to read the tl;dr.
-
@kimmonismus
@kimmonismus
on x
This reads to me as if preparations are being made to ban models like Kimi K3 in the future. I would be very interested in the evidence that leads to the assumption that Fable 5 was distilled for Kimi K3.
-
@krishnanrohit
Rohit
on x
Jun 9: Fable's out Jun 12: Fable revoked Jul 1: Fable's back with stronger classifiers Jul 15: Kimi's out
-
@xinyu2ml
Xinyu Yang
on x
While others write stories, we're busy writing code. Getting our models ready to open-source for the world. Stay tuned.
-
@eliebakouch
Elie
on x
(even if they did it)* i personally have 0 information about whether they did it or not, i'm just saying that even if they had some distillation pipeline for prompts or judge, i'm having a hard time thinking that this would significantly boost performance in this very short
-
@peterwildeford
Peter Wildeford
on x
The US government accuses Kimi K3 of being developed with... - sophisticated large-scale distillation of Anthropic's Fable model - use of Nvidia compute procured in violation of US export controls - legal use of remote compute in Thailand 👀
-
@teknium
@teknium
on x
I have information that Anthropic scraped my github twitter reddit discord and facebook posts for the development of it's Fable model. To do this they developed a sophisticated internal platform to conduct large scale scraping and obfuscation of their actions.
-
@bubbleboi
Bubble Boi
on x
Isn't going to college like literally distilling from your professors? What's the big deal.
-
@danprimack
Dan Primack
on x
“They used my stuff without permission.” “Whatever. That's just distillation.” — “China used my stuff without permission.” “Thieves!!!!!”
-
@ednewtonrex
Ed Newton-Rex
on x
We have information that Anthropic distilled millions of creatives' work for the development of its Fable model. To do this they developed a sophisticated internal platform to conduct large scale training on U.S. copyrighted work, allowing them to quickly train on millions of
-
@chrisgpt
Chris
on x
Kimi K3 was already in internal evaluation by April/May, before Fable 5 had been available long enough to be a plausibly distilled. I'll wait for the evidence from the USG if they'll publish it. However Kimi already outperformed Fable on BrowserComp, so if K3.1 beats Fable 5 on…
-
@randyxian
Randy
on x
yes, Fable went public on July 1 and K3 launched on July 15. We trained a brand new frontier model in JUST 15 DAYS. Guinness World Record stuff.
-
@krishnanrohit
Rohit
on x
Could this be true re the scale? Fable was barely out for any time before it was shut down and Kimi came out.
-
@ednewtonrex
Ed Newton-Rex
on x
If AI training is just like human learning (as the AI bros love to tell us), why should Chinese AI companies not learn from US AI companies' outputs?
-
@andrewcurran_
Andrew Curran
on x
Scott Bessent alluded to this yesterday and specifically mentioned sanctions. It's possible they may be gearing up to use Kimi as a test case for new penalties. US-China AI talks are planned for September, with Bessent leading the US side. Things are heating up. [image]
-
@curtis_yarvin
Curtis Yarvin
on x
Solution: no wires to China. Great Firewall facing inward. Trade still legal but must be conducted by clipper ship. Sail power only
-
@yacinemtb
Kache
on x
@mkratsios47 I don't remember letting anthropic scrape my GitHub profile as well as all of my online writing!
-
@nathancgy4
Nathan Chen
on x
every day rn i go on x to learn something new about this company
-
@martin_casado
@martin_casado
on x
Very sensible position provided the allegations are true.
-
@micsolana
Mike Solana
on x
what's wrong, you don't like the free market?* *american startups competing against the second wealthiest nation state in human history, which is presently committed, from the top down, to destabilizing our industry and cornering the global intelligence market
-
@steve_yegge
Steve Yegge
on x
When are people going to figure out that intelligence can't be contained? It's been leaking for millennia, it's going to keep leaking at an exponential rate, and there's nothing you can do about it.
-
@tekbog
@tekbog
on x
soon the great firewalls will be put up and a shadow token economy will be born welcome to cyber warfare
-
@matthewstoller
Matt Stoller
on x
Anthropic ‘distilled’ millions of copyrighted books without asking. They knowingly used pirated materials for training. The entire U.S. ecosystem of AI is based on similar theft and extraction. But it's unfair when China does it to us? Grow up.
-
@sophiacai99
Sophia Cai
on x
Instead of banning Chinese AI models by putting them on a Commerce entities list, the Trump administration is zeroing in on Chinese models being “distilled” from — or copying — U.S. models. Bessent yesterday floated sanctions.
-
@jack_raines
Jack Raines
on x
Wait til you figure out what the frontier labs trained on!
-
@matthewberman
Matthew Berman
on x
1. Didn't we know this? 2. The data distilled from Ant was not enough to make the model as good as it is. 3. Why can't Fable detect and prevent distillation attacks? 4. This seems like a losing battle, let's just go all-in on building our own (US) AI.
-
@arielkwiat
Ariel
on x
US cope is starting to exceed even the European cope-producing facilities. Truly outstanding.
-
@kchoudhu
@kchoudhu
on x
“They paid for Anthropic for API access and used it”
-
@haider1
Haider
on x
@mkratsios47 we have information that Anthropic distilled humanity's entire internet for the development of Fable 5
-
@matthew_sigel
@matthew_sigel
on x
Frontier labs entire business model is built on “distilling” the entire history of human creativity and intelligence, no?
-
@cmuratori
Casey Muratori
on x
When AI companies pirate something*, it's “fair use”. When someone pirates their model data, it's “stealing” and “undermining American research”. * - Literally pirate. Multiple court admissions have made clear that AI companies download millions of works from pirate sites.
-
@chrisrmcguire
Chris McGuire
on x
Incredibly strong statement by @mkratsios47 showing how China is continuing to illicitly distill its AI models from US models and illegally access U.S. chips. Excellent the administration is so focused on this. The question again is: when is this going to translate into action?
-
@aphysicist
Aaron Slodov
on x
maybe one day china will actually make a better model from the ground up, prob not, but maybe!
-
@dkaushik96
Divyansh Kaushik
on x
Important to note that BIS could address the remote access issue today if it wanted to.
-
@dougcalidas
Doug Calidas
on x
Hard to see how anyone can look at this and reach the conclusion that the US needs to double-down on accelerating release of frontier models to “beat China.” Absent the release of US frontier models, Chinese developers like Moonshot have nothing to distill. This seems so
-
@hunterwalk.com
@hunterwalk.com
on bluesky
even if true, doesn't matter. — Anything that can be distilled will be distilled. [embedded post]
-
@fry69.dev
@fry69.dev
on bluesky
That is simply impossible! — It takes months to train a model! — Fable was not available during that time where the main training run for K3 must have happened! — Also it takes ENORMOUS amount of data to train a model! — Way more that it is possible to siphon from an API …
-
@daniloc.xyz
@daniloc.xyz
on bluesky
I saw Goody Proctor distilling with Fable [embedded post]
-
r/politics
r
on reddit
The White House Is Trying to Figure Out What to Do About Chinese AI
-
r/mlscaling
r
on reddit
USG states that Moonshot used large-scale rapid Fable distillation for Kimi K3, and has both acquired & accessed export-controlled GB300 Nvidia GPUs
-
r/MU_Stock
r
on reddit
White House accuses China's Moonshot AI of distilling Anthropic's Fable to develop Kimi K3.
-
@mkratsios47
Director Michael Kratsios
on x
White House OSTP Director Michael Kratsios says “we have information that Moonshot AI distilled Anthropic's Fable for the development of its K3 model”
-
r/LocalLLaMA
r
on reddit
The Little Tech Association, a new group of ~200 companies across the startup community, including Y Combinator, urges Trump not to ban Chinese open-weight AI