Amazon's third-party “seller services”, a large and growing part of the company's revenue that is also profitable, has filled its Marketplace with junk products
its drift from anything resembling shopping or informed consumption — is becoming harder for Amazon's one-click magic trick to hide.” https://nymag.com/... Maya Kosoff / @mekosoff : retail in 2023 involves choosing between going to walgreens and doing ur shopping by having a worker unlock each individual item for you from behind plexiglas, or trying to decide between IOCBYHZ, BANKKY, or KLAQQED spatulas on amazon https://nymag.com/... Craig Mod / @craigmod : In Japan, for any electronics purchase of moderate value, I go straight to the bic / yodobashi websites instead of Amazon; it can just be too much of a headache to parse the results otherwise: https://nymag.com/... Charlie Warzel / @cwarzel : the age old question: BANKKY or KLAQQED? https://nymag.com/... Noah Kulwin / @nkulw : most original take on amazon i've encountered in years https://nymag.com/... Tom Gara / @tomgara : The experience of shopping on Amazon is getting worse, but the good news for Amazon is that the experience of shopping at physical retail stores is getting worse at a faster pace https://twitter.com/... John Herrman / @jwherrman : amazon is optimizing itself into oblivion https://nymag.com/... @tedfrank : Amazing. (Also, if you live somewhere so shoplifter-ridden that you always need someone to unlock products for you, move to Houston, where it's happened to me twice in three years (both times baby formula), and I never bought from the shelves there again.) https://twitter.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Context & Ripple Effects
This piece extends a critique that has been building for years: back in 2018, [[a:935870|BuzzFeed News argued Amazon was 'surprisingly bad' at its primary job of running a retail site]], and The Verge's Marketplace investigation showed how sellers weaponize Amazon's own rules against each other while living in fear of suspension. What New York Magazine adds is the revenue logic behind the decay — third-party seller services are now large, growing, and profitable, so Amazon has no financial incentive to fix the junk-product problem its own Marketplace produces.
First-order effects
- Shoppers like Craig Mod, quoted in the piece, are already rerouting purchases to specialist retailers — in his case, Japan's Bic and Yodobashi electronics sites — rather than sorting through interchangeable no-name brands like IOCBYHZ or KLAQQED spatulas on Amazon.
Second-order effects
- Specialist and regional retailers gain a differentiation opening: if Amazon's search results are a wall of unvetted listings, curated inventory and trustworthy product information become a selling point rather than a cost.
- Honest sellers inside Marketplace face rising customer-acquisition costs, since the ranking system they compete in is already gamed by click farms, reviewers-for-hire, and paid Amazon insiders — pushing more of them toward off-Amazon channels.
Third-order effects
- If the pattern holds, Amazon's retail business risks splitting in two: a profitable seller-services engine that tolerates degraded quality, and a brand-conscious customer base that migrates to alternatives — the same tension the pandemic exposed when surging demand pushed Amazon to its breaking point. Sustained trust erosion could eventually invite regulatory attention to how Marketplace ranking and seller vetting actually work.
The trend: Marketplace economics — profitable seller services funded by listing volume — are structurally pulling Amazon's retail experience toward junk products, pushing quality-sensitive shoppers back toward specialist retailers.