Obama bans spying on leaders of U.S. allies, scales back NSA program
(Reuters) - President Barack Obama announced a ban on U.S. eavesdropping on the leaders of close friends and allies on Friday, and rein in the vast collection of Americans' phone data in a series of reforms triggered by Edward Snowden's revelations.
Context & Ripple Effects
The announcement lands after a month-long runway: the presidential review panel recommended new limits on NSA spying in mid-December, Obama readied a revamp of the agency earlier this month (WSJ, January 9), and a preview two days ago signaled the plan would leave many current programs intact while embracing reform rhetoric. What changed today is the concrete move against allied-leader eavesdropping and the scaling back of bulk American phone-data collection.
The reception is split along predictable lines: the EFF scored the package at just 3.5 out of 12 proposed reforms, and tech firms told The Switch the proposals fall short of their expectations — notable because NSA officials have been openly discussing how Snowden's leaks are damaging the industry. The context for that damage keeps accumulating, from reports of nearly 100,000 computers implanted with monitoring software to an untargeted sweep collecting some 200 million text messages a day.
First-order effects
- Leaders of close allied governments are removed as legitimate NSA interception targets, forcing the agency to rebuild liaison-based intelligence relationships it had been circumventing.
- The NSA's bulk collection of Americans' phone records is curtailed, changing what data the agency can query without case-by-case justification.
Second-order effects
- U.S. technology companies, already telling reporters the reforms fall short of expectations, still face the harder task of convincing foreign customers that data held with them is not subject to the practices Snowden exposed — pushing them to lobby for stronger legal guarantees than Obama offered.
- Allied governments gain leverage in negotiations over intelligence sharing, having seen that public embarrassment rather than private protest produced concessions.
Third-order effects
- If the pattern holds, surveillance authority shifts incrementally from internal executive rules toward externally enforced limits — legislation and judicial oversight — with each leak cycle forcing another round of codification, though the January 15 preview suggests core programs survive largely intact.
- The economic dimension becomes structural: trust in American cloud and hardware providers turns into a measurable competitive variable abroad, making surveillance policy de facto trade policy for the tech sector.
The trend: Surveillance practice is being reined in one scandal-driven policy adjustment at a time, with executive restraint substituting for legislative overhaul and the tech industry bearing the reputational cost of the gap between the two.
Related: NSA · Edward Snowden · Barack Obama · Obama Panel Recommends New Limits on N.S.A. Spying · Obama surveillance plan leaves many programs in place
Related Coverage
- EFF's scorecard rates Obama's proposed NSA reforms at 3.5 out of 12 Electronic Frontier Foundation
- President Obama's NSA reforms show both promise and peril The Verge
- Tech firms say Obama's proposals fall short of expectations The Switch · Cecilia Kang
- New York Times New York Times · Mark Landler
- Electronic Frontier Foundation Electronic Frontier Foundation · Rebecca Jeschke
- Washington Post Washington Post
- Engadget Engadget · Sharif Sakr
- ZDNet ZDNet · Zack Whittaker
- Gigaom Gigaom · Jeff John Roberts
- Gizmodo Gizmodo · Adam Clark Estes
- Gizmodo UK Gizmodo UK · Adam Clark Estes
- Mashable Mashable · Fran Berkman
- The Verge The Verge · Sean Hollister
- Softpedia News Softpedia News · Gabriela Vatu
- Wall Street Journal Wall Street Journal
- @thewritertype @thewritertype · Paul Bassett Davies
- @trevortimm @trevortimm · Trevor Timm
- @viticci @viticci · Federico Viticci
- @michaelphirsh @michaelphirsh · Michaelhirsh
- @csoghoian @csoghoian · Christopher Soghoian
- @jcenters @jcenters · Josh Centers
- @normative @normative · Julian Sanchez
- @bengreenman @bengreenman · Ben Greenman
- @zoescarpenter @zoescarpenter · Zoë Carpenter
- @eff @eff
- @attackerman @attackerman · Spencer Ackerman
- @tim_stevens @tim_stevens · Tim Stevens
- @jesselynradack @jesselynradack · Jesselyn Radack
- @declanm @declanm · Declan McCullagh
- @profjeffjarvis @profjeffjarvis
- @reckless @reckless · Nilay Patel
- @pierre @pierre · Pierre Omidyar
- @dangillmor @dangillmor · Dan Gillmor
- @jmarkockerbloom @jmarkockerbloom · John Mark Ockerbloom
- The Switch The Switch · Brian Fung
- Guardian Guardian · Glenn Greenwald
- CNET CNET · Edward Moyer
- Betabeat Betabeat · Molly Mulshine
- Computerworld Computerworld
- PC World PC World · Grant Gross
- Senator Wyden's Press Feed Senator Wyden's Press Feed
- Facebook Facebook · Justin Amash
- TechFreedom TechFreedom
- Access Blog Access Blog
- VentureBeat VentureBeat · Eric Blattberg
- TechCrunch TechCrunch · Gregory Ferenstein
- SiliconBeat SiliconBeat · Michelle Quinn
- Gotta Be Mobile Gotta Be Mobile · Warner Crocker
- eWeek eWeek · Sean Michael Kerner
- @joshuatopolsky @joshuatopolsky · Joshua Topolsky
- Mozilla Privacy Blog Mozilla Privacy Blog · Alex Fowler
- Wired Wired · Steven Levy
- Politico Politico · Tony Romm
- CTIA-The Wireless Association® Blog CTIA-The Wireless Association® Blog · Jot Carpenter
- PC Magazine PC Magazine · Chloe Albanesius
- View article New York Times
- View article Electronic Frontier Foundation
- View article Washington Post
- View article Engadget
- View article ZDNet
- View article Gigaom
- View article Gizmodo
- View article Gizmodo UK
- View article Mashable
- View article The Verge
- View article Softpedia News
- View article Wall Street Journal
- View article @thewritertype
- View article @trevortimm
- View article @viticci
- View article @michaelphirsh
- View article @csoghoian
- View article @jcenters
- View article @normative
- View article @bengreenman
- View article @zoescarpenter
- View article @eff
- View article @attackerman
- View article @tim_stevens
- View article @jesselynradack
- View article @declanm
- View article @bengreenman
- View article @profjeffjarvis
- View article @reckless
- View article Electronic Frontier Foundation
- View article @pierre
- View article @dangillmor
- View article @jmarkockerbloom
- View article The Switch
- View article Guardian
- View article CNET
- View article Betabeat
- View article Computerworld
- View article PC World
- View article Senator Wyden's Press Feed
- View article Justin Amash
- View article TechFreedom
- View article Access Blog
- View article VentureBeat
- View article TechCrunch
- View article SiliconBeat
- View article Gotta Be Mobile
- View article eWeek
- View article Softpedia News
- View article @joshuatopolsky
- View article Mozilla Privacy Blog
- View article Wired
- View article Politico
- View article CTIA-The Wireless …
- View article VentureBeat
- View article PC Magazine