Six months after Elon Musk's takeover of Twitter, an overview of its alternatives, including Mastodon, Bluesky, and Nostr, and how they might evolve and improve
Today is six months since Elon took over Twitter and began this bizarre speedrun of the content moderation learning curve …
Techdirt Mike Masnick
Related Coverage
- What is Bluesky? How to get on the waitlist for this decentralized Twitter alternative ZDNet · Jada Jones
- BlueSky, Jack Dorsey backed ‘decentralized’ Twitter rival has more takers than expected. Here's why Livemint
- What is Bluesky? A new Jack Dorsey-backed Twitter rival has people fighting for invites Insider · Beatrice Nolan
- What is Bluesky and why are people clamouring to join it? The Economic Times
- What to know about Bluesky, the Twitter alternative that some celebrities and journalists are joining NBC News · Kalhan Rosenblatt
- Checked out Blue Sky and it immediately feels like the corrosive and viral-baiting aspects of Twitter. No thank'ee. @glennf@twit.social · Glenn Fleishman
- This post by @mmasnick helped clarify my thinking about what post-Twitter option—if any of them—is likely to occupy an embarrassing amount of my screen time six months from now. … @robpegoraro@journa.host · Rob Pegoraro
- I think this nails why people are finding Bluesky exciting. It's a rare situation where something is both embryonic and at a mass scale. — That is somewhat uncommon to find, even here. @ernie@writing.exchange · Ernie Smith
- bluesky is not mastodon.social, it's more c.im @davidgerard@circumstances.run · David Gerard
- Social network status 2023 so far: — Twitter: transforming into paid version of 4chan, OnlyFans for trolls — Mastodon: 40% smug left wingers saying how cool we are, 40% civil war about nothing, 20% content … @GossiTheDog@cyberplace.social · Kevin Beaumont
- I think if Bluesky had launched in November, I would have been curious. But I've been here for 5 months now and there's been a noticeable change in my physical well-being, including a drop in blood pressure. … @kims@mas.to · Kim Scheinberg
- Jack Dorsey Criticizes Sale of Twitter to Elon Musk Wall Street Journal
- Is Jack Dorsey's backed Bluesky the new Twitter alternative? Tech Startups · Nickie Louise
- Elon Musk slashes Twitter employees' parental leaves from 20 weeks to 14 days Livemint
- Jack Dorsey Criticizes Musk Regime, Says Twitter CEO Should've ‘Walked Away’ From Deal International Business Times · Marvie Basilan
- What is Bluesky? And does it have the potential to be a Twitter killer? KnowTechie · Kevin Raposo
- Twitter co-founder Jack Dorsey said company ‘went south’ after Elon Musk took over New York Post · David Propper
- Jack Dorsey criticizes Elon Musk's leadership at Twitter: ‘It all went south’ CNBC · Ashley Capoot
- Jack Dorsey thinks Elon Musk isn't doing right by Twitter TechCrunch · Darrell Etherington
- Jack Dorsey Isn't Happy With Elon Musk's Twitter Newser · Steve Huff
- I Got A Bluesky Invite, Here's What's Going On Over There Forbes · Paul Tassi
- Jack Dorsey's change of heart on Elon Musk.The Twitter co-founder and former CEO said this when Musk bought Twitter one year ago: The Verge · Thomas Ricker
- Roundup: Blue skies and bad cars Disconnect · Paris Marx
- Elon Musk isn't doing right for Twitter: Jack Dorsey The Economic Times
- Jack Dorsey: The Crypto Hero We Need Right Now Coinmonks
- How to Get Bluesky Invite Codes as Chrissy Teigen Joins Decentralized Twitter Rival Decrypt · Alys Key
- Elon Musk not ‘singular solution’ for Twitter after all, says Jack Dorsey in reversal of earlier support Fortune · Steve Mollman
- Jack Dorsey went from being ‘really happy’ about Elon Musk joining Twitter's board to saying he shouldn't have bought it. Here's how their bromance has evolved. Insider
- I see Jack Dorsey is answering questions in his new Twitter, known as Blue Sky. … Scripting News · Dave Winer
- Jack Dorsey Opens Up About Twitter Deal, Criticizes Elon Musk CoinGape · Jai Pratap
- you can tell bluesky is run by crypto people because the answer to questions like “why are block lists public you idiots” is “but the PROTOCOL will be SO COOL in the FABULOUS FUTURE here's the WHITE PAPER” @davidgerard@circumstances.run · David Gerard
- I don't blame Jack for Twitter/Musk, but if he had second thoughts he certainly could've said something before it was too late. Also if he turned against the deal, why did he roll over his shares instead of cash out? … @paul@tapbots.social
- Don't let Dorsey launder his reputation by timidly criticizing the obviously horrendous moron he handpicked to sell Twitter to. Dorsey is responsible for driving Twitter into the ground long before Musk made them an offer they couldn't refuse. … @fraying@xoxo.zone · Derek Powazek
Discussion
-
@tomw@mastodon.social
Tom Walker
on mastodon
Mastodon is an incredibly rare opportunity for open-source, non-profit, advertising-free, decentralised software to be a real contender in a category - and, if it continues to grow, even to pull many other social networks into being part of (or interoperable with) the fediverse. …
-
@Wikisteff@mastodon.social
Steffen Christensen
on mastodon
Mike @mmasnick has a great article about the three big Twitter replacements out now: Mastodon, BlueSky, and nostr. — I really appreciate his analysis here. — I keep thinking about ownership. …
-
@atomicpoet@mastodon.social
Chris Trottier
on mastodon
When you block people on Bluesky, your block list is public. — Which means that if someone is blocked, everyone will know. — This approach to blocking may prove controversial.
-
@daveleeFT@mastodon.social
Dave Lee
on mastodon
Celebrations over at Bluesky as they reach 50k users. Mastodon at 11 million+ yet still written off as the post-Twitter platform. What am I missing?
-
@mmasnick@mastodon.social
Mike Masnick
on mastodon
It's been six months since Elon took over Twitter. I have some thoughts on the “Twitter diaspora” and the current decentralized alternatives: https://www.techdirt.com/...
-
@broderick
Ryan Broderick
on x
Logging on to Bluesky yesterday was like jumping into a time machine and traveling back to 2012. https://www.garbageday.email/ ... https://twitter.com/...
-
@ohnoshetwitnt
@ohnoshetwitnt
on x
Imagine how badly you fucked up a website that people are leaving that website for a nearly identical website created by the guy who created the first website that you fucked up.
-
@airlineflyer
Jason Rabinowitz
on x
The downfall of Twitter continues, as major public agencies and private corporations abandon their customer service operations here. Twitter is (was?) the ***best*** place for direct customer service from many companies. It sucks to see it needlessly destroyed by @elonmusk. https…
-
@carnage4life
@carnage4life
on x
It's interesting how product decisions shape the user base of a product. Mastodon is a pain in the ass to use so it attracts people who think dealing with inconvenience is a virtue. Sort of like Linux on the desktop. This is in stark contrast to Bluesky.
-
@tprstly
Theo
on x
Every platform post-twitter will fail because nobody really cares anymore https://twitter.com/...
-
@mahemoff
@mahemoff
on x
And that cultural norm against algorithms is why Mastodon can't retain most users https://www.techdirt.com/...
-
Vox
Shirin Ghaffary
on x
What is Bluesky, and why is everyone on Twitter talking about it?
-
@Sarahp@mastodon.social
Sarah Perez
on mastodon
Pretty sure I'm a better fit for Mastodon than Bluesky but those kids sure are having fun
-
@brianhough@mastodon.social
Brian Hough
on mastodon
Bluesky users are trying to purposely break the site with extra long “hell threads,” If your wondering what the vibe is like over there rn
-
@atomicpoet@mastodon.social
Chris Trottier
on mastodon
Jack Dorsey explaining exactly why no single company should own a social media platform.
-
@chad_hurley
Mr. Tube
on x
The most underrated superpower of starting a social media platform? Not making yourself the star of the show.
-
@chad_hurley
Mr. Tube
on x
Never been more bullish about Twitter.
-
@grrlscientist
@grrlscientist
on x
Musk's erratic leadership has disillusioned a one-time friend and powerful ally, reflecting a growing backlash against a tumultuous tenure that has sent advertisers fleeing and users searching for alternatives #Twitter #elon_musk https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
-
@ashtonpittman
Ashton Pittman
on x
And while the idea for Bluesky originated at Twitter in 2019 and received funding from Twitter, it no longer has any affiliation with Twitter. Elon Musk cut ties with Bluesky when he took over. So despite what you may've heard, he has no stake in it. 3/ https://www.vox.com/...
-
@comixace
Heidi MacDonald
on x
Tech overlords, I beseech you, can you all please hire a bene gesserit type adviser to always sit by your side and explain blatantly obvious aspects of human nature for you that you can't figure out? https://techcrunch.com/...
-
@shaft
Leslie Miley
on x
What I hate about this take is that @jack is like, it went south, let's move forward and build something else. Which is what so many people with privilege do after facilitating the destruction of something that was invaluable to those with less privilege. https://twitter.com/...
-
@will_decotiis
Will DeCotiis
on x
🤣🤣🤣 I'm sorry but considering what appears to have been going on at Twitter under Dorsey's reign that's pretty rich https://twitter.com/...
-
@iethics
@iethics
on x
“As Bluesky caught fire on Thursday, some users already mourned its small community dynamic. They pointed out that social apps tend to start like this—niche, wild, and fun—until the masses join and they're eventually ruined” https://slate.com/... #ethics #internet #socialmedia
-
@mattbinder
Matt Binder
on x
watching Jack Dorsey simultaneously defend his previous stance on selling Twitter to Elon Musk while also criticizing the decision to sell Twitter to Elon Musk on Bluesky 🍿 https://twitter.com/...
-
@prasanto
@prasanto
on x
A momentary lapse into reason: Twitter founder Jack Dorsey says Musk wasn't the ideal leader after all https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
-
@chargrille
@chargrille
on x
There's a lot of misinformation & disinformation circulating that works to obscure or soften Jack Dorsey's involvement in #Bluesky, #Twitter & his bromance with Elon Musk generally. https://progressives.social/ ... https://twitter.com/...
-
@iethics
@iethics
on x
“Instead of replicating #Twitter one-for-one, simply building a challenger that's big enough to be lively but small enough to disincentivize the toxicity would be a real accomplishment. It's a lofty hope, and unlikely to materialize”: https://slate.com/... #ethics #internet
-
@mazmhussain
Murtaza Hussain
on x
There are still a few simps and courtiers defending Elon Musk out of sincere self-abasement or in the hopes it will benefit them in some way but even Jack Dorsey is saying that his ownership has been a disaster: https://www.cnbc.com/...
-
@livemint
@livemint
on x
#Twitter co-founder Jack Dorsey — once a supporter of #ElonMusk's $44 billion acquisition of the site — is now offering sharp criticism of the new owner and his handling of the deal. https://www.livemint.com/...
-
@cultexpert
Steven Hassan, PhD
on x
If true, this is a big thing. https://twitter.com/...
-
@jayrosen_nyu
Jay Rosen
on x
In my view @jack ought to spend years reflecting on how he made this error and what led up to it. When you get something that big that wrong ("the singular solution I trust...") you have to go back a long way. Then tell us what you found. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ... https…
-
@benedictevans
Benedict Evans
on x
I can't wait to see how Blue Sky benefits from the leadership and product skills Jack Dorsey showed in his near-decade long management of Twitter.
-
@thetimes
@thetimes
on x
Are you scared @elonmusk? https://www.thetimes.co.uk/...
-
@carnage4life
@carnage4life
on x
He said that “Hell no” with his full chest. https://twitter.com/...
-
@davetroy
Dave Troy
on x
1/Regarding Jack, Elon, and Bluesky, it appears that Musk has managed to strain his formerly tight relationship with Dorsey. But that has implications that are non-obvious; here's a quick rundown. First, look at how things have shifted in the last year. https://twitter.com/...
-
@davetroy
Dave Troy
on x
12/And I will remind folks that Dorsey did not transact his shares in Twitter and did not receive any cash benefit from the transaction. He was a true believer in Elon's vision. He may regret that now, but he still holds the shares unless he sold them. https://www.cnn.com/...
-
@evasteslasplaid
Eva McMillan
on x
Highly and respectfully disagree with Jack Dorsey❗️ Elon @elonmusk turned Twitter around just in few months. The platform is more trusted, more fun and entertaining than any other sites. It has more followers and subscribers than ever. One more quarter and Twitter starts bringing…
-
@goldman
Jason Goldman
on x
Man if this couple couldn't make it what hope is there for the rest of us https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
-
@carnage4life
@carnage4life
on x
Jack is spending his time and money to recreate a version of Twitter not subject to whims of one company. This started as a way to get away from one company being bullied by governments to shape the public conversation. Turns out it also ensures the company can't become a bully. …
-
@danprimack
Dan Primack
on x
Surprised to see @jack write that @elonmusk should have just paid Twitter $1 billion to get out of their deal. Surprised because that wasn't really an option Musk had. That was a breakup fee that only applies if musk couldn't close the deal (e.g. regulatory block, etc).
-
@carlquintanilla
Carl Quintanilla
on x
“I wish the [Twitter] board would not have forced the sale,” Dorsey said, “I think [Elon] should have walked away ..” Responding to a post in which a user said “It's pretty sad how it all went down,” Dorsey replied simply: “Yes.” @washingtonpost https://www.washingtonpost.com/ …
-
@goldman
Jason Goldman
on x
This argument is that in April 2022 Elon was the best solution for taking the company private as it could not succeed publicly. And then, almost immediately Elon was revealed to not be the best solution and should've been allowed to walk. And then everything would've been fine. h…
-
@riptari
Natasha
on x
Captain Hindsight walks among us https://twitter.com/...
-
@techinsider
@techinsider
on x
Jack Dorsey once called Elon Musk the ‘singular solution’ for taking Twitter private. Now, the app's co-founder says Musk never should have bought it: ‘I think he should have walked away’ https://www.businessinsider.com/ ...
-
@faizsays
Faiz Siddiqui
on x
Jack Dorsey says Elon Musk shouldn't have bought Twitter A year ago, @jack called Musk “the singular solution I trust” to steer the company forward. “I trust his mission to extend the light of consciousness.” Now: “It all went south.” https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ... w/ @WillO…
-
@banquodyar
@banquodyar
on x
According to Jack Dorsey, Elon Musk was a better choice for owner of twitter than a hedge fund because Elon Musk shares his hair-brained idea that humans should live on Mars. Tech billionaires was a bad idea.
-
@mcwm
Mike Murphy
on x
the mental gymnastics here... I am too tired https://twitter.com/...
-
@benjamingoggin
Ben Goggin
on x
Jack Dorsey is an open book tonight on Bluesky... talking about Elon, his last months at Twitter, and fighting with other users Im sort of obsessed https://twitter.com/...
-
@sarahfrier
Sarah Frier
on x
“It all went south,” Jack Dorsey says about Elon Musk's Twitter purchase, on Bluesky https://twitter.com/...
-
@snurb_dot_info
Axel Bruns
on x
🧐 It's almost as if Jack Dorsey isn't some kind of social media genius, but just a random tech-bro who simply got lucky that one time but still doesn't have a clue why... <feigns shock> https://twitter.com/...
-
@willoremus
Will Oremus
on x
We wrote about jack's skeets https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...