With Congress divided over passing a national privacy law, tech industry groups are lobbying Utah and other states to pass privacy laws weaker than California's
The tech industry is lobbying statehouses across the country to pass privacy bills that critics call weak.
Context & Ripple Effects
This story is the latest turn in a strategy the industry has run since 2018, when tech companies first lobbied for a federal privacy law that would overrule California's because state frameworks were seen as the major threat. With Congress still divided over a national law — even as Capitol Hill negotiations reportedly weigh limits on how giants collect and store personal data — the battleground has shifted to statehouses.
The Markup had already documented Facebook, Apple and Google lobbying in Connecticut, Texas and other states crafting consumer privacy bills; now industry groups are pushing Utah and others toward bills critics call weaker than California's. By early 2024, legislators and privacy experts detailed how far that watering-down effort had gone as 13 US states enacted privacy laws — while frustrated advocates counter-mobilized at the state level in Illinois and New York.
First-order effects
- Utah and other legislatures considering industry-backed bills face pressure to adopt weaker standards than California's, directly shaping what data rights their residents get right now.
- Companies operating nationally gain a patchwork tilted in their favor: every weak state law passed reduces the chance that California-style rules become the de facto national baseline.
Second-order effects
- Privacy advocates' state-level push in Illinois and New York becomes a counter-lobbying race, forcing both sides to spend across dozens of legislatures instead of concentrating on one federal bill.
- A fragmented map of strong-versus-weak state laws raises compliance complexity for Facebook, Google, Apple and peers — an outcome that paradoxically strengthens their case for the federal preemption they have sought since 2018.
Third-order effects
- If the pattern holds, US privacy regulation consolidates into two tiers — California-led strong states versus industry-shaped weak ones — with the scope of any eventual federal law determined by which tier has more members when Congress finally acts.
- Statehouses become the durable venue for data-privacy policy in the US, shifting lobbying budgets and advocacy infrastructure permanently from Washington to fifty capitals.
The trend: With federal privacy legislation stalled, US data-privacy regulation is being written state-by-state, with industry and advocates fighting to set the template in individual capitols.