Apple and Google's privacy-focused contact tracing APIs could impose limitations on the UK NHS's planned app, allowing only a limited version of contact tracing
Tech firms place limitations on how tracing apps may work in effort to protect users' privacy
The Guardian Alex Hern
Related Coverage
- Coronavirus: NHS contact tracing app to target 80% of smartphone users BBC · Leo Kelion
- Apple and Google in ‘Standoff’ With UK Health Service Over COVID-19 Contact Tracing App MacRumors · Tim Hardwick
- UK's NHS clashes with Google and Apple over contact tracing iMore · Stephen Warwick
- ACLU has concerns with Apple-Google's COVID-19 contact-tracing plan MacDailyNews
- EU warns no compromise on privacy as NHS clashes with tech firms on contact tracing ComputerWeekly.com · Joe O'Halloran
- Apple and Google in standoff with NHS over contact tracing Cult of Mac · Buster Hein
- Apple, Google reportedly at odds with UK NHS over centralized contact tracing AppleInsider · Mike Peterson
- Bluetooth-based coronavirus contact tracing finds broad support Axios · Ina Fried
- Coronavirus: German and Australian tracing apps ‘ready in weeks’ BBC
- Majority in UK support use of mobile phones for coronavirus contact tracing Financial Times · Helen Warrell
- ACLU gives Apple/Google coronavirus contact tracing API a mixed reception 9to5Mac · Ben Lovejoy
- The EU has published draft rules for how contact tracing apps should work Pocket-lint · Max Freeman-Mills
- Europe Publishes Contact-Tracing App Guidelines Computer Business Review · Conor Reynolds
Discussion
-
@breditor
Brett Winterford
on x
This likely played out as follows: Governments pressured Apple and Google to allow apps like TraceTogether to run in the background. Apple/Google engineered a privacy-preserving way to do it that doesn't allow for central storage/analysis of data. (1/3) https://www.theguardian.co…
-
@jamesrbuk
James Ball
on x
Contact tracing apps which aren't also enormously invasive (and this huge privacy and hacking/security risks) are HARD. Apple and Google are trying to engineer-in safeguards that the NHS approach doesn't have. The result? A bit of a stand-off. https://twitter.com/...
-
@jsphctrl
Joseph Cotterill
on x
Curious about the emphasis in British debate on apps for contact tracing. In South Africa, where tracing was a priority from the start, it means lots of grassroots health workers and phone surveillance under special judicial review. https://www.theguardian.com/ ...
-
@jimwaterson
Jim Waterson
on x
The proposed design for the NHS app to get us out of the pandemic isn't compatible with privacy controls put in place by Apple and Google. In a battle between the UK government and the US tech companies, I know who I'd put my money on. https://www.theguardian.com/ ...
-
@tomhfh
Tom Harwood
on x
This proposal seems very sensible from Apple & Google - defending users from what could easily be twisted into an authoritarian tool of mass surveillance. Whilst no doubt UK Govt proposal was well intentioned, the consequences of it don't appear to have been well thought though. …
-
@alexhern
Hern
on x
I simply can't see the NHS winning this standoff. Or, rather, I can see the NHS *ignoring* this standoff, and releasing a Singapore-style app that receives limited uptake and delivers even worse data, but I hope that doesn't happen https://www.theguardian.com/ ...
-
Vox
Sara Morrison
on x
Apple and Google look like problematic heroes in the pandemic
-
@jefflee2020
Jeff Lee
on x
Apple and Google debut Bluetooth-based contact-tracing platform to combat Covid-19...and end privacy? — RT World News https://www.rt.com/... @catoletters Add Bill Gates force vaccinations and public will become 100% Corp slaves. NWO rolling out into effect.
-
@stshank
Stephen Shankland
on x
Apple and Google: here's our joint work to create privacy-sensitive coronavirus contact tracing technology. Singapore: LOL https://www.cnet.com/... From @alfredwkng
-
@mattgreenfield
Matthew Greenfield
on x
Apple and Google will make tracking technology to fight coronavirus. The ACLU has privacy concerns, but I have concerns about people dying of Covid-19 if we don't do this. https://www.vox.com/...
-
@scheufele
Dietram A. Scheufele
on x
EU lawmakers outline criteria for #COVID19 #ContactTracing apps: voluntary; approved by national health authorities; private data is securely encrypted; dismantled when no longer needed https://techcrunch.com/... #scicomm #scipol #CivilRights
-
@benlovejoy
@benlovejoy
on x
Unfortunately, the EU appears to be moving very slowly here. Just adopt the Apple/Google API and create a single EU app that can be localised for each country ... https://twitter.com/...
-
@carnage4life
Dare Obasanjo
on x
EU guidelines for #COVID19 contact tracing apps * voluntary * approved by the national health authority * privacy-preserving * dismantled after the crisis Evidence from Singapore is apps need 60-75% adoption to be effective. Maybe Apple should pull a U2? https://techcrunch.com/..…