Interview with Google execs about Project Soli, the tech behind Pixel 4's Motion Sense radar, and why they think gesture-sensing is more than just a gimmick
Why does a phone need radar? — By now, you've heard: the new Google Pixel 4 has a tiny radar chip inside it, which allows you to swipe or wave your hand to do a few things.
The Verge Dieter Bohn
Related Coverage
- Start Up No.1,167: Twitter warns Trump (subtly), WeWork squeezes Meetup, Google Pixel 4 kills Daydream, and more The Overspill · Charlesarthur
- Google Pixel 4 and 4 XL hands-on: More cameras, more ambition Engadget · Chris Velazco
- Google Pixel 4 Motion Sense explained: What it can (and can't) do for now Android Authority · C. Scott Brown
- Google chief: I'd disclose smart speakers before guests enter my home BBC · Leo Kelion
- The Oppo Reno 2's quad camera array takes photos like no other at this price Digital Trends · Andy Boxall
- Are you buying a Pixel 4 or Pixel 4 XL? [Poll] 9to5Google · Ben Schoon
- How to trade in your old Pixel phone The Verge · Cameron Faulkner
- The Reason Your Photos Are About to Get a Lot Better New York Times · Brian X. Chen
- Pixel 4 will use ‘Frequent Faces’ to focus on people you often photograph Android Police · Rita El Khoury
- Google Pixel Buds 2 hands-on review: All about the assistant Digital Trends · Corey Gaskin
- Pre-order the Google Pixel 4 and get a free $100 Amazon gift card Mashable · Leah Stodart
- Google's Most Interesting Hardware Announcements, Ranked OneZero · Will Oremus
- Google's Pixel 4 and 4 XL are available with FREE $100 gift cards at Amazon 9to5Toys · Patrick Campanale
- The Pixel 4 Kills the Best Google Perk Tom's Guide · Philip Michaels
- Google Pixel 4 and Pixel 4 XL Hands-On Roundup: Updated Camera, Motion Sense, and Face Unlock Android Beat · Mahit Huilgol
- Google's aggressive ‘ambient computing’ strategy means it wants to be everywhere CNBC · Jennifer Elias
- Your Google Daydream VR Headset Is Now A Collector's Item Android Headlines · Daniel Fuller
- Google Daydream is finally going to sleep Android Authority · John Callaham
- Google improves the Pixel 4 camera with Live HDR and more The Verge · Dami Lee
- Google Pixel vs. Samsung Galaxy: Which is better for business? TechRepublic · James Sanders
- Google Pixel 4, and 4 XL not coming to India, and this is why Gizchina · Ige Ebima
- Pixel 4 is here to help — With a camera that captures detail … The Keyword · Brian Rakowski
- Innoventions wins patent on skin-based virtual touchpad for wearables VentureBeat · Jeremy Horwitz
- With the Pixel 4, Google's smartphones have to grow up Android Police · David Ruddock
- Google won't sell its Pixel 4 smartphone in India CNN · Rishi Iyengar
- The Pixel 4 Is Redefining the ‘Smart’ in Smartphone Gizmodo · Sam Rutherford
- News Get the Pixel 4 “on Us” at T-Mobile: The Latest Lineup of Google Flagships Head to the Un-carrier T-Mobile
- The Pixel 4 is the first phone with radar. Here's what that really means CNET · Jessica Dolcourt
- Pixel 4 hands-on—Thumbs up for 90Hz, thumbs down for Project Soli Ars Technica · Ron Amadeo
- Pixel 3, Pixel 3a Lineup Confirmed to Get Updated Night Sight Camera Mode Droid Life · Tim
- Google is bringing the Pixel 4's improved Night Sight to the Pixel 3 and 3a Android Central · Chris Wedel
- Google Pixel 4: A 2,800mAh battery? Android Authority · Tristan Rayner
- The Pixel 4 has the same problem as the Pixel 3: It's too expensive PCWorld · Michael Simon
- The real reason Apple and Google still hold big launch events Fast Company
- Google App 10.74.6 hints at the Pixel 4's new Assistant coming to Canada, the UK, and Singapore XDA Developers · Pranob Mehrotra
- All the highlighting camera features on the Google Pixel 4 Technology Personalized · Yash Wate
- When did Google become stingy like Apple? Mashable · Stan Schroeder
- Pixel 3 and Pixel 3A receive interesting features of Pixel 4 Gizchina · Abdullah
- Google Pixel 3 series to get Pixel 4's improved night sight via an update BGR India
- Google Pixel 4 Vs. iPhone 11: Google Is Packing Four Innovations On A Single Device International Business Times · Erwin Castro
- The second generation of Google Assistant is faster and smarter than ever BetaNews · Mark Wyciślik-Wilson
- Google Pixel 4 hands-on: Once again, it's about features, not design PCWorld · Michael Simon
- Pixel 4's astrophotography mode will be coming to older Pixel devices Phandroid · Tyler Lee
- Google Pixel 4/XL is BOGO FREE at Verizon, plus additional $200 gift card 9to5Toys · Trevor Daugherty
- Pixel 4 and Pixel 4 XL are now available at Verizon Verizon Fios & Custom TV
- Pixel 4 hands-on: I almost wish I didn't like it this much The Next Web · Napier Lopez
- [Update: Not new] Google Pixel 4 can automatically install updates overnight 9to5Google · Ben Schoon
- Google kills Daydream with a lack of support on the Google Pixel 4 Digital Trends · Christian de Looper
- Google Pixel 4, 4XL Available October 16 AT&T
- Google Reveals New Pixel Buds, Pixel 4 Phone, Gaming System and More NBC Bay Area · Cristina Corujo
- Google just laid out its vision for the future of the smartphone with its new Pixel 4 … Business Insider · Lisa Eadicicco
- Pixel 3 & Pixel 3a Will Get New & Improved Night Sight Feature Android Headlines · Justin Diaz
- Where Google's Pixel 4 and Apple's iPhone 11 fail ZDNet · Adrian Kingsley-Hughes
- Google Pixel 4 and Google Pixel 4 XL Hands-On Impressions IGN · Kevin Lee
- Google's new voice recorder app transcribes in real time, even when offline TechCrunch · Sarah Perez
- Google Pixel 4 XL Preview Thurrott · Paul Thurrott
- Google shows Motion Sense gestures in action on the Pixel 4 Engadget · Nick Summers
- If it has audio, now it can have captions The Keyword · Brian Kemler
- Live Caption is a Pixel 4 exclusive at launch, will come to Pixel 3 and 3a in December Android Police · Rita El Khoury
- Google rolls out real-time captioning starting with Pixel 4 Engadget · Kris Holt
- Google Brings Automatic Captioning System to Pixel 4 Thurrott · Paul Thurrott
- Live Caption, Google's automatic captioning technology, is now available on Pixel 4 TechCrunch · Sarah Perez
- Everything announced at the Made by Google 2019 event VentureBeat · Paul Sawers
- Live Caption automatic captioning system now available on Pixel 4 devices MSPoweruser · Pradeep
- Google Pixel Event's Biggest Announcements International Business Times · Nica Osorio
- Google Launches New Recorder App with Advanced Speech Recognition Capacity Social Media Today · Andrew Hutchinson
- The Pixel 4 Comes With ‘Live Caption’ Feature For Videos Android Headlines · Justin Diaz
- Pixel 4 Live Caption will come to Pixel 3 and 3a soon SlashGear · JC Torres
- Google Pixel 4's Live Caption feature to soon come to Pixel 3, Pixel 3a phones Firstpost Tech
- Pixel 4's Live Caption feature coming to Pixel 3 and 3a in December Android Central · Nicholas Sutrich
- The Pixel 4's Gestures Might Be a Gimmick—But At Least They Actually Work Gizmodo · Victoria Song
- Google's voice AI resonates in new Pixel Recorder app Search Engine Land · George Nguyen
- Hands off our phones, says Google: Radar-gesture-sensing Pixel 4 just $999 with a 3-year lifespan - great value! The Register · Thomas Claburn
- Say goodbye to Google's Daydream VR experiment CNET · Ian Sherr
- Google Announces New Products For Smart Home Innovation PYMNTS.com
- Google's truly wireless Pixel Buds launch next spring for $179 TechSpot · Shawn Knight
- Google's Pixel 4 and Pixel 4 XL Are the First Phones with Built-In Radar Geek.com · Lee Mathews
- Google's new Pixel Buds are coming spring 2020 for $179 The Verge · Dani Deahl
- Without unlimited original quality photo backups, a 64GB Pixel 4 is ridiculous Android Authority · C. Scott Brown
- Daydream isn't the only Google casualty, as Google Clips seemingly killed too Android Authority · Hadlee Simons
- Phone-based VR is officially over The Verge · Adi Robertson
- Google Ships Pixel 4 Without Daydream VR Support, Stops Selling Daydream Viewer Variety · Janko Roettgers
- Google's Daydream VR experiment is over Engadget · Kris Holt
- Google abandons its phone-powered virtual reality headset Daydream, admitting almost no-one used it Business Insider · Rob Price
- Google pulls first-gen Pixel Buds, Daydream View, and Google Clips from its Store Android Police · Cody English
- The (Day)dream is over: Phone-based VR is well and truly dead Yahoo Finance · Nicole Lee
- On the same day it announced the Stadia launch date, Google killed VR tech Daydream VG247 · Sherif Saed
- RIP Google Daydream View, Pixel Buds (1st-Gen), and Google Clips Droid Life · Tim
- Google Kills Daydream VR Phone Scoop · Rich Brome
- Made by Google, made to help The Keyword · Rick Osterloh
- Top Shot will be available for short videos on the Pixel 4, 3, and 3a Android Police · Rita El Khoury
- Google Daydream VR is dead, kaput, it has ceased to be Pocket-lint · Rik Henderson
- Google's Daydream VR project is no longer a reality The Next Web · Ivan Mehta
- Pixel 4 vs iPhone 11: tech specs compared ZDNet · Adrian Kingsley-Hughes
- Google Pixel 4 pre-orders come with free Chromebooks through Mobiles.co.uk Mashable · Joseph Green
- Pixel 4 hands-on: Quickly maturing into one of the best smartphones [Video] 9to5Google · Ben Schoon
- Google Daydream View VR headset has officially been discontinued SlashGear · Brittany A. Roston
- Google Discontinues Daydream View Headset, the Final Nail in the Coffin for its Android VR Ambitions Road to VR · Ben Lang
- Google is killing Daydream VR Android Central · Muhammad Jarir Kanji
- Google is putting an end to its Daydream VR platform TechSpot · Cohen Coberly
- Hands On With The Google Pixel Buds Android Headlines · Alexander Maxham
- Pixel 4 and 4 XL hands-on: Motion Sense and improved Night Sight make this the phone of the future CNET · Patrick Holland
- Google quietly discontinues Daydream VR XDA Developers · Joe Fedewa
- Google Pixel Buds put Google Assistant in your ear without looking weird TalkAndroid.com · Jared Peters
Discussion
-
@google
@google
on x
Motion Sense helps you get things done on your #pixel4 without touching it. Swipe to skip a song, silence a call with a flick of your hand, and unlock your phone super fast with face unlock. #madebygoogle pic.twitter.com/HAIBtBUsxE
-
@reckless
Nilay Patel
on x
My quick hands-on with the new Pixel Buds — just the hardware though, the demo units here don't work yet. Seems like a solid AirPods competitor but nothing makes me sad like platform-specific features. And not out until spring. (Video incoming) https://www.theverge.com/...
-
@mikesparandara
Mike Sparandara
on x
🚀🎧 Launch day is the best day. So many great things coming out from @madebygoogle today, but I'm particularly proud of the design and research work that has gone into the new Pixel Buds. We've been seriously sweating every detail. https://www.blog.google/...
-
@tomwarren
Tom Warren
on x
Here's a closer look at the Pixel 4 camera vs. Apple's iPhone 11 Pro. Plenty of sample photos in here, but you'll have to wait for the full review for much more. Details here: https://www.theverge.com/... https://twitter.com/...
-
@gregorymcfadden
Gregory McFadden
on x
Some of the first pictures putting Pixel 4 against the iPhone 11! The competition is getting fierce! Can't wait to do my own comparisons. https://twitter.com/...
-
@dylanljmartin
Dylan Martin
on x
Hopefully @Google has fixed the reliability of its camera in general. My Pixel 3 camera has had a stuttering problem for a while that sounds hardware-related (others have reported similar problems). Too bad, because when it works, it works really well. https://twitter.com/...
-
@stshank
Stephen Shankland
on x
But there's more that he & Pixel camera product manager Isaac Reynolds told me: The Pixel 4 now calculates portrait mode iamgery on *raw* data, not the processed JPEG. That means bokeh looks better with point sources of light behind the subject. 3/
-
@stshank
Stephen Shankland
on x
Also, Pixel 4 will write depth map data into all files (if you enable the option), which in principle lets you edit based on 3D scene data, e.g. brighten the foreground only. @Lightroom lets you edit iPhone photos this way already today. 4/
-
@stshank
Stephen Shankland
on x
I interviewed @marclevoy about Google's computational photography tricks in the Pixel 4. Here's our exclusive look at the new portrait mode and more. Pixel 4 is the first camera to see in stereo with 2 baselines (dual-pixel sensor + dual cameras). 1/thread https://www.cnet.com/..…
-
@stshank
Stephen Shankland
on x
My favorite moment on stage was @marclevoy tweak at Apple for the “mad science” line about computational photography. Apple followed Google's HDR+ approach, which blends up to 9 underexposed shots for better dynamic range. 5/
-
@stshank
Stephen Shankland
on x
Some computational features Levoy mentioned on stage: better Super Res Zoom, Live HDR+ so you can trust the phone's exposure choice better, astrophotography, dual highlight/shadow exposure controls. #madebygoogle 2/
-
@stshank
Stephen Shankland
on x
Levoy's jab came as he explained Pixel's HDR+ math about reducing image noise: “The noise goes down as the square root of the number of photos you average together. With nine images, you get a third as much noise. It's not mad science, it's just simple physics.” 6/
-
@scriptedpixels
@scriptedpixels
on x
Probably because that Radar shit is gonna be used for some crazy privacy invasive tracking for Google later on ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ https://twitter.com/...
-
@_am1t
Amit Gawande
on x
Google is slowly, but surely killing every reason people loved the devices from Google. It started with price. Then with copying everything that was wrong with Apple (uhmm.. headphone jack). And now this. No mocking Apple in ads on storage this time then? #madebygoogle https://tw…
-
@sub8u
Subrahmanyam Kvj
on x
Says a lot about Google's interest in hardware. https://twitter.com/...
-
@chriswelch
Chris Welch
on x
One of the best perks that came with buying a flagship Pixel phone is no more. https://www.theverge.com/...
-
@google
@google
on x
#NightSight already helps you take beautiful photos in the dark. Now you can use it for shots of the night sky.🌙✨ Coming to Pixel 3a and Pixel 3 as well as #pixel4. #madebygoogle pic.twitter.com/o4bORnPc6j
-
@google
@google
on x
The new Recorder app uses speech recognition and AI to transcribe lectures, meetings, interviews and more—and makes them easy for you to find later. (English only right now, with more languages to come.) #madebygoogle pic.twitter.com/fdKRItuS4b
-
@mkbhd
Marques Brownlee
on x
On stage: “While ultrawide is fun, we feel telephoto is more useful” .... I feel personally attacked
-
@mkbhd
Marques Brownlee
on x
Pixel 4 Snapdragon 855 6GB RAM 3200x1800 90Hz display Black/White/Orange Dual cameras - NO ULTRAWIDE Radar sensors for faster face unlock Improved Google Assistant Shipping October 24th Starting at $799/$899 for 4/4XL pic.twitter.com/fbIIIKGVL4
-
@leostatic
@leostatic
on x
I have been staying loyal to Android and Pixel so far but with Google deciding to skip Pixel 4 launch in India, it's time to switch to iPhone. And once you get sucked into that ecosystem, well, it's a point of no return. 👏 Google. Sigh https://techcrunch.com/...
-
@themaholupper
Ali
on x
Quick notes: 1. Pixel4 images consistently lowering exposure to avoid highlight blowout, iPhone more willing to overexpose them to brighten up image overall 2. iPhone pictures consistently warmer & more saturated than Pixel 3. iPhone detail in SOME instances more than Pixel https…
-
@theworkofjar
@theworkofjar
on x
how does it feel knowing that you've invested thousands of dollars in camera gear only to be replaced by a phone https://twitter.com/...
-
@snubs
@snubs
on x
“software defined camera” makes me think about SDR, or software defined radio. It makes a lot of sense, actually, to use that terminology. https://twitter.com/...
-
@google
@google
on x
With a great camera, the new Google Assistant built in, and Motion Sense, #pixel4 is designed to be helpful throughout your day. Bonus: it gets better with every update → http://goo.gle/2VGZRE9 #madebygoogle pic.twitter.com/b2pRzczOza
-
@sievertmike
Mike Sievert
on x
The next best thing to being in space 🛰 is being able to take the best #Astrophotos of space! I guess this view will do for now😉 #Pixel4 https://www.t-mobile.com/... https://twitter.com/...
-
@_namrataa
@_namrataa
on x
From making phones that have good cameras, google and Apple seem to have switched to making good cameras that are also phones! https://twitter.com/...
-
@alexdobie
Alex Dobie
on x
Underappreciated Pixel 4 feature: Unless you're an utter madman and buy the (glossy) black version, the matte finish on both the sides and back make this the *least* fingerprinty phone I've used in years. https://twitter.com/...
-
@reckless
Nilay Patel
on x
Very early Pixel 4 vs iPhone 11 photo comparisons — seems like the iPhone produces more detail but the Pixel's colors and contrast are still very distinct. https://www.theverge.com/...
-
@stshank
Stephen Shankland
on x
Dumping the notch took #courage (though presumably @madebygoogle didn't have room with all the new sensors). The single best thing about motion sense radar is faster face unlock IMO. I look forward to a better screen, but of course the camera is the top item on my list. https://t…
-
@backlon
Dieter Bohn
on x
I got a chance to spend an hour talking about Project Soli (aka Motion Sense) and what Google's reasoning was for including it — and what it could turn into in the future. https://www.theverge.com/... https://twitter.com/...
-
@harrymccracken
Harry McCracken
on x
The Pixel 4's new auto-transcribing voice recorder looks like a killer app for journalists, and bad news for the companies that want us to pay for transcriptions. pic.twitter.com/la9GQh7kw0
-
@supersaf
Safwan AhmedMia
on x
Pixel 4 has big emphasis on cameras as expected but no Ultra-wide 😕 I'm super excited for proper Telephoto Portraits (you guys know I love my 50mm equivalent Portraits) but come on, the competition have all 3 cameras (Primary, Telephoto and Ultra-wide) pic.twitter.com/JURjkTKL9…
-
@reckless
Nilay Patel
on x
Google running down the list of Pixel 4 camera features: “And a flash that we hope you'll use mostly as a flashlight.” I'm dying.
-
@backlon
Dieter Bohn
on x
Pixel 4 and 4 XL hands-on time. Google is doing more with the Pixel than it ever has before: high refresh rate screen, new Assistant, face unlock, and radar. That's four things — plus a new design and hopefully the camera is good. It's a lot! https://www.theverge.com/... https://…
-
@thurrott
Paul Thurrott
on x
Google: It's cute that others have picked up night sight features. We can take photos of galaxies now. Suck it, Apple.
-
@rogerwcheng
Roger Cheng
on x
Google throwing some shade on Apple's wide-angle camera lens. “While wide angle can be fun, we think telephoto is more important.” To be fair, the iPhone has had a telephoto lens for a while. The Pixel 4 finally gets one #madebygoogle
-
@chillmage
@chillmage
on x
“we're doing better on hair and dog fur” is exactly the kind of extremely incremental update I crave in a major tech keynote
-
@thekenyeung
Ken Yeung
on x
Pixel 4 camera: telephoto capabilities (don't crop, pinch-to-zoom and take photo), live HDR+ (signature look while composing photo in real-time), dual-exposure controls for HDR, white balancing (truer colors in tricky lighting), portrait mode (SLR bokeh) #madebygoogle
-
@redletterdave
Dave S. Pumpkins
on x
Google Assistant is super advanced, but talking to your phone out loud is still incredibly obnoxious. Just type silently like the rest of us please
-
@thurrott
Paul Thurrott
on x
I wonder what Assistant usage really is on phone. I bet it's low. They're really pushing this.
-
@acvollers
Anna Claire Vollers
on x
Pleasepleasepleaseplease make this an app for iPhones. Pleeeeeeease https://twitter.com/...
-
@caseynewton
Casey Newton
on x
Pls bring this to iOS immediately, thank you https://twitter.com/...
-
@deliprao
Delip Rao
on x
On device ASR from Google. Do we know what's the WER for this product? https://twitter.com/...
-
@davidmarcus
David Marcus
on x
Very excited about this. 👏🏼 @Google https://twitter.com/...
-
@345triangle
Sam Byford
on x
i wish both i and my interview subjects spoke in flawless american accents so i could be excited for this, because it would be cool in that scenario. in any other i am sceptical https://www.theverge.com/...
-
@panzer
Matthew Panzarino
on x
Google sherlocks Rev and Otter (both of which we use and are really good). Good thing google will ship a teeny amount of these pixels, comparatively. But have to imagine this is a table stakes feature now. https://twitter.com/...
-
@tsuvik
Vikas SN
on x
Really hope that Google releases this app as a standalone app as well https://twitter.com/... https://twitter.com/...
-
@epro
Emil Protalinski
on x
Google killed its Daydream VR platform today: - Pixel 4 and Pixel 4 XL do not support Daydream - Google stopped selling the Daydream View headset - Google has stopped certifying Android devices for Daydream https://venturebeat.com/...
-
@benedictevans
Benedict Evans
on x
Google's Daydream is gone. Follows Samsung's GearVR. Lots of good work here (the VR store was lovely). But. https://www.engadget.com/...
-
@nisummers
Nick Summers
on x
Google admits that Daydream is dead. Pixel 4 won't support the VR platform and the Daydream View is no longer being sold. “Over time we noticed some clear limitations constraining smartphone VR from being a viable long-term solution.” https://www.engadget.com/...
-
@chr1sa
Chris Anderson
on x
Another nail in the coffin of consumer VR. I'm still cautiously optimistic about commercial AR and VR arcades (a fun visit, not ownership) may survive as a niche. But first 3D TV and now this — the marketplace has spoken about isolating glasses/headsets https://www.engadget.com/.…