Court filing: OpenAI seeks to block a May 13 order requiring it to save all ChatGPT user logs, including deleted chats, “to protect its users' data and privacy”
OpenAI is now fighting a court order to preserve all ChatGPT user logs—including deleted chats and sensitive chats logged through …
Ars TechnicaAshley Belanger
Context & Ripple Effects
The dispute sits in The New York Times copyright case, where OpenAI’s challenge to indefinite retention of ChatGPT material was also covered as an appeal over a conflict with user-privacy commitments. The central tension is not merely discovery volume: it is whether conversations users delete can be held for litigation.
Later filings sharpened the evidentiary stakes: the Times sought access to a far larger set of chats to test alleged article regurgitation, while OpenAI had offered a smaller production. That makes the preservation fight an early boundary-setting contest over a user-chat corpus sought for output analysis.
First-order effects
OpenAI must devote immediate legal and data-governance attention to overturning or narrowing the preservation order; if it remains in force, deleted and sensitive ChatGPT logs would be retained rather than handled solely under its ordinary privacy commitments.
The Times’ ability to examine alleged output regurgitation depends on access to a preserved, reviewable chat corpus, increasing pressure on OpenAI to define anonymization and production limits rather than simply retain data.
Other consumer-AI providers face a clearer operational precedent: privacy-facing deletion controls may need distinct legal-hold procedures when user conversations become potentially relevant evidence.
Third-order effects
If courts increasingly require broad retention of AI conversations in content disputes, chat logs could become a governed litigation corpus whose access, anonymization, and deletion rules are negotiated alongside model behavior claims.
The durable policy question is whether consumer AI services can make meaningful deletion promises while meeting expansive discovery obligations; the answer will shape trust and compliance design across the sector.
The trend: Generative-AI copyright litigation is turning user-conversation retention into a core governance issue, linking model-output evidence with consumer privacy controls.
i do not know what the judge is thinking — zero evidence that users are deleting chat logs to avoid copyright enforcement — yet, many local and international privacy laws are being violated. not to mention contracts & privacy policies — arstechnica.com/tech-policy/ ...
@markriedl
Mark Riedl on bluesky
Judge orders OpenAI to retain all ChatGPT logs, including deleted chats arstechnica.com/tech-policy/ ... This is in the context of NYT vs OpenAI. However, AI companies, like social media companies, are on the frontier of law enforcement.
@askbillmitchell
Bill Mitchell on bluesky
Apparently my link did save the first time: — Finally, copyright ownership rights of copyright holders are pushing up against privacy rights of everyone else. While this doesn't fall square on all copyright owners, it does effect those who had nothing to do with model training…
@badinternet.oracularhades.com
@badinternet.oracularhades.com on bluesky
This is insane. Shame on the New York Times for being involved in this. You'd think journalists would have an interest in privacy 🤷♂️ arstechnica.com/tech-policy/ ... [embedded post]
@kepano
@kepano on x
OpenAI is now required by court order to preserve all ChatGPT logs including “temporary chats” and API requests that would have been deleted if I understand this correctly, it means data retention policies for apps that use OpenAI API simply cannot be honored [image]
@deadalnix
@deadalnix on x
Your LLM will be local or you'll live in a dystopia. There is no in between.
@fonnesbaek
Rasmus Fonnesbæk on x
This is insane — and could make it impossible for any high-stakes organizations to use LLMs. OpenAI is similar to Microsoft, Google (Cloud, Gmail), AWS, DropBox, etc. — these services only work with the right data policies (... and yes, the CLOUD Act Also stinks here).
@mrchrisellis
Chris Ellis on x
Put all your confessions on to other peoples computers all around the world so that future archaeologists have a clear record of all your dirty secrets.
@elomaur
@elomaur on x
anyone treating llms as a some sort of personal therapist might want to reconsider
@kepano
@kepano on x
this is why terms and policies are not self-guaranteeing. a self-guaranteeing promise about privacy gives you proof that the tool cannot access your data in the first place https://x.com/...
@aarushsah_
Aarush Sah on x
At Groq, we have a zero data retention policy. the prompts you send to LLMs on our platform disappear from our systems the moment your API request returns an output. If you'd like to use LLMs and make sure your data is private, use @GroqInc.
r/technology
r on reddit
OpenAI slams court order to save all ChatGPT logs, including deleted chats
r/LocalLLaMA
r on reddit
After court order, OpenAI is now preserving all ChatGPT and API logs
r/privacy
r on reddit
OpenAI slams court order to save all ChatGPT logs, including deleted chats
r/OpenAI
r on reddit
OpenAI slams court order to save all ChatGPT logs, including deleted chats
r/artificial
r on reddit
OpenAI slams court order to save all ChatGPT logs, including deleted chats