A coalition of newspapers, writers, movie producers, and others rejects UK's plans to create a copyright exemption for AI companies to train their models
Exclusive: Coalition of musicians, photographers and newspapers insist existing copyright laws must be respected
The GuardianRobert Booth
Context & Ripple Effects
The proposal arrives after the UK had already shelved earlier AI-training copyright rules when artists and technology groups could not agree. This broader coalition makes the dispute less a single-sector complaint and more a contest over whether existing copyright permissions should govern model inputs.
The conflict persisted: musicians later staged a collective silent-album protest, and the government ultimately withdrew the opt-out proposal. The arc shows how difficult it is to create a training exception acceptable to both creative-rights holders and AI developers.
First-order effects
Newspapers, writers, producers, musicians and photographers are publicly aligned against a copyright exception, increasing pressure on UK policymakers to preserve permission-based use of protected works.
AI companies seeking a broad training exemption face a more contested policy environment, while rights holders reinforce their claim that existing copyright rules apply.
Second-order effects
A coordinated cross-media stance strengthens creators’ leverage in any licensing or consultation process, rather than leaving AI training terms to separate negotiations by sector.
Model developers may need to plan for more fragmented access to high-value content if policy does not provide a clear exception, raising the importance of rights-clearance arrangements.
Third-order effects
If this pattern holds, AI training policy will increasingly be shaped by organized rights holders’ bargaining power, with licensing and provenance becoming central market infrastructure rather than peripheral compliance issues.
The eventual withdrawal of the opt-out approach suggests that durable rules will require political legitimacy across creative industries as well as technical feasibility for model builders.
The trend: This is one instance of AI content commercialization: creators are pushing to convert training-data access from an assumed input into a negotiated, accountable commercial relationship.
I mean, it would be nice if the people who hold the copyright get to reject the plans to undermine their copyright but that's not usually how it works — and OMG how am I on the same side of *anything* as *mumsnet*?!? ugh ugh [embedded post]
The battle is on over AI crawling - but is it too late? — UK arts and media reject plan to let AI firms use copyrighted material — www.theguardian.com/technology/ 2...
UK Music will engage constructively with the consultation on copyright and Artificial Intelligence. Music is at the heart of the creative industries, which is one of eight identified sectors for growth as part of the government's industrial strategy, and worth over 1/4
I appreciate @RhonddaBryant addressing my concern yesterday, and confirming that the UK government won't upend copyright law without an effective rights reservation (i.e. opt-out) system actually existing. But the problems with opt-out schemes cannot just be solved by putting [vi…
I've started reading the UK Government's consultation on copyright and AI. It's striking that it frames copyright as a purely economic right, ignoring the myriad other reasons why people might want to have visibility and control over what happens to their work.
Has any PM ever made so many duff decisons in the first few months of their administration? It really does boggle the mind https://www.theguardian.com/ ...
Today, the UK government announced a proposal to change copyright law - for the benefit of AI companies - that would cause huge, irreversible harm to creators. More info below, but most importantly here's what you can do (wherever you live): 1. Email your MP. If you're in the [im…
The UK government AI and Copyright Consultation opens today. We want to hear from a wide range of voices. Respond to the consultation to share your views. [Link]: https://www.gov.uk/... [video]