The EU opens an investigation into X over hosting disinformation tied to Hamas' Israel attack and sends X a formal request for information under the DSA
'In this particular case, the Commission services are investigating X's compliance with the #DSA, including with regard to its policies and practices regarding notices on illegal content, complaint handling, risk assessment and measures to mitigate the risks identified.' … Claes de Vreese / @claesdevreese@mastodon.social : The European Commission is “investigating X's compliance with the DSA, including with regard to its policies and practices regarding notices on illegal content, complaint handling, risk assessment.” — Responses required by the of the month. Late or insufficient answers can lead to penalties. … Bluesky: JimboChill / @jimbochill.bsky.social : Yeah that's like $100 at this point. X: Thierry Breton / @thierrybreton : #TikTok has a particular obligation to protect children & teenagers from violent content & terrorist propaganda —as well as death challenges & potentially life-threatening content. #DSA sets out very clear obligations TikTok must comply with. Letter to TikTok CEO Shou Zi Chew⤵️ [image] Thierry Breton / @thierrybreton : The #DSA is here to protect both freedom of expression & our democracies — including in times of crisis. We have sent @X a formal request for information, a first step in our investigation to determine compliance with the DSA. https://ec.europa.eu/... Věra Jourová / @verajourova : Illegal content and terrorist propaganda has no place in the EU, neither offline nor online. The Commission has a duty to vigorously enforce the #DSA and this formal request for information is a step to fully understand what measures @X is taking to ensure online safety. Glenn Greenwald / @ggreenwald : EU officials continue to directly threaten X (along with other Big Tech platforms) that either they start immediately censoring more political speech that EU officials regard as false or dangerous, or they will suffer severe punishment under the EU's new censorship law: Daphne Keller / @daphnehk : In a way we should be relieved that @ThierryBreton said the quiet part out loud so quickly. Other countries considering emulating the DSA should consider whether they want to hand this same authority to restrict lawful speech to their own governments. 2/ Erin Woo / @erinkwoo : New: The European Commission is investigating X's compliance with the DSA over its content moderation policies. It comes as X has slashed its capabilities for responding to misinformation. Failure to comply could result in fines of up to 6% of X's revenue. https://www.theinformation.com/ ... Preston Byrne / @prestonjbyrne : @ThierryBreton @X The DSA is a censorship and content takedown law. Its sole purpose is to censor content European governments dislike. To tell your constituents that this regime protects “freedom of expression” is the worst kind of Orwellian doublespeak. Daphne Keller / @daphnehk : When the EU tells platforms they have a legal obligation to “mitigate harms,” does that just mean “take down lawful but harmful content”? This letter from @ThierryBreton seems like a big YES. Regulators can tell platforms what legal material to remove. 1/ https://twitter.com/... Ingrid / @ingridlunden : Why does this matter? A formal investigation will give us all a better idea of how ‘X’ is used and abused: since Musk took Twitter private, there is a lot less transparency around it. We use it in a dark tunnel bored by Elon. Matt Taibbi / @mtaibbi : You don't “protect freedom of expression” by allowing unaccountable bureaucrats to mandate removal of content. You have no idea what freedom of expression is. https://www.racket.news/... Daphne Keller / @daphnehk : @ThierryBreton If this letter were really just telling Meta to take down ILLEGAL content, it would have used that word half a dozen more times, instead of saying things like “fake.” 3/3 Jason Kint / @jason_kint : I guess that answers the question of what the enforcement team thought of Team Elon's reply. [image] Scott Nover / @scottnover : As bad as Twitter is at stopping misinformation—the point of my last piece—we should be very worried when governments start deciding what's “misinformation” and what isn't. Lisa O'Carroll / @lisaocarroll : BREAKING: The EU sends 2nd missive to X re alleged “spreading of terrorist and violent content and hate speech” Thierry Breton makes formal demand for fresh info about its ability to comply with new laws. Giving it two deadlines 18 Oct and 31 Oct https://ec.europa.eu/... Forums: r/inthenews : Elon Musk's X faces E.U. probe over handling of Israel-Gaza war
Financial Times Javier Espinoza
Related Coverage
- The Commission sends request for information to X under the Digital Services Act European Commission
- EU turns up the heat on X over illegal content in wake of Israel-Hamas war TechCrunch
- EU probes X over spread of Israel-Gaza disinformation, ‘terrorist’ content The Hill · Rebecca Klar
- EU is formally investigating X over content about the Israel-Hamas war The Verge · Umar Shakir
- Elon Musk's X faces E.U. probe over handling of Israel-Gaza war Washington Post · Cat Zakrzewski
- X faces EU investigation over handling of Israel-Hamas war content Android Headlines · Sumit Adhikari
- EU investigates disinformation on X related to Israel conflict Silicon Republic · Vish Gain
- X under fire over spread of ‘terrorist content and hate speech’ Metro
- European Commission Officially Investigating Elon Musk's Twitter Over Alleged Disinformation Digital Music News · Ashley King
- EU Issues Ultimatum to Social Media Giants Over Israel-Hamas Disinformation The Tech Report · Krishi Chowdhary
- Musk's X Rebuffs Disinfo Claims On Israel Violence International Business Times · Joseph Boyle
- EU Officials Launch Investigation into X Over the Distribution of Misinformation Around the Israel-Hamas War Social Media Today · Andrew Hutchinson
- X Fumbles First Big Musk-Era Test of Content Policies After Israel Attack Wall Street Journal
- Europe is investigating Elon Musk's X about Israel-Hamas misinformation, violence on the app CNBC · Jonathan Vanian
- EU Announces Formal Investigation Into X Just Hours After Linda Yaccarino Details Response To Israel-Hamas Conflict Disinformation Surge Deadline · Melanie Goodfellow
- EU opens probe into X over content on Hamas-Israel conflict BusinessLIVE
- The EU is probing X's response to Israel-Hamas misinformation Engadget · Will Shanklin
- Europe Formally Demands Elon Musk Share His Plan to Get Hamas off X The Messenger · Abram Brown
- EU Commission sends request for information to X / #Twitter under the #DigitalServicesAct. — 'In this particular case, the Commission services are investigating X's compliance with the #DSA, including with regard to its policies and practices regarding notices on illegal content, complaint handling, risk assessment and measures to mitigate the risks identified.' … @AliceStollmeyer@eupolicy.social · Alice Stollmeyer
- EU opens investigation into X over alleged disinformation BBC · James Gregory
- Israel-Hamas war poses early disinformation test for Meta's Threads The Guardian · Nick Robins-Early
- X CEO Yaccarino responds to Israel-Hamas disinformation — but only after coercion from the EU Mashable · Matt Binder
- The EU wants to crack down on misinformation online — but here's why it probably won't work CBC News · Anis Heydari
- After delays, X updates Community Notes fact-checks to improve speed and distribution TechCrunch · Sarah Perez
- TikTok latest firm after X and Meta to be warned by EU over Hamas videos BBC · Tom Gerken
- Hamas Seeds Violent Videos on Sites With Little Moderation New York Times
- Linda Yaccarino Says X/Twitter Has Removed or Labeled ‘Tens of Thousands’ of Israel-Hamas War Posts in Response to EU's Disinformation Warning Variety · Ellise Shafer
- Musk given 24 hours to address graphic images of Hamas attacks Politico · Mark Scott
- A group of 67 X accounts spread coordinated disinformation about Israel-Hamas war, says research group NBC News · Kevin Collier
- EU warns Elon Musk over ‘disinformation’ on X about Hamas attack The Guardian · Lisa O'Carroll
- Germany's anti-discrimination agency quits X over anti-minority posts Reuters
- EU officials warn TikTok over Israel-Hamas disinformation CNN · Brian Fung
- After X and Meta, TikTok now pressed by EU to tackle Hamas content Politico · Clothilde Goujard
- Linda Yaccarino Says X Has ‘Redistributed Resources’ to Combat Misinformation in Response to EU Letter The Wrap · Natalie Korach
- Elon Musk demanded to see evidence of how X is spreading ‘fake content’ on Hamas attacks—now CEO Linda Yaccarino tells Brussels she is working ‘around the clock’ to tackle disinformation Fortune · Christiaan Hetzner
- How Israel-Hamas war disinformation is being spread online The Guardian
- Musk's X has taken down hundreds of Hamas-linked accounts, CEO says Associated Press · Kelvin Chan
- Europe gives Elon Musk 24 hours to respond about Israel-Hamas war misinformation and violence on X, formerly Twitter CNBC · Jonathan Vanian
- X Has Removed Hundreds Of Hamas-Linked Accounts, CEO Linda Yaccarino Tells EU After Threat Of Fines Forbes · Siladitya Ray
- EU launches probe into disinformation campaigns as X says ‘hundreds’ of Hamas-affiliated accounts removed CNN
- Elon Musk's X rebuts EU allegations of ‘illegal’ content about the Israel-Hamas conflict CNBC · Arjun Kharpal
- “There Is No Place on X for Terrorist Organizations”: CEO Responds to EU Warning Over Hamas-Israel Content Hollywood Reporter · Georg Szalai
- X defends itself over EU accusations of playing host to Israel-Hamas disinformation The Verge · Jon Porter
- Linda Yaccarino responds to EU: 700 Community Notes, 5K+ images shared on Israel-Hamas war, “thousands” of pieces of content removed TechCrunch · Ingrid Lunden
- Musk's X Rebuffs Accusations of Israel-Hamas War Disinformation Bloomberg
- Israel-Hamas disinformation: What it is, how to fight it Mashable · Chris Taylor
- X Is a Fog-of-War Machine — Twitter has never been the most popular social media platform. Slate · Scott Nover
- Hamas hate videos make Elon Musk Europe's digital enemy No. 1 Politico · Mark Scott
- A Graphic Hamas Video Donald Trump Jr. Shared on X Is Actually Real, Research Confirms Wired · David Gilbert
- EU's Thierry Breton gives Elon Musk 24-hour ultimatum to deal with Israel-Hamas misinformation on X Euronews
- The EU's Threats to Elon Musk Are Empty, Sources Say Wired · Morgan Meaker
- Israel-Hamas disinformation isn't just going viral on X, Elon Musk is financially incentivizing it Associated Press · Barbara Ortutay
- Elon Musk's X could face expulsion from Europe over Israel-Gaza disinformation, EU official says: ‘These are not empty threats’ Insider
- Elon Musk couldn't seem to find any Hamas-Israel disinformation on X, so we found a bunch for him Fast Company · Clint Rainey
- Letter: European regulator Thierry Breton urges Mark Zuckerberg to be “vigilant” about removing disinformation from Meta's platforms during the Israel-Hamas war CNBC · Ashley Capoot
Discussion
-
@claesdevreese@mastodon.social
Claes de Vreese
on mastodon
The European Commission is “investigating X's compliance with the DSA, including with regard to its policies and practices regarding notices on illegal content, complaint handling, risk assessment.” — Responses required by the of the month. Late or insufficient answers can lea…
-
@jimbochill.bsky.social
JimboChill
on bluesky
Yeah that's like $100 at this point.
-
@thierrybreton
Thierry Breton
on x
#TikTok has a particular obligation to protect children & teenagers from violent content & terrorist propaganda —as well as death challenges & potentially life-threatening content. #DSA sets out very clear obligations TikTok must comply with. Letter to TikTok CEO Shou Zi Chew⤵️ […
-
@thierrybreton
Thierry Breton
on x
The #DSA is here to protect both freedom of expression & our democracies — including in times of crisis. We have sent @X a formal request for information, a first step in our investigation to determine compliance with the DSA. https://ec.europa.eu/...
-
@verajourova
Věra Jourová
on x
Illegal content and terrorist propaganda has no place in the EU, neither offline nor online. The Commission has a duty to vigorously enforce the #DSA and this formal request for information is a step to fully understand what measures @X is taking to ensure online safety.
-
@ingridlunden
Ingrid
on x
Why does this matter? A formal investigation will give us all a better idea of how ‘X’ is used and abused: since Musk took Twitter private, there is a lot less transparency around it. We use it in a dark tunnel bored by Elon.
-
@prestonjbyrne
Preston Byrne
on x
@ThierryBreton @X The DSA is a censorship and content takedown law. Its sole purpose is to censor content European governments dislike. To tell your constituents that this regime protects “freedom of expression” is the worst kind of Orwellian doublespeak.
-
@ggreenwald
Glenn Greenwald
on x
EU officials continue to directly threaten X (along with other Big Tech platforms) that either they start immediately censoring more political speech that EU officials regard as false or dangerous, or they will suffer severe punishment under the EU's new censorship law:
-
@daphnehk
Daphne Keller
on x
When the EU tells platforms they have a legal obligation to “mitigate harms,” does that just mean “take down lawful but harmful content”? This letter from @ThierryBreton seems like a big YES. Regulators can tell platforms what legal material to remove. 1/ https://twitter.com/...
-
@daphnehk
Daphne Keller
on x
In a way we should be relieved that @ThierryBreton said the quiet part out loud so quickly. Other countries considering emulating the DSA should consider whether they want to hand this same authority to restrict lawful speech to their own governments. 2/
-
@mtaibbi
Matt Taibbi
on x
You don't “protect freedom of expression” by allowing unaccountable bureaucrats to mandate removal of content. You have no idea what freedom of expression is. https://www.racket.news/...
-
@daphnehk
Daphne Keller
on x
@ThierryBreton If this letter were really just telling Meta to take down ILLEGAL content, it would have used that word half a dozen more times, instead of saying things like “fake.” 3/3
-
@jason_kint
Jason Kint
on x
I guess that answers the question of what the enforcement team thought of Team Elon's reply. [image]
-
@lisaocarroll
Lisa O'Carroll
on x
BREAKING: The EU sends 2nd missive to X re alleged “spreading of terrorist and violent content and hate speech” Thierry Breton makes formal demand for fresh info about its ability to comply with new laws. Giving it two deadlines 18 Oct and 31 Oct https://ec.europa.eu/...
-
@erinkwoo
Erin Woo
on x
New: The European Commission is investigating X's compliance with the DSA over its content moderation policies. It comes as X has slashed its capabilities for responding to misinformation. Failure to comply could result in fines of up to 6% of X's revenue. https://www.theinformat…
-
@scottnover
Scott Nover
on x
As bad as Twitter is at stopping misinformation—the point of my last piece—we should be very worried when governments start deciding what's “misinformation” and what isn't.
-
@carnage4life
Dare Obasanjo
on threads
Elon is about to find out that “free speech” actually costs a lot, in fines, in the EU.
-
@safety
@safety
on x
In the past couple of days, we've seen an increase in daily active users on @X in the conflict area, plus there have been more than 50 million posts globally focusing on the weekend's terrorist attack on Israel by Hamas. As the events continue to unfold rapidly, a cross-company l…
-
@lindayax
Linda Yaccarino
on x
Everyday we're reminded of our global responsibility to protect the public conversation by ensuring everyone has access to real-time information and safeguarding the platform for all our users. In response to the recent terrorist attack on Israel by Hamas, we've redistributed...
-
@thierrybreton
Thierry Breton
on x
Following the terrorist attacks by Hamas against 🇮🇱, we have indications of X/Twitter being used to disseminate illegal content & disinformation in the EU. Urgent letter to @elonmusk on #DSA obligations ⤵️ [image]
-
@elonmusk
Elon Musk
on x
@ThierryBreton Our policy is that everything is open source and transparent, an approach that I know the EU supports. Please list the violations you allude to on 𝕏, so that that the public can see them. Merci beaucoup.
-
@globalaffairs
@globalaffairs
on x
Today @lindayaX responded to @ThierryBreton's letter detailing our work in response to the terrorist attack on Israel. [image]
-
@thierrybreton
Thierry Breton
on x
@elonmusk Vu, merci. You are well aware of your users' — and authorities'— reports on fake content and glorification of violence. Up to you to demonstrate that you walk the talk. My team remains at your disposal to ensure DSA compliance, which the EU will continue to enforce rigo…
-
@thierrybreton
Thierry Breton
on x
We have received the reply by @X to our letter raising concerns about the spread of illegal content and disinformation related to the Hamas terrorist attack against Israel. The #DSA enforcement team will analyse the reply and decide on next steps.
-
@marinamedvin
@marinamedvin
on x
X has spent the past 12 hours systemically removing all proof of Palestinian terrorist atrocities committed on children, women, the elderly, and the men. A fraction of the proof remains. And not just individual posts — but full accounts gone. Why is X doing this. The victims...
-
@prestonjbyrne
Preston Byrne
on x
“Why is X doing this?” Probably because the European Commission is ordering them to, as @ThierryBreton made clear in his post on Monday. People seeing Hamas atrocities threatens social order in Europe so it must be suppressed.
-
@elonmusk
Elon Musk
on x
@ThierryBreton We take our actions in the open. No back room deals. Please post your concerns explicitly on this platform.
-
@isabelle_szcz
Isabelle Szczepanski
on x
A few remarks : - @ThierryBreton wrongly sent his letter to @elonmusk (the old boys club mentality ?). @lindayaX replies, as she should have been the rightful recipient as the company's CEO. Amen to that. - Breton says that X must remove disinformation, Linda Yacarino replies in.…
-
@erinkwoo
Erin Woo
on x
Linda Yaccarino responded to Thierry Breton's letter here: (Elon Musk responded yesterday via this platform, asking for more information and demanding that Breton post alleged violations publicly on X.)
-
@elonmusk
Elon Musk
on x
@MatchasmMatt @ThierryBreton I still don't know what they're talking about! Maybe it's in the mail or something.
-
@pinboard
@pinboard
on x
This is a misunderstanding of how to use Twitter effectively. You can still get feeds of arbitrarily high quality on any topic, including breaking news, but it requires using the lists feature. That has never been adequately promoted or supported, but it's at everyone's disposal
-
@pinboard
@pinboard
on x
A lot of people who spent the Trump years cheerleading for critical thinking, fact-checking and fighting disinformation are now leaving in a huff now that this site is not ideologically homogeneous instead of putting their principles into action. Sad!
-
@anneapplebaum
Anne Applebaum
on x
“X users were presented with video game footage passed off as footage of a Hamas attack, images of fireworks in Algeria presented as Israeli strikes on Hamas & old video from the Syrian civil war repurposed to look like it was taken this weekend” https://www.wired.com/...
-
@jason_kint
Jason Kint
on x
Things just got (appropriately) real for Elon in his posture on the new DSA. “I urge you to ensure a prompt, accurate and complete response to this request within the next 24 hours. We will include your answer in our assessment file on your compliance with the DSA.”
-
@guyverhofstadt
Guy Verhofstadt
on x
A long overdue first step by @ThierryBreton Under Musk, X has become a swamp of disinformation..including from the owner of the platform. EU laws must apply & if not enough, X should be regulated until it cleans up its act!
-
@jason_kint
Jason Kint
on x
Why didn't he address the letter to the ceo? Just curious. That would be normal protocol.
-
@zsk
Zoe Kleinman
on x
I have seen a lot of disinfo on X - my fab colleague @Shayan86 is doing a good job of highlighting the fakes he has been able to verify but ultimately it's X's job, not his
-
r/worldnews
r
on reddit
EU opens investigation into X over alleged disinformation
-
r/technology
r
on reddit
X removes hundreds of Hamas-affiliated accounts since attack, CEO says