Instagram head Adam Mosseri reiterates Threads' position on hard news, saying that Threads does not intend to “amplify” news because it's currently “too risky”
Mosseri had already framed Threads as a risky standalone bet and said the service would not encourage politics or hard news. Reporting also indicated that its feed drew on an Instagram-style ranking approach that favored creators and friends over news sources.
The position sits uneasily with Threads’ broader ambition to host public conversation: later API planning acknowledged that easier publisher access could tilt the mix toward publisher content rather than creators.
First-order effects
Threads signals that hard-news posts should not expect proactive distribution through its recommendation systems, limiting the platform’s immediate utility as a news-discovery channel for publishers and reporters.
The product’s ranking priorities remain aligned with the creator-and-friends-focused feed approach reported at launch, rather than a direct contest for news attention.
Second-order effects
Publishers considering Threads must treat it more as an audience-maintenance and direct-following channel than as a reliably amplified distribution outlet.
If this posture persists, platforms seeking broad public conversation may increasingly separate conversational reach from news distribution, treating news amplification as a moderation and product-risk decision rather than a default feature.
That would leave news organizations more dependent on channels willing to absorb the operational and scrutiny costs of elevating breaking, political, and hard-news content.
The trend: Threads is part of a broader shift in which social platforms pursue public conversation while tightly controlling whether news becomes a recommendation-driven growth category.
This is actually a reasonable take. The idea that there is going to be one news platform to rule them all, and magical algorithmic feeds that know to only boost “good” things, is a fantasy. If you want to see news, you can go visit news sites right now. …
@guillecummings
@guillecummings on threads
Based on the QTs and replies to this it seems people actually like Mosseri's position on this.
@mattdpearce
@mattdpearce on threads
A lot of the conversations we've had about finding a middle ground between having a sanitized/lobotomized public square (Threads) and a snuff-film propaganda server (X) is really about trying to reconstitute the principles of journalistic judgment as digital protocol, except some…
@mattdpearce
@mattdpearce on threads
The more specific question is whether Meta will ban journalism on Threads alongside their other platforms if Congress passes JCPA or if California passes CJPA. There's a difference between not actively promoting journalism versus potentially actively suppressing it in the future…
@keithedwards
Keith Edwards on threads
What does “not going to amplify it” mean? Does that mean trending topics won't be about what's happening in the world - like Israel, for instance?
@laurengoode
Lauren Goode on threads
This exactly. We've been through the pivot to live video, the pivot to 20-minute videos, the pivot to “discover,” etc etc. Amplification of our stories (and “brands") is essential but we cannot bet the farm on these platforms.
@reckless1280
Nilay Patel on threads
I am begging my peers in the media to stop asking for anything from the people who made the entire media industry pivot to video. Hold them to their promises around federation and build better interoperable news products that actually compete! It will be better for everyone!
@bashowicks
Bash O Wicks on threads
🧵 It's becoming quite comical the number of times @mosseri has to say this about news, and how each time journos hear it as “Meta doesn't want news on Threads”. Personally speaking, I'm exhausted from this narrative that only pushes users further away from a platform with a lot …
@om
@om on threads
Amplification is the core function of a platform defined by algorithms. How they do it, is their prerogative. Whether it is news, misinformation, ads, photos — amplification of those are strategic business decisions. And weirdly, I can see why Adam and his team are taking this…
@taylorlorenz
Taylor Lorenz on threads
By wholesale blocking people from searching newsworthy words including covid, long covid, etc, you are *absolutely* “getting in the way of it”
@jasonrosenbaum
Jason Rosenbaum on threads
Hi @mosseri: I understand you don't want overpromise and under-deliver. If you want journalists like me to use this platform as the primary place to post our reporting, you could have an algorithm that prioritizes posts with links alongside text-heavy commentary posts. …
@myhlee
Michelle Ye Hee Lee on threads
I don't think we're clamoring for Threads — a Meta product — to “amplify news.” The conversations I'm witnessing is that post-Twitter, people are looking for a place where news from multiple trusted sources is easily accessible real-time, especially breaking news. Threads is ju…
@frankafusco
Frank Fusco on threads
The sides in this debate aren't speaking the same language. Meta's strategy for Threads is (somewhat extreme) risk aversion in opposition to Twitter's (very extreme and self-destructive) lust for risk. However, fundamentally: if you have moderation, you have curative interventi…
@luckytran
Dr. Lucky Tran on threads
But this is false. Threads is absolutely getting in the way of news because you are arbitrarily choosing to restrict search results on important news and health words like Covid and vaccines. Please fix this!
@drewharwell
Drew Harwell on threads
Thanks for elaborating. Just to be clear, what genres of content does Threads intend to amplify, and what will that look like? And why is news - original reporting, discussion of current events, real-world issues - uniquely ineligible in comparison?
@benedictevans
Benedict Evans on threads
It is notable how many times Adam has to say this, and how many journalists seem to hear it as “Meta doesn't want news on Threads” And also worth asking whether a firehose of real-time posts about news (with all the abuse and distortion that comes with that) is unambiguously a go…
@lucaspuskaric
@lucaspuskaric on threads
@threads @mosseri Read the room. I love you. You're doing a great job so far. Keep releasing amazing features at an incredible cadence to your millions of active users. This was the most seamless product launch I've witnessed in some time. I love the diversity of content and…
@yayitsrob
Robinson Meyer on threads
FWIW, I don't take issue with this approach as much as others. I don't really want a “news” app, and I'm not even sure I understand what a “news” app is. As a journalist, I want an app where I can (1) share links, ideas, and reportage with curious readers, (2) follow and chat w…
@mosseri
Adam Mosseri on threads
We're not anti-news. News is clearly already on Threads. People can share news; people can follow accounts that share news. We're not going to get in the way of any either. But, we're also not going go to amplify news on the platform. To do so would be too risky given the ma…
@miasato.2
Mia Sato on threads
Israel-Palestine news has brought lots of people on this app in recent days — it undeniably feels like a different place. I want to know how this squares with what @mosseri has said about how Meta won't encourage “hard news” on Threads https://www.theverge.com/...
@jason_kint
Jason Kint on x
I'm calling BS long term here. There is no way they will build habitual and long term behavior without embracing live, current events and news. They know this. They're using Threads as part of their public policy strategy to scare news distribution and not overpromise on product.