An author finds multiple “garbage books” uploaded to Amazon under her name, most likely AI-generated, and on Goodreads, which removed them after her complaint
Update: Hours after this post was published, my Goodreads profile was cleaned of the offending titles.
Jane Friedman
Related Coverage
- Amazon Faces Backlash for AI-Authored Books Attributed to Human Authors Cryptopolitan · Editah Patrick
- Amazon Won't Remove Books Listed Under a Real Author's Name But Allegedly Written With AI Decrypt · Jason Nelson
- “...even if and when you get these insane books removed from your official profiles, they will still be floating around out there, with your name, on two major sites that gets millions of visitors, just waiting to be “discovered. ” And there's absolutely nothing you can do about it.” https://janefriedman.com/... @lilithsaintcrow@raggedfeathers.com · Lili Saintcrow
- I would rather see my books get pirated than this Hacker News
- Taking Down Prosecraft.io — Today, I'm taking down the prosecraft.io website … The Shaxpir Blog · Benji Smith
- Use of AI led to Prosecraft's closure gHacks Technology News · Emre Çitak
- Explaining the Prosecraft drama: This is why every author is mad at a website that counted words The A.V. Club · Sam Barsanti
- Prosecraft.io Shuts Down After Backlash from Authors CityLife · Robert Andrew
- Fiction Analytics Site Prosecraft Shut Down After Author Backlash Gizmodo · Linda Codega
- Maddening. They won't be happy until every bit of art, literature and music is devalued to the point that human creatives are incapable of earning a decent living from their work. — We need a popular movement committed to supporting independent creators outside these monopolistic platforms. … @imtheq@realsocial.life
Discussion
-
@Haste@mastodon.social
@Haste@mastodon.social
on mastodon
“But here's what does rankle me: garbage books getting uploaded to Amazon where my name is credited as the author... Whoever's doing this is obviously preying on writers who trust my name and think I've actually written these books. I have not. Most likely they've been generate…
-
@tylerking.bsky.social
Tyler King
on bluesky
Jfc. If AI-gen books weren't bad enough, now scammers are uploading illegitimate books to Amazon/Goodreads with a recognizable author's name on them in the hopes of skimming a few bucks from unsuspecting readers. https://janefriedman.com/... [embedded post]
-
@jenhoward.bsky.social
Jen Howard
on bluesky
A sneaky peril for authors on Amazon and Goodreads: fraudulent books (likely AI-authored) being passed off as theirs. @janefriedman.bsky.social reports on her experience. https://janefriedman.com/...
-
@edsermark.bsky.social
@edsermark.bsky.social
on bluesky
“As of today, there are about half a dozen books being sold on Amazon, with my name on them, that I did not write or publish. Some huckster generated them using AI.” — Amazon refused to remove them. — https://janefriedman.com/...
-
@jasonsanford.bsky.social
Jason Sanford
on bluesky
Must-read post by @janefriedman.bsky.social about a disturbing new publishing trend. Essentially Amazon is allowing scammers to upload books under the names of well known and trusted authors, as has happened to Friedman. https://janefriedman.com/...
-
@janefriedman
Jane Friedman
on x
As of today, there are about half a dozen books being sold on Amazon, with my name on them, that I did not write or publish. Some huckster generated them using AI. This promises to be a serious problem for the book publishing world. https://janefriedman.com/...
-
@nina_metz
Nina Metz
on x
“We desperately need guardrails on this landslide of misattribution and misinformation. Amazon and Goodreads, I beg you to create a way to verify authorship, or for authors to easily block fraudulent books credited to them. Do it now, do it quickly” https://janefriedman.com/...
-
@lexlanham
Alexandra J. Roberts
on x
remember when I tweeted like a month ago do we still have lanham act false over-attribution claims after dastar? seems important & guess we'll find out soon seems like a fit on facts like these, & not a copyright runaround...
-
@lisadubbels
Lisa Braun Dubbels
on x
Maybe Amazon needs to enact a verification layer to ensure that books being uploaded to their platform are written by who they say they are. There's a whole reputation mgmt component of impersonation & fraud that's become my job to police and it sucks. https://janefriedman.com/..…
-
@authorsguild
@authorsguild
on x
THIS: “We desperately need guardrails on this landslide of misattribution and misinformation. Amazon and Goodreads, I beg you to create a way to verify authorship, or for authors to easily block fraudulent books credited to them.” https://janefriedman.com/...
-
@charlotteashley
Charlotte Ashley
on x
Read this important piece from Jane Friedman today. Remembered that there has been a fake Charlotte Ashley pulping out farmed books for years. It was funny at the time, but now I really, hope none of the agents I have been querying looked me up. 😬 https://janefriedman.com/...
-
@otisframpton
Otis Frampton
on x
The AI fraudsters aren't just impersonating artists. They're impersonating authors, too. Unbelievable.
-
r/books
r
on reddit
I Would Rather See My Books Get Pirated Than This (Or: Why Goodreads and Amazon Are Becoming Dumpster Fires)
-
@pronounced_ing
Celeste Ng
on x
I count 20 @StephenKing books, 20 @jodipicoult books, plus books by tons of other contemporary writers (@legroff, Madeline Miller, Angie Thomas... just search and they're pretty much in there). Did any of these authors/publishers consent to this use of their work?
-
@maureenjohnson
Maureen Johnson
on x
I join the chain of those who did not consent to this. [image]
-
@benji_smith
Benji Smith
on x
I took down the prosecraft website. I'm sorry, everyone. https://blog.shaxpir.com/...
-
@kaylaancrum
@kaylaancrum
on x
Watching weird tech people get seduced by mega corp boldness into believing the lie that all art is “content” and like “content” produced by novices, is unprotected and available for use has been very 😃 This guy is about to get sued by all ten of the largest publishers at once.
-
@zachrosewriter
@zachrosewriter
on x
How DARE you, @benji_smith I demand you take my book off your site immediately. I do not consent to this, and never did. And I know my publisher never would [image]
-
@lindaholmes
@lindaholmes
on x
@pronounced_ing ... Mine's in there, and I definitely didn't.
-
@bibliogato
Katherine Locke
on x
He took the website down but that doesn't account for the theft and the database he fed our books into. Publishers and authors need to be aggressive and not let this go. Guys like this will just let the fury die down and quietly restart.
-
@pronounced_ing
Celeste Ng
on x
Speaking of which, this might be of interest to writers out there (and anyone else concerned about AI being trained on writing by humans, without consent): https://authorsguild.org/...
-
@pronounced_ing
Celeste Ng
on x
I'm not worried about AI writing being *better* than works by actual humans. But I *am* worried about companies (wrongly) thinking they can replace human writers with AI. And companies should DEFINITELY not be able to train AI on other people's work w/o consent or compensation.
-
@harikunzru
Hari Kunzru
on x
This company Prosecraft appears to have stolen a lot of books, trained an AI, and are now offering a service based on that data https://blog.shaxpir.com/...
-
@pronounced_ing
Celeste Ng
on x
Adding insult to injury, the site doing the “analysis” doesn't seem to understand what passive voice is, and arbitrarily assigns each word a “vividness” score, and then scores the book's “vividness” on that.