Interviews with 20 people detail the Biden admin's response to SVB's and Signature's collapse, as tech executives and investors lobbied to protect all deposits
It seemed like a simple question: Did the treasury secretary have any concerns about the economic risks posed by Silicon Valley Bank?
Context & Ripple Effects
SVB’s failure exposed the fragility of a startup-focused bank whose depositor base and interest-rate exposure had already drawn scrutiny in accounts of the bank’s collapse. The FDIC’s initial plan for depositors above $250,000 left companies facing an immediate payroll deadline, making a broader response especially consequential for SVB’s technology clients.
The lobbying campaign unfolded against a policy backdrop in which higher stress-test thresholds had reduced oversight for banks of SVB’s size. It also sharpened concerns that the government response would bring tougher scrutiny of the tech sector.
First-order effects
- The Biden administration and Treasury had to weigh pressure from tech executives and investors seeking protection for uninsured deposits against the broader economic risks of the two bank failures.
- SVB and Signature customers with balances above the insurance limit gained a direct stake in the government’s response, particularly firms needing cash for near-term payroll.
Second-order effects
- The intervention made the relationship between concentrated technology deposits and bank-rescue decisions more visible, increasing the political salience of Silicon Valley’s lobbying power.
- Banks that fall below the former $250 billion stress-test threshold face renewed attention after SVB’s failure highlighted the consequences of lighter oversight.
Third-order effects
- If bank failures with concentrated commercial deposit bases repeatedly require broad depositor protection, specialist banks will face a more demanding balance between serving a single ecosystem and containing correlated withdrawal risk.
- The episode points toward a regulatory debate in which bank supervision and technology-sector influence are increasingly assessed together, rather than as separate policy questions.
The trend: The SVB and Signature response is part of a broader reassessment of how concentrated industry deposits, lighter bank oversight, and emergency backstops interact.
Related: Specialist Absorption Risk · Frontier capital concentration · Silicon Valley Bank · Dodd-Frank reforms and the SVB collapse · FDIC plan for SVB deposits above $250K · Concerns over tougher tech regulation after SVB
Related Coverage
- ‘Lungs of the startup world’: bank fall upends most Silicon Valley industries The Guardian
- U.S. Is Said to Open Investigation Into Silicon Valley Bank Collapse New York Times
- Why Did Silicon Valley Bank and Signature Bank Fail So Fast? Gizmodo · Vidhura S. Tennekoon
- Bank Runs, Crypto Concerns and Takeovers: A Timeline of the Panic New York Times
- How Washington Decided to Rescue Silicon Valley Bank's Depositors New York Times
- SVB and the Fed — The banking panic of 2023 appears to be over, as swiftly as it began. Noahpinion · Noah Smith
- Tech pressure, Yellen everywhere: How Washington scrambled as SVB collapsed Reuters · Andrea Shalal
- CEO: Bailing Out Tech ‘1000000x More Important Than Defending Ukraine’ VICE · Jordan Pearson
- Four days of panic: How startup execs navigated SVB's meltdown and prepared for the worst CNBC · Ari Levy
- Real-Estate Investor Run on Signature Bank Helped Fuel Its Demise Wall Street Journal
- Where the Venture Community Goes From Here The Information · Hemant Taneja
- Update from Silicon Valley Bridge Bank CEO Silicon Valley Bank
- Silicon Valley Bank's new CEO urges customers to bring deposits back TechCrunch · Natasha Mascarenhas
- SEC and Justice Dept. look into Silicon Valley Bank collapse Washington Post
- Silicon Valley Bridge Bank CEO Invites Depositors to Return PYMNTS.com
- ‘Help us rebuild’ deposit base: Silicon Valley Bridge Bank CEO Livemint
- ‘Trust is a hard thing to earn’: SVB's closure could disproportionately affect Black founders TechCrunch · Dominic-Madori Davis
- Wine, Skiing, and Loans: How Silicon Valley Bank Became Startups' Best Friend Wired · Paresh Dave
Discussion
-
@sarthakgh
Sar Haribhakti
on x
“In a meeting, Jeff Zients, the chief of staff; Lael Brainard, the national economic director; and Cecilia Rouse, one of Biden's top economic advisers, alerted the president to a type of danger not seen since the financial crisis nearly 15 years ago: The https://www.washingtonpos…
-
@johnjharwood
John Harwood
on x
“The administration managed to calm markets after a day of turbulence that cut into bank stocks. “And it prevented panic that might've resulted in countless Americans withdrawing money, which could've created damaging instability in the financial system.” https://www.washingtonpo…
-
@stevedaniels27
Steve Daniels
on x
Good account of behind-the-scenes action in DC. Was the banking system as a whole really in such danger? Here in Chicago, I'm not detecting that. But I get the decision making. The down side, even if less than 50%, was really bad https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
-
@armanddoma
Armand Domalewski
on x
it is becoming abundantly clear that the FDIC, Treasury, and Fed acting decisively was the only thing that kept Monday from being a blood bath https://twitter.com/...
-
@washingtonpost
@washingtonpost
on x
The world saw a failing bank. Biden aides saw a great unraveling. New fears began to surface about a potential run on Silicon Valley Bank, threatening widespread devastation not just for California, but perhaps the U.S. economy writ large. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
-
@timothys
Tim Shorrock
on x
One of the funnier explanations for anonymity I've heard. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ... https://twitter.com/...
-
@karaswisher
Kara Swisher
on x
As I noted before, it was the quiet but always reasonable techies like @reidhoffman who did the heavy lifting on helping solve this crisis. https://twitter.com/...
-
@imillhiser
Ian Millhiser
on x
I am grateful for the fact that the United States is currently led by officials who, in a moment when quick action was necessary to avert an economic crisis, acted in a highly competent manner. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
-
@mattyglesias
Matthew Yglesias
on x
Like read this story — no screaming fights? No internal dissension? Where's the drama? https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
-
@jstein_wapo
Jeff Stein
on x
Top banking regulators saw a surge in requests for withdrawals — including at banks that appeared totally disconnected from SVB Distress emerged at banks outside NY & CA Treasury Dept aides received alarming reports on bank balance sheet data https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
-
@tracyalloway
Tracy Alloway
on x
The cognitive dissonance here is pretty stunning. https://twitter.com/...
-
@davidsacks
David Sacks
on x
But it's important to understand that SVB's failure didn't arise from risky startups doing risky startup things. It arose from SVB's over-exposure to boring old mortgage bonds, which were considered safe at the time SVB bought them.
-
@buccocapital
BuccoCapital Guy
on x
Nice bit from Odd Lots today: SVB's mistake was thinking that even w/in tech they were diversified They thought they had thousands of customers w/ millions in deposits They actually had a few customers (VC's) w/ billions who all coordinated leaving together, causing the run
-
@emollick
Ethan Mollick
on x
There seems to be a belief among some tech pundits that public reactions on Twitter about the SBV collapse shows that Americans hate technology companies. Twitter is not real life! Tech is MORE trusted than any other industry, https://www.ipsos.com/...... https://twitter.com/...…
-
@davidsacks
David Sacks
on x
It's painful for me to watch so many smart pundits and politicians on both the right and the left buy into a media narrative that seeks to blame “wealthy speculators” or “tech bros” or VCs for a banking crisis that ultimately started in Washington. Let me explain. 🧵
-
@bongcapital
@bongcapital
on x
Please let this happen, just because I want to see how VC and startup bros on this cursed hellsite react when they have to deal with owing money to Ares. *ARES IS SAID TO CONSIDER BID FOR SLICE OF SVB'S LOAN BOOK
-
@smtuffy
Sean Tuffy
on x
Thoughts & Prayers to the FDIC admin of the former SVB who has to have calls with the VC bros. It's like a fire chief being forced to have regular meetings with arsonists.
-
@nickdeiuliis
Nick DeIuliis
on x
#SVB failure root causes: (a) free money for banks via deposits no longer free w/ Fed raising rates, (b) balance sheet bond & real estate assets inflated by free money now under stress, (c) VC clients are risky startups & many fail in real world. SVB will not be alone. #bailout
-
@katie_roof
Katie Roof
on x
The SVB situation underscores how interdependent the VC/startup ecosystem is
-
@martingtobias
Martin Tobias
on x
Blaming lack of regulation for SVB is such a bad take! Management decided to go long on TBills. VCs decided to pull money all at the same time. In capitalism companies need freedom to innovate. And when they make bad business decisions, they are responsible for consequences.
-
@profkatejudge
Kate Judge
on x
SVB has become the ultimate Rorschach test. Its messy demise has been blamed on woke boards, excessive government spending (motivating the Fed's tightening), VC Bros, and now Twitter. Just pick your pet peeve and get creative in your storytelling. https://www.wsj.com/...
-
@georgemagnus1
George Magnus
on x
Taleb is surely spot on with this. You could argue that SVB was wrong/naive to bloat itself with too many deposits, but the crass thing it did was was take such long duration risk in Tsies/Agencies. Why didn't the VC crowd call it out? (Rhetorical) https://twitter.com/...
-
@conorsen
Conor Sen
on x
If Trump had done more fiscal stimulus interest rates never would have gotten so low, VC's wouldn't have raised so much money that they deployed into startups, and SVB never would have had massive deposit growth. So it's Trump's fault.
-
@dsquareddigest
Dan Davies
on x
Given the above - which I think is the true picture of SVB, after speaking to numerous customers and shareholders - the VC guys can't just wash their hands and blame everything on management.
-
@dsquareddigest
Dan Davies
on x
I am probably being harsh here, but some experience at a Swiss bank gives me a more than normal sense of the fuzzy boundary between “a bad bank” and “a good bank with bad clients”...(oh god, THRED. this was what the Substack was meant to protect you from). https://twitter.com/...
-
@htaneja
Hemant Taneja
on x
SVB crisis is what happens when our community fails to collaborate. We must commit to a new VC model: collaboration, responsible innovation, & appreciation of unintended consequences. We have a lot of work to do—together. My thoughts @theinformation: https://www.theinformation.co…
-
@emptywheel
@emptywheel
on x
Am I missing where this WSJ piece on the SVB panic sown on Twitter mentions @DavidSacks? Or where it explains that Calacanis is ANOTHER of Elmo's closest advisors? https://www.wsj.com/... https://twitter.com/...
-
@billackman
Bill Ackman
on x
The irony of the @SVBFinancial_ intervention is that we now have three tiers of banks. SVB and Signature Bridge Banks - which are now the safest banks with explicit guarantees on all deposits, the SIB banks - which have implicit guarantees on all deposits, and all other banks.
-
@adamsinger
Adam Singer
on x
Much of what happens on Twitter is faked or astroturfed. Reason being, every reporter and blogger is here as water cooler so there is much incentive to do this, probably the best honeypot to spread narrative. This is widely known amongst anyone paying attention. But many do not..…
-
@thestalwart
Joe Weisenthal
on x
Um? Could the tech backlash be a lot worse than we realize? Over 700 votes so far, and the majority of respondents don't think tech startups should be allowed to have bank accounts https://twitter.com/...
-
@compound248
@compound248
on x
The “TWITTER CREATED BANK RUN CONTAGION RISK” narrative is off to the races. Think any of the highlighted pyromaniacs have regrets? Illusion of Control bias started this. Overconfidence bias dug them in. Cognitive Dissonance will prevent honest reflection. @WSJ highlights.👇 https…
-
@mdudas
Mike Dudas
on x
.@jason prepping his next all caps tweetstorm https://twitter.com/... https://twitter.com/...
-
@carnage4life
Dare Obasanjo
on x
A live feed of how Silicon Valley VCs viewed themselves as solving the SVB crisis by tweeting hysterically over the weekend. https://twitter.com/...
-
@professorstam
@professorstam
on x
“...the weekend's events made clear that banks now must contend with “social media risk."" Thanks to @georgia_wells @WSJ for interviewing me on this topic. Stay tuned for more of my unfiltered thoughts on the subject... https://www.wsj.com/...
-
@silvermanjacob
Jacob Silverman
on x
“In one Reddit thread, users disagreed about whether a photo showed lines at a bank or people waiting for food at a taco stand. The photo was later taken down.” https://www.wsj.com/...
-
@karaswisher
Kara Swisher
on x
Exactly. Screaming meemies are not the heroes of this story — they are actually the dude in “Die Hard” who turns tail: ‘Twitter-fueled bank run’: Social-media postings amplify anxiety over SVB collapse https://www.wsj.com/...
-
@georgia_wells
Georgia Wells
on x
“This was the first Twitter-fueled bank run,” said Rep. Patrick McHenry. Here's how social-media posts amplified anxiety over the SVB collapse. w/ @AlexaCorse https://www.wsj.com/...
-
@goldman
Jason Goldman
on x
I am reminded of Biz's observation from SxSW 2007 about how Twitter allowed for this emergent behavior and the ability to see crowds move “like a flock a birds.” https://www.wsj.com/...
-
@moorehn
Heidi N. Moore
on x
Tim Mayopoulos will also be known to connoisseurs of the 2008 financial crisis as the general counsel of Bank of America who was unceremoniously fired and then had to explain to Congress how BofA bought Merrill Lynch at an enormously mistaken valuation
-
@nickjonesvp
Nick Jones
on x
A message to our clients, friends, and partners of SVB (from our new CEO Timothy Mayopoulos). https://twitter.com/...
-
@euniceajim
Eunice Ajim
on x
The past couple of days have been a roller coaster but I'm happy with the level of communication SVB has shown over the last few days. Currently on a call with the new CEO, Tim Mayopoulos of SVB and many other VCs/LPs. I'm confident keeping some of our capital at SVB.
-
@pitdesi
Sheel Mohnot
on x
“There is no safer place for deposits than SVB. We are not subject to the $250k FDIC limit. We are fully insured.” -Tim Mayopoulos, SVB Bridge Bank CEO
-
@thechiefnerd
@thechiefnerd
on x
“SVB's new CEO Tim Mayopoulos...asked clients to return deposits to the institutions: 'That's the single-most important thing you can do to ensure that Silicon Valley Bank survives.'” https://techcrunch.com/... https://twitter.com/...
-
@readkrystalhu
Krystal Hu
on x
SVB new CEO Tim Mayopoulos' first call w/ top VC clients on Tue went much better than his predecessor's. He laid out three scenarios of the banks, honored loans & lines of credit for startups, calling the FDIC-insured bank “probably the safest place” https://www.reuters.com/...
-
@msuster
Mark Suster
on x
1/ Update on what I know about SVB situation. New info on industry call with new CEO last night. Their main message, “we are open for business, your deposits are fully FDIC insured & safe” They understand you will have cash in multiple banks, they would like to be one of them
-
@ijakemendel
Jake Mendel
on x
A message from Tim Mayopoulos, CEO Silicon Valley Bridge Bank, N. A. https://www.svb.com/... https://twitter.com/...
-
@dk_munro
Daniel Munro
on x
Inside the Collapse of Silicon Valley Bank “This isn't greed, necessarily, at the bank level.... It's just bad risk management. It was complete and utter bad risk management on the part of SVB.” https://www.nytimes.com/...
-
@dannygroner
Danny Groner
on x
“Greg was always looking out five to 10 years,” said Mr. Coffey of Janney Montgomery Scott. “He was more of a V.C. than he was a banker.” https://www.nytimes.com/...
-
@nytimes
@nytimes
on x
The tale of Silicon Valley Bank is one of ambition and management mistakes. When the bank was caught flat-footed in a changing economic environment, it waited until the last minute to try to avert its fate. By Friday, it was dead. https://www.nytimes.com/...
-
@flitteronfraud
Emily Flitter
on x
Read this fantastic piece by @maureenmfarrell as she takes readers inside Silicon Valley Bank during its final days. I have chills. https://www.nytimes.com/...