After a decade of waiting for a quality Harry Potter video game, some fans struggle to reconcile enjoying Hogwarts Legacy with JK Rowling's transphobic comments
Harry Potter fans have been waiting more than a decade for a video game worthy of the blockbuster entertainment franchise's dedicated following.
Bloomberg Jason Schreier
Related Coverage
- Hogwarts Legacy Review IGN · Travis Northup
- Hogwarts Legacy breaks record before official release, despite controversy CNN · Vanessa Yurkevich
- Hogwarts Legacy review - wizarding wish-fulfilment whose magic wears off The Guardian · Keza MacDonald
- Portkey Games Addresses Hogwarts Legacy's Transgender Character IGN · Alex Stedman
- ‘Hogwarts Legacy’ Video Game Debuts Trans Character Despite J.K. Rowling's Politics The Wrap · Dessi Gomez
- ‘Hogwarts Legacy’ Video Game Controversy: Boycotts And J.K. Rowling's Comments On Transgender Community, Explained Forbes · Conor Murray
- A new trans character doesn't fix ‘Hogwarts Legacy’ transphobia MSNBC · Katelyn Burns
- Hogwarts Legacy Can't Cast Aside Debate Over J.K. Rowling New York Times · Julia Jacobs
- Rowling's Transphobic Comments Prompted ‘Hogwarts Legacy’ Studio to Become More Inclusive Bloomberg
- Why I'm reviewing ‘Hogwarts Legacy’ Engadget · Jessica Conditt
- Can trans allies play Hogwarts: Legacy? Laurie Charles
- JK Rowling's Anti-Transgender Stance And Hogwarts Legacy GameSpot · Jessie Earl
- Pushing Buttons: ‘We can survive without it’ - the gamers boycotting Hogwarts Legacy The Guardian · Keza MacDonald
- ‘Hogwarts Legacy’ Release Date, Early Access, PC Performance Issues, And Everything You Need To Know Forbes · Erik Kain
Discussion
-
@masterofthetds
@masterofthetds
on x
Any review for Hogwarts Legacy that mentions J.K. Rowling or transphobia is an automatic skip for me. I want to know about the game, not what you are pretending to be offended by.
-
@okami13_
@okami13_
on x
Hogwarts Legacy - Official Review Scores: PSU - 10 IGN - 9 XboxEra - 9 PowerUp - 9 Well Played - 9 Gamerant - 4.5/5 Pushsquare - 8 VGC - 4/5 ACG - Buy Metacritic - 86 https://www.metacritic.com/... Opencritic - 85 https://opencritic.com/... https://twitter.com/... https://twitte…
-
@younghomiekobi
Kobi
on x
Me still buying #HogwartsLegacy and watching the folks who boycott it bitch and complain about it https://twitter.com/...
-
@thegemagenda
@thegemagenda
on x
The IGN Hogwarts Legacy review is one of the funniest pieces of games writing ever: * This game barely works * Inventory can hold four items * There are two enemies * The story and worldbuilding make no sense * An inset about how the author is a bigot * But I love Potter so 9/10
-
@epistemophagy
Moby Dickgirl
on x
IGN's review of Hogwarts Legacy is very weird because it reads like they wanted to give it a bad review but weren't allowed to
-
@stonethecrowsx0
@stonethecrowsx0
on x
Rare ign W. Separating the hogwarts legacy review, scoring it appropriately and a piece about J. K Rowling. https://twitter.com/...
-
@ssmoek_i
@ssmoek_i
on x
Hogwarts Legacy the first game to get black folks hair right🤝🏾😂 A1 stuff https://twitter.com/...
-
@zannahg
@zannahg
on x
Please do not buy/play/stream the harry potter game. Stand with the communities begging you to put them and their lives first. I have compiled a list of alternative magic games to play. More will be added in the future, I just ran out of spoons half way https://boycotthl.crd.co/
-
@jasonschreier
Jason Schreier
on x
Rowling's comments in the summer of 2020 rattled a number of people working on Hogwarts Legacy. Some looked for new jobs; others stayed and tried to grapple with their ethical questions. And the company responded by making one NPC transgender, according to four people familiar
-
@evinh111
Evin H
on x
Might get the game second-hand, but have no intention of buying it new. This is a prime example of why. https://twitter.com/... https://twitter.com/...
-
@zachsilberberg
Zach Silberberg
on x
jk rowling wont see your tweet about why hogwarts legacy sucks but your friend who is shamefully playing hogwarts legacy will. good. hope you see this jeremy
-
@jasonschreier
Jason Schreier
on x
Although Rowling was not involved with the creation of the game, her creative agency, The Blair Partnership, played a big role. She still owns Harry Potter and benefits financially and culturally from sales, leaving some fans facing ethical dilemmas.
-
@christapeterso
@christapeterso
on x
The idea that the Hogwarts Legacy boycott isn't having an impact is just a take from Mars https://twitter.com/...
-
@emilyjnicolle
Emily Nicolle
on x
gf (masc-presenting cis woman) has been playing this week. while the avatar options are more diverse than other games, she has to wear a skirt for the entire game if she wants to have a feminine face. same as preferring ‘wizard’ over ‘witch’, now stuck in male dormitories https:/…
-
@jazzysart
@jazzysart
on x
buying hogwarts legacy =/ you're a transphobe but it does = you're giving money to a transphobe who is actively using said money to harm trans people if youre armed with that info, I'd hope you'd make the wiser and kinder choice and not passively support jk rowling
-
@chronotope
Aram Zucker-Scharff
on x
There is a direct line that starts at G*m*rG*te, runs through the POC and LGBTQA+ people they chased permanently out of the industry, goes through the shift backwards in how reviews are written, and comes to this dumb IGN quote. https://twitter.com/... https://twitter.com/...
-
@jasonschreier
Jason Schreier
on x
Hogwarts Legacy is already breaking records on Twitch and topping pre-order charts. It's going to sell gangbusters. But, thanks to Rowling's incendiary comments over the past few years, this isn't an ordinary blockbuster launch. Full story: https://www.bloomberg.com/...
-
@jasonschreier
Jason Schreier
on x
Hogwarts Legacy is one of the year's biggest video games. But for some fans and even people who made it, it's been difficult to reconcile enjoyment of the Harry Potter world with author JK Rowling's views on transgender people. New Bloomberg feature: https://www.bloomberg.com/...
-
@jessconditt
Jessica L. Conditt
on x
the level of infighting and hate in my feed this morning is heartbreaking. if you're boycotting hogwarts legacy, cool — boycott the game, not the players. keep the focus on our shared fight. forget her name. https://www.engadget.com/...
-
@vward98
@vward98
on x
BREAKING: The upcoming Harry Potter universe game ‘Hogwarts Legacy’ will introduce the franchise's first ever openly gay character, named “Homie McSexual”. https://twitter.com/...
-
@pistolrick
@pistolrick
on x
Just downloaded Hogwarts Legacy https://twitter.com/...
-
@ign
@ign
on x
Hogwarts Legacy's technical issues don't come close to breaking its enchanting spell. Our review by Travis Northup: https://www.ign.com/... https://twitter.com/...
-
@islandfae653
@islandfae653
on x
“Trans people don't get to ignore the pain the franchise has become intrinsically linked to, and those who wish to care for them shouldn't get to do so, either” -@jessiegender Good on GameSpot to put this front and center *before* their review dropped https://www.gamespot.com/...