Apple's Maps Tilt in Strange Directions
Last week, I used Apple's new Maps app on my iPhone to guide me to a speaking engagement. — The GPS navigation screen was clean, bold and distraction-free. The voice instructions spoke the actual street names. The prompts gave me just the right amount of time to prepare for each turn.
Context & Ripple Effects
Apple's iOS 6 switch from Google Maps put a home-grown mapping service at the center of the iPhone experience, even as widespread complaints about mapping errors exposed its uneven launch. Apple had already directed transit users to third-party transit apps, leaving turn-by-turn driving as the clearest test of the new service.
The account underscores that the navigation interface and spoken street-name guidance can work well even while unusual map orientation undermines confidence in the overall product. That split matters because Maps is no longer a replaceable supplier feature for Apple.
First-order effects
- iPhone users receive Apple’s clean, voice-guided driving interface, but directional anomalies make the service less dependable for trips where map orientation matters.
- Apple assumes direct responsibility for the mapping experience that had previously been supplied by Google.
Second-order effects
- Transit-app developers retain a necessary role in iOS 6 because Apple’s Maps experience routes transit directions to third-party services.
- Google gains an opening to compete on mapping reliability as Apple’s in-house alternative is judged on everyday navigation rather than interface design alone.
Third-order effects
- Mobile maps are becoming a core platform layer: owning the interface gives Apple control, but it also makes data quality and routing accuracy central to the iPhone’s perceived reliability.
- If smartphone makers continue replacing outside map providers, navigation competition will shift from bundled access to the quality of each company’s underlying geographic service.
The trend: Smartphone platforms are bringing maps in-house, turning navigation accuracy into a direct test of ecosystem control.
Related: Apple · iPhone · Apple’s buggy iOS 6 Maps draws complaints · Apple sends transit directions to third-party apps
Related Coverage
- Apple-Google Maps Talks Crashed Over Voice-Guided Directions AllThingsD · John Paczkowski
- Snubbed by Apple, Foursquare makes its maps experience better on iPhone VentureBeat · Jennifer Van Grove
- On the Timing of Apple's Map Switch Daring Fireball · John Gruber
- Ripping Off The Bloody Band-Aid massive greatness · MG Siegler
- SiliconANGLE None
- Real Dan Lyons None
- Business Insider None
- Inquirer None
- Engadget None
- Gizmodo None
- Phones Review None
- Edible Apple None
- CNET None
- iLounge None
- iDownloadBlog.com None
- Forbes None
- Macgasm None
- PhoneArena None
- digitaltrends.com None
- Softpedia News None
- Redmond Pie None
- MacNN None
- Gotta Be Mobile None
- The Next Web None
- SiliconANGLE SiliconANGLE · Mellisa Tolentino
- Real Dan Lyons Real Dan Lyons · Dan Lyons
- Business Insider Business Insider · Jay Yarow
- Inquirer Inquirer · Lee Bell
- Engadget Engadget · Richard Lawler
- Gizmodo Gizmodo · Sam Gibbs
- Phones Review Phones Review · Mark
- Edible Apple Edible Apple
- CNET CNET · Lance Whitney
- iLounge iLounge · Phil Dzikiy
- iDownloadBlog.com iDownloadBlog.com · Christian Zibreg
- Forbes Forbes · Peter Cohan
- Macgasm Macgasm · Kaylie Moise
- Phone Arena Phone Arena
- digitaltrends.com digitaltrends.com · Trevor Mogg
- Softpedia News Softpedia News
- Redmond Pie Redmond Pie · Ben Reid
- MacNN MacNN
- Gotta Be Mobile Gotta Be Mobile · Adam Mills
- The Next Web The Next Web · Matthew Panzarino
- BetaNews None
- WebProNews None
- iPhone None
- TechCrunch None
- Pocket-lint None
- Softpedia News None
- ZDNet None
- Gizmodo None
- Daring Fireball None
- Coyote Tracks None
- SeekingAlpha.com None
- CNET None
- BetaNews BetaNews · Wayne Williams
- WebProNews WebProNews · Sean Patterson
- iPhone iPhone · J.R. Bookwalter
- TechCrunch TechCrunch · Anthony Ha
- Pocket-lint Pocket-lint · Rik Henderson
- ZDNet ZDNet · David Gewirtz
- Daring Fireball Daring Fireball · John Gruber
- Coyote Tracks Coyote Tracks
- SeekingAlpha.com SeekingAlpha.com
- Engadget None
- Wired.co.uk None
- Foursquare Blog None
- GadgeTell None
- Mashable! None
- WebProNews None
- Gizmodo None
- Search Engine Land None
- Wired.co.uk Wired.co.uk · Max Tatton-Brown
- Foursquare Blog Foursquare Blog
- GadgeTell GadgeTell · Robert Nelson
- Mashable! Mashable! · Stan Schroeder
- Search Engine Land Search Engine Land · Matt McGee
- Edible Apple None
- Geeky-Gadgets None
- The Next Web None
- The Verge None
- TechCrunch None
- SeekingAlpha.com None
- nbcnews.com None
- Geeky-Gadgets Geeky-Gadgets · Roland Hutchinson
- The Verge The Verge · Adi Robertson
- nbcnews.com nbcnews.com · Rosa Golijan
- Real Dan Lyons None
- parislemon None
- TechCrunch None
- Daring Fireball None
- parislemon parislemon · MG Siegler