U.S. intelligence mining data from nine U.S. Internet companies in broad secret program
The National Security Agency and the FBI are tapping directly into the central servers of nine leading U.S. Internet companies, extracting audio, video, photographs, e-mails, documents and connection logs …
Context & Ripple Effects
Before this disclosure, the FBI had already called for legislation against online services that offer users strong security and proposed making the internet wiretap-ready. The reported collection program turns that policy push into a concrete question about how major internet platforms are built and governed.
The story travelled widely on June 6, while several companies named in contemporaneous coverage publicly denied participation. That split places the providers between government access demands and the need to account to users for how their systems handle sensitive information.
First-order effects
- The NSA and FBI gain access to audio, video, photographs, email, documents and connection logs from the nine companies’ central servers under the reported program.
- The affected internet companies face immediate demands to clarify their role, particularly after Facebook, Apple, Google, Microsoft, Dropbox and Yahoo denied participation in contemporaneous coverage.
Second-order effects
- The disclosure raises the political and commercial cost of the FBI’s proposed wiretap-ready internet rules, putting providers’ security design choices at the center of the surveillance debate.
- Services that market strong user security are more directly exposed to conflict with law-enforcement demands for access, given the FBI’s stated interest in penalizing services it considers too secure.
Third-order effects
- If access to major platforms becomes a durable surveillance mechanism, the boundary between private communications infrastructure and state intelligence collection shifts from exceptional requests toward system-level access.
- The episode points to a governance contest over whether internet services can independently set security and data-access limits when national-security agencies seek operational reach into their systems.
The trend: Internet-platform security is becoming a contested layer of state power, as law-enforcement access requirements collide with providers’ control over user data and system design.
Related: Public-data permission boundary · FBI · The National Security Agency · NSA slides explain the PRISM data-collection program · U.S. Agencies Said to Swap Data With Thousands of Firms
Related Coverage
- NSA slides explain the PRISM data-collection program Washington Post
- Anti-Surveillance Activist Is at Center of New Leak New York Times
- President Obama's Dragnet New York Times
- Facebook, Apple, Google, Microsoft, Dropbox and Yahoo deny participation in US government spying program PRISM The Next Web · Harrison Weber
- Twitter boosts its privacy cred with its absence from the NSA's surveillance program Quartz · Zachary M. Seward
- U.S. Collects Vast Data Trove Wall Street Journal · Jared A. Favole
- The NSA surveillance story reinforces why an entity like WikiLeaks is so important GigaOM · Mathew Ingram
- U.S. Government: Reports About PRISM Contain “Numerous Inaccuracies” TechCrunch · Frederic Lardinois
- Government acknowledges PRISM spying program, disputes details The Technology Chronicles · James Temple
- Internet tapping aimed at non-U.S. people outside U.S. : official Reuters · Mark Felsenthal
- Guardian None
- Guardian None
- The Next Web None
- Wall Street Journal None
- Computerworld None
- Fortune None
- Agence France Presse None
- Business Insider None
- FP Passport None
- AllThingsD None
- GigaOM None
- GigaOM None
- Help Net Security None
- Mediashift None
- Marketing Land None
- Wonkblog None
- TechEye None
- ZDNet None
- Reuters None
- Forbes None
- InfoWorld None
- DSLreports None
- VentureBeat None
- WebProNews None
- Macgasm None
- Corporate Intelligence None
- Gawker None
- Softpedia News None
- TechPresident None
- Neowin None
- CNET None
- Quartz None
- Electronista None
- VatorNews None
- bizjournals None
- TechSpot None
- Ubergizmo None
- BBC None
- Search Engine Watch None
- Hillicon Valley None
- SlashGear None
- iDownloadBlog.com None
- The Verge None
- BuzzFeed None
- Guardian Guardian
- The Next Web The Next Web · Jon Russell
- Wall Street Journal Wall Street Journal
- Computerworld Computerworld · Preston Gralla
- Fortune Fortune · Philip Elmer-DeWitt
- Agence France Presse Agence France Presse
- Business Insider Business Insider · Nicholas Carlson
- FP Passport FP Passport · Elias Groll
- AllThingsD AllThingsD · Arik Hesseldahl
- GigaOM GigaOM · David Meyer
- Help Net Security Help Net Security
- Mediashift Mediashift · Zach C. Cohen
- Marketing Land Marketing Land · Danny Sullivan
- Wonkblog Wonkblog · Timothy B. Lee
- TechEye TechEye · Nick Farrell
- ZDNet ZDNet · Zack Whittaker
- Reuters Reuters
- Forbes Forbes · Tim Worstall
- InfoWorld InfoWorld · Ted Samson
- DSLreports DSLreports
- VentureBeat VentureBeat · Rebecca Grant
- WebProNews WebProNews · Zach Walton
- Macgasm Macgasm · Phil Poccia
- Corporate Intelligence Corporate Intelligence · William Launder
- Gawker Gawker · Max Read
- Softpedia News Softpedia News · Lucian Parfeni
- TechPresident TechPresident · Nick Judd
- Neowin Neowin · John Callaham
- CNET CNET · Charles Cooper
- Quartz Quartz · Leo Mirani
- Electronista Electronista
- VatorNews VatorNews · Steven Loeb
- bizjournals bizjournals · Luke Stangel
- TechSpot TechSpot · Jesse Schoff
- Ubergizmo Ubergizmo · Edwin Kee
- BBC BBC
- Search Engine Watch Search Engine Watch · Shaun Nichols
- Hillicon Valley Hillicon Valley · Brendan Sasso
- SlashGear SlashGear · Brittany Hillen
- iDownloadBlog.com iDownloadBlog.com · Cody Lee
- The Verge The Verge · Carl Franzen
- BuzzFeed BuzzFeed
- 9to5Google None
- 9to5Mac None
- Lifehacker None
- Inquirer None
- Falkvinge on Infopolicy None
- www.idigitaltimes.co.uk None
- The Next Web None
- Ars Technica None
- BuzzFeed None
- Boing Boing None
- SiliconANGLE None
- Slate None
- Close Read None
- Quartz None
- The Atlantic Wire None
- 9to5Google 9to5Google · Ben Lovejoy
- 9to5Mac 9to5Mac · Ben Lovejoy
- Lifehacker Lifehacker · Alan Henry
- Inquirer Inquirer · Dave Neal
- Falkvinge on Infopolicy Falkvinge on Infopolicy · Rick Falkvinge
- www.idigitaltimes.co.uk www.idigitaltimes.co.uk · David Gilbert
- Ars Technica Ars Technica · Cyrus Farivar
- Boing Boing Boing Boing · Cory Doctorow
- SiliconANGLE SiliconANGLE · Mike Wheatley
- Slate Slate · William Saletan
- Close Read Close Read · Amy Davidson
- The Atlantic Wire The Atlantic Wire · Abby Ohlheiser
- Forbes None
- App Advice None
- ValueWalk None
- BGR None
- The Next Web None
- Guardian None
- T3 News None
- Digital Trends None
- App Advice App Advice · Bryan M. Wolfe
- ValueWalk ValueWalk · Aman Jain
- BGR BGR · Tero Kuittinen
- T3 News T3 News · Nick Cowen
- Digital Trends Digital Trends · Trevor Mogg
- Forbes None
- Computerworld None
- ZDNet None
- CNN None
- Gawker None
- TIME None
- VentureBeat None
- CNN CNN
- TIME TIME · Victor Luckerson
- Washington Post None
- Microsoft None
- SiliconANGLE None
- The Verge None
- Forbes None
- Computerworld None
- AllThingsD None
- BuzzFeed None
- Inquirer None
- Mashable None
- PhoneArena None
- Bloomberg None
- www.idigitaltimes.co.uk None
- Business Insider None
- VentureBeat None
- Softpedia News None
- Reuters None
- Washington Post Washington Post
- Microsoft Microsoft
- BuzzFeed BuzzFeed · Charlie Warzel
- Mashable Mashable · Alex Fitzpatrick
- Phone Arena Phone Arena
- Bloomberg Bloomberg
- SiliconANGLE None
- A VC None
- BetaNews None
- Professional Blog None
- Associated Press None
- The Raw Story None
- Telegraph None
- The Next Web None
- A VC A VC · Fred Wilson
- BetaNews BetaNews · Brian Fagioli
- Professional Blog Professional Blog · Chris Saad
- Associated Press Associated Press
- The Raw Story The Raw Story · Dominic Rushe
- Telegraph Telegraph · Raf Sanchez
- Mashable None
- VentureBeat None
- Quartz None
- Techdirt None
- Guardian None
- The Huffington Post None
- PhoneArena None
- Engadget None
- Techdirt Techdirt · Mike Masnick
- The Huffington Post The Huffington Post · Sam Stein
- Engadget Engadget · Richard Lawler
- Uncrunched None
- The Atlantic Online None
- Uncrunched Uncrunched · Michael Arrington
- The Atlantic Online The Atlantic Online
- ODNI Newsroom Feed None
- Guardian None
- Forbes None
- SlashGear None
- Quartz None
- ODNI Newsroom Feed ODNI Newsroom Feed
- ODNI Newsroom Feed None
- Business Insider None
- Forbes None
- Guardian None
- The Next Web None
- The Verge None
- Mashable None
- PC World None
- Gizmodo None
- PhoneArena None
- PC World PC World · John Ribeiro
- Gizmodo Gizmodo · Casey Chan