New Apple maps app under fire from users
Apple's map app renames the town of Hagley as Dudley - which is more than seven miles away — Inaccuracies and misplaced towns and cities in Apple's new map software have provoked anger from users. — In June Apple announced it would stop using Google Maps …
Context & Ripple Effects
Apple announced in June that it would stop using Google Maps, making its own mapping software a core part of the iOS experience. The location errors reported here align with widespread complaints about buggy iOS 6 mapping, turning a product transition into a visible test of Apple’s ability to replace a major third-party service.
First-order effects
- Users navigating with Apple’s new Maps app face erroneous place names and misplaced locations, including the Hagley-to-Dudley error cited in the report.
- Apple absorbs the reputational cost of mapping errors because it has replaced Google Maps rather than presenting the service as a third-party dependency.
Second-order effects
- Google Maps gains a clearer reliability contrast on iOS as Apple’s replacement draws complaints, preserving the strategic value of Google’s mapping product even after Apple’s break.
- Apple must prioritize correction of geographic data errors, since inaccurate search and directions undermine the wider iOS experience rather than a standalone optional app.
Third-order effects
- If platform owners replace foundational third-party services with their own software, data quality and operational reliability become as important as interface integration.
- The episode points to a mobile-platform contest in which control over core services brings greater differentiation but also transfers accountability for failures to the platform owner.
The trend: Mobile platform companies are bringing essential services in-house, trading dependence on partners for direct responsibility over quality and user trust.
Related: Apple · Google Maps · Apple’s buggy iOS 6 maps draw widespread complaints
Related Coverage
- That's not an airport, it's a farm - Irish Minister for Justice considers Apple's iOS 6 Maps dangerous The Sociable · Piers Dillon Scott
- As Google Maps Disappears In iOS 6, Google Remains Cagey About Releasing Its Own App Search Engine Land · Danny Sullivan
- Review: Refined iOS 6 highlighted by stunning Maps overhaul Macworld · Dan Moren
- Who benefits from iOS6's crappy maps? Anil Dash
- SiliconANGLE None
- BGR None
- Computerworld None
- ZDNet None
- InformationWeek None
- Bloomberg None
- Simon's Technology Blog None
- Pocket-lint None
- SlashGear None
- The Australian None
- TechCrunch None
- ReadWriteWeb None
- Josh Centers None
- SiliconANGLE SiliconANGLE · Mike Wheatley
- BGR BGR · Zach Epstein
- Computerworld Computerworld · Richi Jennings
- ZDNet ZDNet · Matthew Miller
- InformationWeek InformationWeek · Thomas Claburn
- Bloomberg Bloomberg
- Simon's Technology Blog Simon's Technology Blog · Simon
- Pocket-lint Pocket-lint · Rik Henderson
- SlashGear SlashGear · Chris Davies
- The Australian The Australian
- TechCrunch TechCrunch · Mike Butcher
- ReadWriteWeb ReadWriteWeb · Brian Proffitt
- Josh Centers Josh Centers
- Guardian None
- The Next Web None
- Guardian Guardian · Juliette Garside
- The Next Web The Next Web · Matt Brian
- 9to5Google None
- DailyFinance.com None
- Better Broadband Blog None
- Pulse2 Technology … None
- Wired.co.uk None
- The H Security None
- memeburn None
- PadGadget None
- TechSpot None
- Josh Centers None
- Mashable! None
- The Next Web None
- Marketing Land None
- Daring Fireball None
- 9to5Google 9to5Google · Élyse Betters
- DailyFinance.com DailyFinance.com
- Better Broadband Blog Better Broadband Blog · Dan Deeth
- Pulse2 Technology and Social Media News Pulse2 Technology and Social Media News · Amit Chowdhry
- Wired.co.uk Wired.co.uk · David Cornish
- The H Security The H Security
- memeburn memeburn
- PadGadget PadGadget · Lory
- TechSpot TechSpot · Matthew DeCarlo
- Mashable! Mashable! · Lance Ulanoff
- Marketing Land Marketing Land · Danny Sullivan
- Daring Fireball Daring Fireball · John Gruber
- The Verge None
- VentureBeat None
- Fortune None
- iMore.com None
- Search Engine Land None
- Pulse2 Technology … None
- SocialTimes None
- MacStories None
- TechCrunch None
- VoIP & Gadgets Blog None
- BGR None
- Ars Technica None
- MacStories None
- LAPTOP Magazine None
- Pogue's Posts None
- Ars Technica None
- TUAW None
- GigaOM None
- The Verge The Verge · Chris Welch
- VentureBeat VentureBeat · Jennifer Van Grove
- Fortune Fortune · Philip Elmer-DeWitt
- iMore.com iMore.com · Rene Ritchie
- Search Engine Land Search Engine Land · Matt McGee
- SocialTimes SocialTimes · Devon Glenn
- MacStories MacStories · Chris Herbert
- VoIP & Gadgets Blog VoIP & Gadgets Blog
- Ars Technica Ars Technica · Chris Foresman
- LAPTOP Magazine LAPTOP Magazine · Daniel P. Howley
- Pogue's Posts Pogue's Posts · David Pogue
- TUAW TUAW · Chris Rawson
- GigaOM GigaOM · Mark Crump
- Search Engine Land None
- Mashable! None
- New York Times None
- Gizmodo None
- About Foursquare None
- SocialTimes None
- ZDNet None
- Pluggd.in None
- MacStories None
- Business Insider None
- 9to5Mac None
- Forbes None
- parislemon None
- The Next Web None
- the understatement None
- BetaNews None
- ReadWriteWeb None
- Daring Fireball None
- The Tech Block None
- iDownloadBlog.com None
- New York Times New York Times · The New
- Gizmodo Gizmodo · Kyle Wagner
- About Foursquare About Foursquare · Chris Thompson
- Pluggd.in Pluggd.in · Jayadevan
- Business Insider Business Insider · Steve Kovach
- 9to5Mac 9to5Mac · Jordan Kahn
- Forbes Forbes · Tomio Geron
- parislemon parislemon · MG Siegler
- the understatement the understatement · Michael Degusta
- BetaNews BetaNews · Joe Wilcox
- The Tech Block The Tech Block · Jon Dick
- iDownloadBlog.com iDownloadBlog.com · Christian Zibreg