Samsung Vows to Fight Ban
SEOUL—Samsung Electronics said Tuesday it would fight Apple Inc.'s attempt to ban the sale of some of its smartphones in the U.S. with “all necessary measures.” — After winning a jury verdict for patent infringement against Samsung in a U.S. court last week …
Wall Street Journal Evan Ramstad
Context & Ripple Effects
Apple and Samsung have been litigating this dispute since Apple’s 2011 suit, with Samsung first pledging a counter-action to Apple’s patent case and then filing its own case over the iPhone and iPad. The jury’s infringement finding moves the immediate contest from liability to Apple’s requested remedy: removing some Samsung phones from the U.S. market.
Samsung’s pledge to use “all necessary measures” signals that the remedy fight will be as consequential as the verdict for the two companies’ U.S. smartphone competition.
First-order effects
- Samsung must defend the U.S. availability of the smartphones Apple seeks to ban, while Apple presses to convert its jury victory into a sales remedy.
Second-order effects
- The dispute shifts the companies’ competitive confrontation into court-supervised product access, making the scope of any ban a central issue rather than the verdict alone.
Third-order effects
- If patent verdicts increasingly lead to product-specific sales remedies, major device makers will treat litigation as a direct lever over rivals’ market access, not solely as a damages dispute.
The trend: The Apple-Samsung fight is part of a shift toward patent litigation that targets product availability alongside financial liability.
Related: Apple Inc. · Samsung · Samsung’s 2011 counter-action pledge · Samsung countersues Apple over iPhone and iPad
Related Coverage
- Samsung Case Puts Apple Closer to Google Fight New York Times
- Apple-Samsung jury foreman says evidence ‘spoke overwhelmingly’ Los Angeles Times · Andrea Chang
- Apple identifies which Samsung products it will try to ban in US The Verge · Matt Macari
- SiliconANGLE None
- San Francisco Chronicle None
- AppleInsider None
- VentureBeat None
- Associated Press None
- Gizmodo None
- BGR None
- Edible Apple None
- PhoneArena None
- Hillicon Valley None
- CNNMoney.com None
- Phones Review None
- Android News, Rumours … None
- SiliconANGLE SiliconANGLE · Mellisa Tolentino
- San Francisco Chronicle San Francisco Chronicle
- AppleInsider AppleInsider · Sam Oliver
- VentureBeat VentureBeat · Devindra Hardawar
- Associated Press Associated Press · Youkyung Lee
- Gizmodo Gizmodo · Brian Barrett
- BGR BGR · Zach Epstein
- Edible Apple Edible Apple
- Phone Arena Phone Arena
- Hillicon Valley Hillicon Valley · Jennifer Martinez
- CNNMoney.com CNNMoney.com · David Goldman
- Phones Review Phones Review · James
- Android News, Rumours, and Updates Android News, Rumours, and Updates · Colton Kaiser
- Tech Trader Daily None
- GigaOM None
- iDownloadBlog.com None
- TechCrunch None
- WSJ Blogs - WSJ None
- Wall Street Journal None
- Reuters None
- The Loop None
- Tech Trader Daily Tech Trader Daily · Tiernan Ray
- GigaOM GigaOM · Bobbie Johnson
- iDownloadBlog.com iDownloadBlog.com · Ed Sutherland
- TechCrunch TechCrunch · Ingrid Lunden
- WSJ Blogs - WSJ WSJ Blogs - WSJ · Steven Russolillo
- Wall Street Journal Wall Street Journal · Sven Grundberg
- Reuters Reuters · Alison Frankel
- The Loop The Loop · Jim Dalrymple
- The Verge None
- Fortune None
- Guardian None
- PC Pro None
- Tech Daily Dose None
- AllThingsD None
- Bloomberg None
- PhoneArena None
- 9to5Mac None
- VentureBeat None
- Mashable! None
- The Verge The Verge · Nathan Ingraham
- Fortune Fortune · Philip Elmer-DeWitt
- Guardian Guardian · Charles Arthur
- PC Pro PC Pro
- Tech Daily Dose Tech Daily Dose · Adam Mazmanian
- AllThingsD AllThingsD · John Paczkowski
- Bloomberg Bloomberg · Joel Rosenblatt
- 9to5Mac 9to5Mac · Seth Weintraub
- Mashable! Mashable! · Emily Price
- ReadWriteWeb None
- Inquirer None
- Guardian None
- DSLreports None
- San Francisco Chronicle None
- Phones Review None
- Bloomberg None
- The Droid Guy None
- iPhone in Canada Blog None
- Telegraph None
- TechEye None
- Pulse2 Technology … None
- Reuters None
- eWeek None
- Android News, Rumours … None
- Droid Life None
- Gizmodo None
- Techland None
- Macgasm None
- TUAW None
- Android and Me None
- ReadWriteWeb ReadWriteWeb · Dan Rowinski
- Inquirer Inquirer · Lee Bell
- DSLreports DSLreports
- The Droid Guy The Droid Guy · Melissa
- iPhone in Canada Blog iPhone in Canada Blog · Ryan St. Onge
- Telegraph Telegraph · Emma Barnett
- TechEye TechEye · Nick Farrell
- Pulse2 Technology and Social Media News Pulse2 Technology and Social Media News · Amit Chowdhry
- eWeek eWeek · Don Reisinger
- Droid Life Droid Life · Tim-o-tato
- Techland Techland
- Macgasm Macgasm · Andrew Kunesh
- TUAW TUAW · Mike Schramm
- Android and Me Android and Me · Nick Gray