CurrentC alerts users of its pilot program that some email addresses were stolen by hackers
Wal-Mart's Answer To Apple Pay Has Already Been Hacked — Here's a bad sign for CurrentC, the fledgling mobile payment system in development by a consortium of retailers.
Context & Ripple Effects
The breach lands four days after a widely shared teardown of CurrentC as a clunky, privacy-heavy bid by Walmart, CVS and other retailers to sidestep card fees, so the story hits a product already under scrutiny. The pickup list — TechCrunch, CNBC, The Verge, Re/code, 9to5Mac, AppleInsider — shows how closely the Apple Pay-versus-retailers fight is being watched.
MCX's response, reported by TechCrunch, is that the theft happened at an email provider rather than in CurrentC's own systems, and that the consortium is open to dropping QR codes for NFC and relaxing exclusivity — a notable softening given that MacRumors simultaneously confirmed retailer exclusivity remains the rule, just without fines for leaving.
First-order effects
- CurrentC's pilot users are directly exposed — some had email addresses stolen — forcing MCX into damage control before the wallet has even launched broadly.
- MCX must defend its security posture publicly while conceding flexibility on QR codes and non-exclusivity, weakening two pillars of the original design.
Second-order effects
- Consortium members weighing exclusivity now have a public security stumble to point to, making it easier for retailers like Target — reportedly developing its own mobile wallet — to justify going solo.
Third-order effects
- The pattern that follows in this corpus points to fragmentation: MCX eventually postpones CurrentC's rollout and pivots to bank deals, shuts down the beta entirely, and members like CVS launch their own CVS Pay app — the retailer-consortium wallet giving way to single-retailer apps.
The trend: Retailer-owned payment consortia are losing ground to phone-native wallets, with security stumbles accelerating a split into individual retailer apps and bank partnerships.
Related: CurrentC · A look at CurrentC, the clunky and creepy mobile payments app · MCX postpones rollout of CurrentC, lays off 30 · MCX to disable all CurrentC accounts as beta test ends · Wal-Mart
Related Coverage
- MCX: open to switching from QR codes to NFC and non-exclusivity; reported hack only occurred at email provider TechCrunch
- MCX Confirms Retailer Exclusivity for CurrentC Mobile Payments, but No Fines for Leaving Consortium MacRumors · Eric Slivka
- CNBC None
- TechCrunch None
- The Verge None
- 9to5Mac None
- Re/code None
- AppleInsider None
- Gizmodo None
- The Technology Chronicles None
- MacRumors None
- TUAW None
- Ars Technica None
- Consumerist None
- MacDailyNews None
- VentureBreak None
- SlashGear None
- DailyTech None
- TechnoBuffalo None
- Finextra Research news None
- CNNMoney.com None
- Gigaom None
- PhoneNews.com None
- dailywireless.org None
- O'Grady's PowerPage None
- The Daily Dot None
- Tech Times None
- iDownloadBlog.com None
- The Next Web None
- Engadget None
- iPhone in Canada Blog None
- Cult of Mac None
- The Hill None
- BGR None
- Electronista None
- iMore None
- Gizmodo UK None
- CNBC CNBC · Cadie Thompson
- TechCrunch TechCrunch · Sarah Perez
- The Verge The Verge · Colin Lecher
- 9to5Mac 9to5Mac · Mark Gurman
- Re/code Re/code · Jason Del Rey
- AppleInsider AppleInsider · Neil Hughes
- Gizmodo Gizmodo · Kate Knibbs
- The Technology Chronicles The Technology Chronicles · Wendy Lee
- MacRumors MacRumors · Eric Slivka
- TUAW TUAW · Yoni Heisler
- Ars Technica Ars Technica · Megan Geuss
- Consumerist Consumerist · Chris Morran
- MacDailyNews MacDailyNews
- VentureBreak VentureBreak · Brad Merrill
- SlashGear SlashGear · Nate Swanner
- DailyTech DailyTech · Brandon Hill
- TechnoBuffalo TechnoBuffalo · Brandon Russell
- Finextra Research news Finextra Research news
- CNNMoney.com CNNMoney.com · Jose Pagliery
- Gigaom Gigaom · Kevin Fitchard
- PhoneNews.com PhoneNews.com · Humberto Saabedra
- dailywireless.org dailywireless.org · Sam Churchill
- O'Grady's PowerPage O'Grady's PowerPage · Chris Barylick
- The Daily Dot The Daily Dot · Allen Weiner
- Tech Times Tech Times · Nicole Arce
- iDownloadBlog.com iDownloadBlog.com · Christian Zibreg
- The Next Web The Next Web · Josh Ong
- Engadget Engadget · Nicole Lee
- iPhone in Canada Blog iPhone in Canada Blog · Gary Ng
- Cult of Mac Cult of Mac · Buster Hein
- The Hill The Hill · Julian Hattem
- BGR BGR · Brad Reed
- Electronista Electronista
- iMore iMore · Joseph Keller
- Gizmodo UK Gizmodo UK · Brian Barrett
- New York Times None
- The Daily Dot None
- TIME None
- The Verge None
- Mercury News None
- Macworld None
- AppleInsider None
- Fortune None
- ReadWrite None
- BGR None
- The Next Web None
- New York Times New York Times · Mike Isaac
- TIME TIME · Alex Fitzpatrick
- Mercury News Mercury News · Jeremy C. Owens
- Macworld Macworld · Caitlin McGarry
- Fortune Fortune · Benjamin Snyder
- ReadWrite ReadWrite · Owen Thomas
- iMore None
- TechCrunch None
- Daring Fireball None
- Wired None
- Business Insider None
- AppleInsider None
- The Daily Dot None
- Bank Innovation None
- Daring Fireball Daring Fireball · John Gruber
- Wired Wired · Davey Alba
- Business Insider Business Insider
- Bank Innovation Bank Innovation · Philip Ryan