Thanks To “Right To Be Forgotten,” Google Now Censors The Press In The EU
The EU's Right To Be Forgotten removals have been happening for about a week on Google, and now news publications are discovering the fallout. For some searches, you can't find their news stories relating to certain people.
Marketing Land Danny Sullivan
Context & Ripple Effects
The mechanics were mapped early: a May 2014 explainer separated the myths from the realities of how the EU's new right-to-be-forgotten rule would actually operate inside Google, and reporting on June 9 already spotted tell-tale signs of removals reshaping European result pages. What was then an abstract compliance question has turned concrete within a week of enforcement.
First-order effects
- News organizations are the immediate casualties: Guardian articles covering named individuals have been confirmed hidden from Google results shown to EU users, meaning European readers searching those names simply cannot find the journalism.
- Publishers lose referral visibility on specific person-name queries overnight, with no advance notice of which stories have been delisted.
Second-order effects
- Rivals and other newsrooms must now audit their own archives against removal requests and decide whether to contest delistings through Google's review process or accept the lost reach.
- The BBC, Businessweek, Business Insider and others picking up the story signals the fallout is being treated as a press-freedom issue, not a search-quality quirk, raising the reputational stakes for how Google processes each request.
Third-order effects
- If delisting at this scale holds, search engines become de facto arbiters of which journalism Europeans can find, institutionalizing a structural gap between what readers inside and outside the EU see for the same query.
- That gap pressures regulators and platforms alike to define who reviews removal decisions — a private company's judgment call standing in for due process on press visibility.
The trend: Deletion-by-request regimes are turning search intermediaries into gatekeepers of press visibility, with publishers discovering their archives one hidden result at a time.
Related: EU's right to be forgotten: Guardian articles have been hidden by Google · The Myths & Realities Of How Of The EU's New “Right To Be Forgotten” In Google Works · Publisher controls for AI search · Google · EU
Related Coverage
- BBC News BBC News · Robert Peston
- Digital Trends Digital Trends · Andy Boxall
- Guardian Guardian · Chris Moran
- Search Engine Watch Search Engine Watch · Carly Page
- Business Insider Business Insider · Jim Edwards
- SiliconBeat SiliconBeat · Brandon Bailey
- Daily Mail Daily Mail
- Businessweek Businessweek · Joshua Brustein
- Engadget Engadget · Sharif Sakr
- Salon Salon · Andrew Leonard
- All All · Gayana Sarkisova
- Wired Wired · Marcus Wohlsen
- Gigaom Gigaom · David Meyer
- New York Times New York Times · Mark Scott
- PandoDaily PandoDaily · Nathaniel Mott
- TIME TIME · Victor Luckerson
- Quartz Quartz · Leo Mirani
- Wall Street Journal Wall Street Journal · John Edwards
- PC World PC World · Loek Essers
- Associated Press Associated Press · Juergen Baetz
- Electronista Electronista
- The Hill The Hill · Julian Hattem
- 9to5Google 9to5Google · Ben Lovejoy
- Gizmodo Gizmodo · Mario Aguilar
- Forbes Forbes · Guy Clapperton
- Fortune Fortune · Geoffrey Smith
- WebProNews WebProNews · Chris Crum
- The Verge The Verge · Adi Robertson
- Re/code Re/code · Catherine Boyle
- Nextgov Nextgov · Polly Mosendz
- Tech Times Tech Times · Anu Passary
- VentureBeat VentureBeat · Harrison Weber
- CNET CNET · Luke Westaway
- TechPresident TechPresident · Micah L. Sifry
- Pocket-lint Pocket-lint · Rik Henderson
- Techdirt Techdirt · Mike Masnick
- PC Magazine PC Magazine · Chloe Albanesius
- Search Engine Land Search Engine Land · Barry Schwartz
- FierceEnterpriseCommunications … FierceEnterpriseCommunications … · Scott M. Fulton, III
- BGR BGR · Tero Kuittinen
- @mathewi @mathewi · Mathew Ingram
- @jimmy_wales @jimmy_wales · Jimmy Wales
- @pmarca @pmarca · Marc Andreessen
- @dannysullivan @dannysullivan · Danny Sullivan
- @robpegoraro @robpegoraro · Rob Pegoraro
- @beschizza @beschizza · Rob Beschizza
- View article BBC News
- View article Digital Trends
- View article Guardian
- View article Guardian
- View article Search Engine Watch
- View article Business Insider
- View article SiliconBeat
- View article Daily Mail
- View article Businessweek
- View article Engadget
- View article Salon
- View article All
- View article Wired
- View article Gigaom
- View article New York Times
- View article PandoDaily
- View article TIME
- View article Quartz
- View article Wall Street Journal
- View article PC World
- View article Associated Press
- View article Electronista
- View article The Hill
- View article 9to5Google
- View article Gizmodo
- View article Forbes
- View article Fortune
- View article WebProNews
- View article The Verge
- View article Re/code
- View article Nextgov
- View article Tech Times
- View article VentureBeat
- View article CNET
- View article TechPresident
- View article Pocket-lint
- View article Techdirt
- View article Forbes
- View article PC Magazine
- View article Search Engine Land
- View article FierceEnterpriseCommunications …
- View article Business Insider
- View article Guardian
- View article BGR
- View article @mathewi
- View article @jimmy_wales
- View article @pmarca
- View article @dannysullivan
- View article @robpegoraro
- View article @beschizza