Official Statement from the family and partner of Aaron Swartz
Our beloved brother, son, friend, and partner Aaron Swartz hanged himself on Friday in his Brooklyn apartment. We are in shock, and have not yet come to terms with his passing. — Aaron's insatiable curiosity, creativity …
Context & Ripple Effects
The family's statement lands hours after news broke of Swartz's death on Friday, and it does more than mourn: it assigns cause, framing the 26-year-old's suicide against the federal hacking indictment he had carried since his 2011 arrest for downloading millions of academic articles through MIT's network — an act that echoed his earlier mass release of paywalled federal court records in 2009.
The story travels fast and wide: MIT's own paper breaks the death, then AllThingsD picks up both the family's accusation that MIT and the U.S. Attorney contributed to it and MIT's announcement of an internal investigation, while Lawrence Lessig publishes a 'Prosecutor as bully' post directing anger at the charging decisions themselves.
First-order effects
- MIT faces immediate reputational exposure and responds by opening an internal investigation into its role in the events leading to Swartz's arrest and prosecution.
- The U.S. Attorney's office and its handling of the case become the named target of public blame, shifting the story from tragedy to accountability fight within a day.
Second-order effects
- Researchers begin posting paywalled journal PDFs publicly under the #pdftribute hashtag, turning grief into direct action aimed at the academic publishing paywall system Swartz was charged under.
- JSTOR and MIT, the institutions whose resources sat at the center of the indictment, face renewed questions about why a case JSTOR had reportedly moved past still proceeded criminally.
Third-order effects
- If the pattern holds, the case becomes the reference point for arguments that computer-crime statutes give prosecutors too much discretion over charging and plea leverage — a debate likely to reach Congress and the courts.
- Open-access advocacy gains a defining figurehead, raising the political cost for universities and publishers defending subscription paywalls against systematic downloading.
The trend: Swartz's death is accelerating the collision between open-access activism and the criminal enforcement of computer-misuse law, with universities and prosecutors now forced to defend how such cases are charged.
Related: Aaron Swartz · Aaron Swartz commits suicide · Losing Aaron: Bob Swartz on MIT's Role in His Son's Death
Related Coverage
- MIT Responds to Death of Activist Aaron Swartz, Begins Internal Investigation AllThingsD · Mike Isaac
- The Truth about Aaron Swartz's “Crime” Unhandled Exception · Alex Stamos
- Family of Hacktivist Aaron Swartz Accuses MIT, U.S. Attorney of Contributing to His Suicide AllThingsD · Mike Isaac
- Prosecutor as bully Lessig Blog, v2 · Lawrence Lessig
- Researchers begin posting article PDFs to twitter in #pdftribute to Aaron Swartz Neuroconscience · Micah Allen
- JSTOR None
- Quinn Norton None
- Slashdot None
- Danny O'Brien's Oblomovka None
- petitions.whitehouse.gov None
- CNN None
- TorrentFreak None
- Philip Greenspun's Weblog None
- Ars Technica None
- The Verge None
- ZDNet None
- Bloomberg None
- Softpedia News None
- CNET None
- SocialTimes None
- CNET None
- Neowin None
- digitaltrends.com None
- Digital Media Wire None
- BostInno None
- Forbes None
- Ars Technica None
- TechCrunch None
- Business Insider None
- Daily Mail None
- GigaOM None
- Boing Boing None
- SiliconANGLE None
- BuzzFeed None
- Doc Searls Weblog None
- Guardian None
- The Daily Caller None
- JSTOR JSTOR
- Quinn Norton Quinn Norton
- Slashdot Slashdot · Samzenpus
- Danny O'Brien's Oblomovka Danny O'Brien's Oblomovka · Danny O'Brien
- petitions.whitehouse.gov petitions.whitehouse.gov
- CNN CNN · Michael Martinez
- TorrentFreak TorrentFreak · Ernesto
- Philip Greenspun's Weblog Philip Greenspun's Weblog · Philg
- Ars Technica Ars Technica · Cyrus Farivar
- The Verge The Verge · Joshua Kopstein
- ZDNet ZDNet · Violet Blue
- Bloomberg Bloomberg
- Softpedia News Softpedia News
- CNET CNET · Charles Cooper
- SocialTimes SocialTimes · Devon Glenn
- Neowin Neowin · John Callaham
- digitaltrends.com digitaltrends.com · Trevor Mogg
- Digital Media Wire Digital Media Wire · Ned Sherman
- BostInno BostInno · Lauren Landry
- Forbes Forbes · Daniel Nye Griffiths
- TechCrunch TechCrunch · John Biggs
- Business Insider Business Insider · Owen Thomas
- Daily Mail Daily Mail · Snejana Farberov
- GigaOM GigaOM · Mathew Ingram
- Boing Boing Boing Boing · Cory Doctorow
- SiliconANGLE SiliconANGLE · John Furrier
- BuzzFeed BuzzFeed · Summer Anne Burton
- Doc Searls Weblog Doc Searls Weblog
- Guardian Guardian · Martin Pengelly
- The Daily Caller The Daily Caller · Josh Peterson
- Pastebin.com None
- CNET None
- The Verge None
- Ars Technica None
- TechCrunch None
- VentureBeat None
- Business Insider None
- Politico None
- Pastebin.com Pastebin.com
- VentureBeat VentureBeat · Dylan Tweney
- Politico Politico · Josh Gerstein
- danah boyd None
- Joho the Blog None
- Business Week None
- Ars Technica None
- The Laboratorium None
- Creative Commons None
- Boing Boing None
- Wikimedia blog None
- Lessig Blog, v2 None
- CNET None
- Crooked Timber None
- Guardian None
- MetaFilter None
- Search Engine Land None
- SiliconANGLE None
- Business Insider None
- Errata Security None
- The Verge None
- danah boyd danah boyd · Zephoria
- Joho the Blog Joho the Blog · Davidw
- Business Week Business Week · Brendan Greeley
- The Laboratorium The Laboratorium · James Grimmelmann
- Creative Commons Creative Commons
- Wikimedia blog Wikimedia blog · Erik Moeller
- Lessig Blog, v2 Lessig Blog, v2 · Lawrence Lessig
- Crooked Timber Crooked Timber · Henry
- MetaFilter MetaFilter · Llama-Lime
- Search Engine Land Search Engine Land · Danny Sullivan
- Errata Security Errata Security · Robert Graham
- The Verge None
- TheTechStorm None
- TheTechStorm TheTechStorm · Storm Williams
- Electronic Frontier Foundation None
- GeekWire None
- TIME None
- msnbc.com None
- Crooked Timber None
- Susie Bright's Journal None
- CNET None
- BetaNews None
- The Verge None
- Business Insider None
- Wonkblog None
- Internet Archive Blogs None
- U.S. News None
- The Register None
- heyjude.wordpress.com None
- Jillian C. York None
- Freedom to Tinker None
- Guardian None
- TechSpot None
- somersetbean.blogspot.com.au None
- TUAW None
- The Adventures … None
- Mashable! None
- Web 2.0 Asia Blog None
- confused of calcutta None
- Dan Gillmor None
- The Laboratorium None
- The Lede None
- New York Times None
- Wired None
- AfterDawn.com None
- BuzzMachine None
- thenation.com/blogs/171686 None
- Softpedia News None
- Examiner None
- PC World None
- SlashGear None
- The Atlantic Online None
- BostInno None
- ABCNEWS None
- LJ INFOdocket None
- Weblogsky None
- The Hill None
- Joho the Blog None
- Howard Lindzon None
- Geekosystem None
- The Huffington Post None
- VentureBeat None
- Gothamist None
- Gizmodo None
- Digits None
- MIT's The Tech None
- The Daily Caller None
- Gawker None
- Remember Aaron Swartz None
- Featured stories None
- AllThingsD None
- The Loop None
- kottke.org None
- Memex 1.1 None
- Daring Fireball None
- rc3.org None
- Nerdcore None
- Electronic Frontier Foundation Electronic Frontier Foundation · Peter Eckersley
- GeekWire GeekWire · Kathy Gill
- TIME TIME · Sam Gustin
- msnbc.com msnbc.com · Chris Hayes
- Susie Bright's Journal Susie Bright's Journal · Susie Bright
- BetaNews BetaNews · Joe Wilcox
- Wonkblog Wonkblog · Tim Lee
- Internet Archive Blogs Internet Archive Blogs · Brewster
- U.S. News U.S. News · Isolde Raftery
- The Register The Register · Iain Thomson
- heyjude.wordpress.com heyjude.wordpress.com · Judy O'Connell
- Jillian C. York Jillian C. York
- Freedom to Tinker Freedom to Tinker · Steve Schultze
- TechSpot TechSpot · Matthew DeCarlo
- somersetbean.blogspot.com.au somersetbean.blogspot.com.au
- TUAW TUAW · Michael Rose
- The Adventures of Accordion Guy … The Adventures of Accordion Guy … · Joey deVilla
- Mashable! Mashable! · Alex Fitzpatrick
- Web 2.0 Asia Blog Web 2.0 Asia Blog
- confused of calcutta confused of calcutta
- Dan Gillmor Dan Gillmor
- The Lede The Lede
- New York Times New York Times · John Schwartz
- Wired Wired · Kevin Poulsen
- AfterDawn.com AfterDawn.com
- BuzzMachine BuzzMachine · Jeff Jarvis
- thenation.com/blogs/171686 blogs/171686 · thenation.com
- Examiner Examiner · Michael Santo
- PC World PC World · Juan Carlos Perez
- SlashGear SlashGear · Chris Davies
- The Atlantic Online The Atlantic Online · James Fallows
- ABCNEWS ABCNEWS · Alyssa Newcomb
- LJ INFOdocket LJ INFOdocket · Gary Price
- Weblogsky Weblogsky · Jonl
- The Hill The Hill · Brendan Sasso
- Howard Lindzon Howard Lindzon
- Geekosystem Geekosystem · Rollin Bishop
- The Huffington Post The Huffington Post · Chris Gentilviso
- Gothamist Gothamist · Jen Chung
- Gizmodo Gizmodo · Eric Limer
- Digits Digits · Matthew Lynley
- MIT's The Tech MIT's The Tech · Anne Cai
- Gawker Gawker · Taylor Berman
- Remember Aaron Swartz Remember Aaron Swartz
- Featured stories Featured stories · Alex Howard
- AllThingsD AllThingsD · John Paczkowski
- The Loop The Loop · Peter Cohen
- kottke.org kottke.org · Jason Kottke
- Memex 1.1 Memex 1.1
- Daring Fireball Daring Fireball · John Gruber
- rc3.org rc3.org · Rafe
- Nerdcore Nerdcore
- CNET None
- PC Magazine None
- Science Citizen None
- Gizmodo None
- Aid Economics None
- PC Magazine PC Magazine · David Murphy
- Science Citizen Science Citizen · Jessica
- Aid Economics Aid Economics · Eva