Our test finds new iPad hits 116 degrees while running games
The new iPad can run significantly hotter than the earlier iPad2 model when running an action game, Consumer Reports testers have found. — Using a thermal imaging camera, Consumer Reports engineers recorded temperatures …
Consumer Reports News Donna L. Tapellini
Context & Ripple Effects
The finding lands on a tester Apple already knows well: Consumer Reports declined to recommend the iPhone 4 in 2010 and held that line even after Apple ended its free-case program. Applying thermal imaging to the new iPad extends the same playbook — instrumented, third-party measurement of flagship hardware — to a product that by late 2011 accounted for roughly 97% of tablet web traffic.
The story traveled unusually fast for a single test result, drawing same-day pickups at CNET, AllThingsD, TechCrunch, Computerworld and the Telegraph. The framing split quickly: a CNET-quoted expert pointed to the LED backlight as the likely culprit, while some commentators such as Marco.org dismissed the write-up as sensationalism, and AllThingsD characterized Apple's response as chilly — leaving the heat claim contested rather than settled in the first news cycle.
First-order effects
- Apple's launch-week narrative for the new iPad now carries a quantified defect claim from a widely trusted reviewer, forcing a public-response decision on a product otherwise defined by its Retina display upgrade.
- Shoppers choosing between the new iPad and the still-on-sale iPad 2 gain a concrete, measurable hesitation point about whether the upgrade is worth it, since the test pegs the new model significantly hotter than its predecessor under sustained gaming.
Second-order effects
- Android tablet makers get an easy comparison point against a rival that dominates tablet usage share, letting them compete on thermals rather than matching the Retina display spec-for-spec.
- The disputed cause — backlight versus chipset versus chassis design — pushes Apple's component suppliers and thermal engineers into a public engineering debate, since whichever explanation wins shapes what Apple changes in the next revision.
Third-order effects
- Independent lab measurement is consolidating as a reputational gatekeeper for consumer hardware: between the 2010 iPhone 4 call and this heat test, Consumer Reports has twice shown it can define the risk narrative around Apple launches regardless of how Apple responds.
- As fanless tablets keep adding display resolution and processing power within fixed thermal envelopes, sustained-load temperature looks set to become a standard benchmark dimension across the tablet industry, not just an Apple-specific quibble.
The trend: Tablet makers pushing brighter displays and faster chips into sealed, fanless slabs are turning third-party thermal benchmarks into a recurring competitive battleground alongside speed and battery life.
Related: Consumer Reports · iPad · iPad2 · Not So Hot: New iPad Heat Levels Comparable to Android Tablets · The new iPad Gobbles Up 5% of All iPad Traffic; CA, CT & NY new iPad “Hot Spots”
Related Coverage
- LED backlight a likely culprit in iPad heat issue, says expert CNET · Brooke Crothers
- More Consumer Reports sensationalism Marco.org · Marco Arment
- Apple's Chilly Response to iPad Heat Complaints AllThingsD · Peter Kafka
- Inquirer None
- Telegraph None
- Computerworld None
- TechCrunch None
- The Loop None
- Social Media None
- Agence France Presse None
- GSMArena Blog None
- TG Daily None
- CNET None
- Reuters None
- USA Today None
- The Next Web None
- Pulse2 Technology … None
- eWeek None
- The Next Web None
- Examiner None
- Softpedia News None
- PhoneArena None
- Computerworld UK Mobiles … None
- CNET None
- TechnoBuffalo None
- Washington Post None
- Gizmodo None
- Ars Technica None
- LAPTOP Magazine None
- PadGadget None
- Gotta Be Mobile None
- Network World None
- PC World None
- Wall Street Journal None
- 9to5Mac None
- Appolicious Advisor None
- Neowin.net None
- BetaNews None
- The Technology Chronicles None
- IntoMobile None
- DVICE None
- discussions.apple.com None
- MacRumors None
- DailyTech None
- Wall Street Journal None
- gdgt None
- parislemon None
- Business Insider None
- T3 News None
- Inquirer Inquirer · Dave Neal
- Telegraph Telegraph · Shane Richmond
- Computerworld Computerworld · Jonny Evans
- TechCrunch TechCrunch · Mg Siegler
- The Loop The Loop · Jim Dalrymple
- Social Media Social Media · Darcy Travlos
- Agence France Presse Agence France Presse
- GSMArena Blog GSMArena Blog · Peter
- TG Daily TG Daily · Emma Woollacott
- CNET CNET · Eric Franklin
- Reuters Reuters · Edwin Chan
- USA Today USA Today · Scott Martin
- The Next Web The Next Web · Matthew Panzarino
- Pulse2 Technology and Social Media News Pulse2 Technology and Social Media News · Amit Chowdhry
- eWeek eWeek · Nicholas Kolakowski
- Examiner Examiner · Michael Santo
- Softpedia News Softpedia News
- Phone Arena Phone Arena
- Computerworld UK Mobiles and Wireless Computerworld UK Mobiles and Wireless · Agam Shah
- TechnoBuffalo TechnoBuffalo · Todd Haselton
- Washington Post Washington Post · Hayley Tsukayama
- Gizmodo Gizmodo · Sam Biddle
- Ars Technica Ars Technica · Jacqui Cheng
- LAPTOP Magazine LAPTOP Magazine
- PadGadget PadGadget · Juli
- Gotta Be Mobile Gotta Be Mobile · Warner Crocker
- Network World Network World · Brad Reed
- PC World PC World · Agam Shah
- Wall Street Journal Wall Street Journal · Ian Sherr
- 9to5Mac 9to5Mac · Jordan Kahn
- Appolicious Advisor Appolicious Advisor · Marty Gabel
- Neowin.net Neowin.net · John Callaham
- BetaNews BetaNews · Ed Oswald
- The Technology Chronicles The Technology Chronicles · Jason Lloren
- IntoMobile IntoMobile · Kelly Hodgkins
- DVICE DVICE · Raymond Wong
- discussions.apple.com discussions.apple.com
- MacRumors MacRumors · Jordan Golson
- DailyTech DailyTech · Brandon Hill
- gdgt gdgt · Ryan Block
- parislemon parislemon · MG Siegler
- Business Insider Business Insider · Jay Yarow
- T3 News T3 News · Chris Smith
- 9to5Mac None
- Softpedia News None
- Computerworld None
- PadGadget None
- USA Today None
- Computerworld None
- The Apple Core Blog None
- Gadgetsteria None
- TechnoBuffalo None
- WebProNews None
- VentureBeat None
- The Register None
- Bloomberg None
- 9to5Mac None
- The Loop None
- TechSpot None
- CNET None
- The Verge None
- BGR None
- blog.chron.com None
- App Advice None
- TUAW None
- Appolicious Advisor None
- Los Angeles Times None
- Computerworld None
- The Apple Core Blog The Apple Core Blog · Jason D. O'Grady
- Gadgetsteria Gadgetsteria · Mike Norris
- WebProNews WebProNews · Shaylin Clark
- VentureBeat VentureBeat · Devindra Hardawar
- The Register The Register · Richard Chirgwin
- Bloomberg Bloomberg · Sarah Frier
- TechSpot TechSpot · Shawn Knight
- The Verge The Verge · Nathan Ingraham
- BGR BGR · Dan Graziano
- blog.chron.com blog.chron.com · Dwight Silverman
- App Advice App Advice · Bryan M. Wolfe
- TUAW TUAW · Kelly Hodgkins
- Los Angeles Times Los Angeles Times · Nathan Olivarez-Giles