Tasks, not search, at DEMOfall08
Philipp Lenssen points to a video of a DEMOfall08 panel on “Where the Web is Going” that included Peter Norvig from Google and Prabhakar Raghavan from Yahoo. — What is notable in the talk is that (starting at 12:32) Prabhakar and Peter agree that …
Context & Ripple Effects
By late 2008, both Google and Yahoo had spent years framing themselves around search — a rivalry chronicled in coverage like the people-search wars and questions about where Google stood as the web evolved. So when Peter Norvig and Prabhakar Raghavan, the search quality chiefs of the two companies, appeared together on a DEMOfall08 'Where the Web is Going' panel (video surfaced by Philipp Lenssen), their agreement carried weight. Norvig had already been articulating Google's longer-term view in interviews such as his Technology Review Q&A, making this panel a rare moment of convergence between rivals.
First-order effects
- Two competing search leaders publicly reframed their own category: Norvig and Raghavan agreed that the web's future is about completing tasks, not issuing queries — an implicit admission that the search box is a means, not the destination.
- The agreement signals product direction at both companies: expect investment to shift from ranking results toward tools that finish jobs for users, with each firm interpreting 'tasks' through its own assets.
Second-order effects
- If the gatekeepers stop optimizing for clicks on blue links, the economics of the sites that depend on referral traffic come under pressure — a tension that resurfaces today in debates over AI Overviews and clickthrough rates.
- Competitors and startups reading the same signal would race to build task-completion experiences, shifting differentiation from index size and ranking quality to intent understanding and action execution.
Third-order effects
- The pattern points toward search engines becoming agentic work surfaces — interfaces that act on a user's behalf rather than list options — restructuring how value flows between users, engines, and publishers.
- Over the long run, this reframing erodes the query-as-unit-of-measurement model, forcing new metrics for success and new settlement mechanisms between answer providers and content owners.
The trend: This panel is an early data point in the industry's slow migration from search-as-listing to task completion — the trajectory that culminates in today's AI assistants and answer engines.