Sources: OpenAI and Anthropic quietly lobby Washington regulators to restrict open-source AI models, even as Sam Altman publicly says he supports open source AI
Anthropic and OpenAI are clashing with the rest of the tech industry over whether “open-source” models from China should be freely available or restricted.
New York Times
Context & Ripple Effects
The lobbying push extends OpenAI’s earlier call to bar PRC-produced models and equipment on security and privacy grounds, but now places OpenAI and Anthropic in a visible policy conflict with other technology companies over availability of Chinese open-source models.
It also follows the labs’ participation in Frontier Model Forum information-sharing on adversarial distillation, showing how coordination around frontier-model risks is increasingly intersecting with government access policy.
First-order effects
- Washington regulators face a coordinated request from OpenAI and Anthropic to limit availability of Chinese open-source models, while the two labs become more clearly opposed to the broader tech industry on that question.
- The gap between Sam Altman’s public support for open source and OpenAI’s reported lobbying position creates immediate scrutiny of how the company distinguishes open development from access to foreign models.
Second-order effects
- Open-source advocates and companies that build on broadly available models have stronger reason to contest restrictions, framing model availability as a competitive and ecosystem issue rather than solely a safety question.
- If regulators take up the request, model distributors and enterprise users would need to assess whether a model’s Chinese origin creates new access or compliance risk before deployment.
Third-order effects
- The dispute points toward AI model access becoming a geopolitical control point: governments may increasingly treat model provenance and distribution as matters of strategic policy, not just software licensing.
- If this approach spreads, the AI ecosystem could split more sharply between nationally acceptable model supply chains and a contested global open-model commons, though the article does not establish that restrictions will be adopted.
The trend: This is part of the shift from voluntary frontier-AI safety coordination toward state-mediated control over which models can circulate across borders.
Related: Model access as geopolitical control · AI Commons as Critical Infrastructure · State-mediated AI · OpenAI’s call to ban PRC-produced models · Frontier Model Forum information sharing · OpenAI
Related Coverage
- US reportedly favors selective bans over blanket restrictions on Chinese open weight models citing security concerns The Decoder · Matthias Bastian
- OpenAI quietly signs letter from Nvidia, Microsoft, and Meta warning about dangers of ‘premature restrictions’ … TechRadar · David Nield
- Silicon Valley is split over open-source AI and how to react to Chinese AI The Boston Globe
- Nvidia Open Weights Letter Doubled To 50 Without Amazon And Anthropic Forbes · Sandy Carter
- OpenAI and Anthropic Lobby Washington to Restrict Chinese Open-Weight AI Implicator.ai · Marcus Schuler
- MoonShot CEO Says “OpenAI Didn't Invent Anything New,” As Sam Altman Signs The Letter Calling For Open-Weight AI Models After The Fact And Under Pressure Wccftech · Rohail Saleem
- Microsoft, Nvidia, Meta and 22 others defended open weights. Anthropic and OpenAI didn't sign. The New Stack · Matthew Burns
- Tech leaders lobby against restrictions on open-source AI PitchBook · Jacob Robbins
- Nvidia and 24 other companies sign open-weights letter as Washington weighs Chinese AI model ban — OpenAI, Anthropic, and Google absent from the list Tom's Hardware · Luke James
- Nvidia, Microsoft Lead Call for Open-Weight AI Models After Kimi Bloomberg · Michael Shepard
- Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang leads charge for open source AI GamesBeat · Dean Takahashi
- Nvidia's CEO Wants to Support Open AI Models So Bad, He Was Willing to Join the X Cesspool Gizmodo · AJ Dellinger
- Microsoft, Meta, Nvidia, OpenAI, and Palantir have a message for Washington Business Insider
- Jensen Huang just used his first ever X post to warn the AI industry not to make the mistake that software narrowly avoided in the 1980s Fortune · Nick Lichtenberg
- In Face of US Crackdown, Microsoft, Nvidia CEOs Back Open-Weight AI Models PCMag · Michael Kan
- In their letter defending open-weight AI, tech companies urge lawmakers to avoid “premature restrictions” that “stifle competition or drive innovation overseas” CNBC · Ashley Capoot
- Jensen Huang Posts On X For The First Time Ever — And Uses It To Defend Open-Source AI Benzinga · Erica Kollmann
- High-Stakes Battle Over China Policy & Open Source AI Pits LLM Giants Against Their Customers Newcomer
- Silicon Valley divided over restricting Chinese AI as China closes gap with US The Business Times
- What's the name for the type of fallacy this is? Supporting the existence of Linux and people's right to use it, in no way necessitates the open sourcing of your own platform. It's like Burger King announcing support for the local food bank and McDonald's getting pissy and saying “oh yeah? … @alexc04 · Alex Chesser
- As open-weight models become the next AI ecosystem's foundation, a US ban on Chinese models would risk ceding the neutral substrate where innovation compounds Tobi Knaup
- Making sense of the panic over Chinese AI TechCrunch · Anthony Ha
- Open-weight AI is having its Kubernetes moment Hacker News
- Tech leaders back open-source AI Semafor · J.D. Capelouto
Discussion
-
@jensenhuang
Jensen Huang
on x
For my first post, I'm sharing a letter @NVIDIA signed on why open models matter. AI will transform every industry, power every company, and be built by every country. Open models strengthen safety and cybersecurity, accelerate innovation and diffusion, and enable sovereignty. Th…
-
@satyanadella
Satya Nadella
on x
Open-weight models are essential to a healthy AI ecosystem. Together with others across our industry, we are outlining a path for open-weight models to strengthen American competitiveness and expand economic opportunity, while protecting national security. https://www.microsoft.c…
-
@andrewcurran_
Andrew Curran
on x
AMD has also signed! [image]
-
@mattzeitlin
Matthew Zeitlin
on x
Oh so innovation being driven by quasi monopoly returns accruing to companies run by their founders is bad now? I thought we had all read Zero to One?
-
@mikeisaac
Rat King
on x
google spent the week fence sitting until this morning, now looks like they too want to be seen as pro open source now that everyone else signed the jensen letter
-
@davidsacks
David Sacks
on x
Nobody is saying that all software has to be open source. What they're saying is that open-weight AI should be allowed. By implication, they're rejecting your company's incessant machinations to kneecap the open model ecosystem. Read the room.
-
@tszzl
Roon
on x
if we could coordinate a global capabilities slowdown today i would likely press that magic button
-
@packym
Packy McCormick
on x
Anthropic is an ideologically captured organization seeking regulatory capture to protect both their business and their ideology. [image]
-
@mikeisaac
Rat King
on x
the way this is playing out: the part of the industry that is conflicted on open source realizes it is better to all align against anthropic and box them out tons of frenemies against a common antagonist, and what better way to sway valley sentiment than say “hooray open source”
-
@thestalwart
Joe Weisenthal
on x
It's funny that this whole fracas kicked off because there was one eval which said that Kimi3 was near-frontier at frontend design work (probably one of the least important metrics tbh).
-
@firstadopter
Tae Kim
on x
NYTimes: “OpenAI and Anthropic have lobbied regulators in Washington to restrict open-source A.I. models …
-
@emollick
Ethan Mollick
on x
I think most people, when talking about open weights models, don't deeply believe in the vision of AGI/ASI that lab insiders believe in. Like they don't expect AI to really present grave semi-autonomous biosecurity or other similar risks. Whether it is right or not, no one knows,
-
@tszzl
Roon
on x
@woke8yearold yep - there is no way to hold a consistent belief set where you're agi pilled and pro open source and this has been obvious since ilya wrote this 2015 or whatever. enormous cope ensues
-
@bgurley
Bill Gurley
on x
Excited to see Anthropic acknowledge the real problem with open is it competes with their corporate economic strategy. The “awareness” here is revealing. When you build the biggest private market cap ever, you should expect competition. I'm sure the secondaries have been nice.
-
@thestalwart
Joe Weisenthal
on x
Yesterday they were signing open letters. Today they are yelling at people to “read the room. VCs have recreated BlueSky-politics from first principles.
-
@mikeisaac
Rat King
on x
here's a story about the “open vs closed” debate over the past few weeks in the tech industry and how, depending on who you ask, the global economy and national security could be at stake w/ @kateconger @AnaSwanson and meaghan tobin https://www.nytimes.com/...
-
@angelbrodin
Angel
on x
this is the dumbest take i've seen all week, on par with ppl who say “if you care about homelessness then let them live in your house.” just an incredibly dumb purity test it's not too late to delete this my man
-
@sundarpichai
Sundar Pichai
on x
Very happy to support this on behalf of Google. We have long benefited from open source, are big contributors to open source and in fact have consistently made open weights models with Gemma available from @GoogleDeepMind @demishassabis . Onwards!
-
@mononofu
Julian Schrittwieser
on x
I'm so excited that @JensenHuang is a believer in open source now, looking forward to the CUDA and GPU driver open source release!
-
@finkd
Mark Zuckerberg
on x
Open source is a positive and important force for both empowering people and preventing centralization. Proud to support this.
-
@wowbaggert
@wowbaggert
on bluesky
These guys both know that their customers are going to migrate to cheaper self hosted open models the second they try to charge them the actual cost of their opex. — This is rank anti-competitive maneuvering.
-
r/artificielle
r
on reddit
la guerre est déclarée entre partisans du closed et de l'open source
-
r/technology
r
on reddit
Nvidia and 24 other companies sign open-weights letter as Washington weighs Chinese AI model ban — OpenAI, Anthropic, and Google absent from the list
-
@carnage4life
Dare Obasanjo
on bluesky
Anthropic and OpenAI are creating a Streisand Effect where their ongoing attacks on open Chinese AI models lets everyone know those models are actually so good that they're worth checking out.
-
r/LocalLLaMA
r
on reddit
Sources: OpenAI and Anthropic quietly lobby Washington regulators to restrict open-source AI models, even as Sam Altman publicly says he supports open source AI
-
@vkoganpolisci
Vladimir Kogan
on x
Classic Bootleggers and Baptists! OpenAI and Anthropic want to do to Chinese open-source AI models what Detroit did to Chinese electric cars. https://www.nytimes.com/...
-
r/BetterOffline
r
on reddit
OpenAI and Anthropic quietly lobby Washington regulators to restrict open-source AI models, even as Sam Altman publicly says he supports open source AI
-
@davidsacks
David Sacks
on x
The entire tech industry (save for Anthropic) has come out in favor of open source AI. So what happens next? Will Anthropic change its lobbying efforts? Not likely. Now the gaslighting begins: “Nobody is trying to ban open source.” “We just want to limit who can use it.” “W…