Apple agrees to pay $50M to settle a class-action lawsuit claiming the company knew and concealed that its MacBook butterfly keyboards were prone to failure
Apple Inc (AAPL.O) agreed to pay $50 million to settle a class-action lawsuit by customers who claimed it knew and concealed that the …
Reuters Jonathan Stempel
Context & Ripple Effects
The MacBook keyboard claims had already cleared a major procedural hurdle when a judge certified the proposed class action, after allegations that smaller fixes had not solved the underlying flaw. The settlement converts that litigation risk into a defined cost for Apple.
It also sits alongside Apple's earlier up-to-$500M iPhone slowdown settlement, establishing a related record of large consumer claims centered on allegations that the company did not adequately disclose device behavior.
First-order effects
- Apple commits $50 million to resolve the butterfly-keyboard class action, while affected MacBook customers gain a settlement route rather than continuing through trial.
Second-order effects
- The agreement adds another prominent consumer-device case to Apple's legal record, increasing the importance of how it documents product defects and communicates remedies when design problems emerge.
Third-order effects
- If claims over undisclosed device behavior continue to reach class-wide resolution, consumer class actions become a more durable check on technology companies' product-design and disclosure decisions.
The trend: Apple's keyboard settlement is part of a broader pattern in which consumer class actions turn alleged device and disclosure failures into material corporate liabilities.
Related: Apple · MacBook butterfly keyboard class action certified · Apple iPhone slowdown class-action settlement
Related Coverage
- Apple to Pay $50 Million Settlement Over MacBook Butterfly Keyboard Lawsuit Wall Street Journal · Denny Jacob
- Apple agrees to pay up to $395 to MacBook owners who replaced ‘butterfly’ keyboards CNBC · Kif Leswing
- Apple agrees to pay $50M to customers with faulty MacBook keyboards PC Gamer
- Apple Settles Butterfly Keyboard Lawsuit for $50 Million iPhone Hacks · Sriansh
- Apple agrees to settle class-action suit over problematic ‘butterfly’ keyboards ZDNet · Stephanie Condon
- Apple's sticky butterfly: I'm not waiting for my $50 Philip Elmer‑DeWitt · Philip Elmer-DeWitt
- Faulty MacBook Butterfly Keyboards Cost Apple $50 Million in Lawsuit Settlement MacRumors · Juli Clover
- Apple To Pay $50 Million To Settle Case Against Defective MacBook Keyboards With Butterfly Keys Fossbytes · Abhishek Mishra
- Numlock News: July 20, 2022 • Pret Index, Raiders, Worm Wars Numlock News · Walter Hickey
- Start Up No.1842: Musk v Twitter set for October, heat burns cloud services, showrunners' gripes about streaming, and more The Overspill · Charlesarthur
- If you owned a MacBook with a butterfly keyboard, Apple may owe you $395 Macworld
- Apple settles $50 million lawsuit over defective keyboards — here's what we know Tom's Guide · Malcolm McMillan
- Apple's Butterfly Keyboard Fiasco Leads to a $50M Settlement Wired · Boone Ashworth
- Apple agrees to $50 million settlement over MacBook's old defective butterfly keyboards Mashable
- Apple settles MacBook Butterfly keyboard lawsuit for $50 million iThinkDifferent · Rida Imran
- Apple settles class-action lawsuit over defective keyboard for $50 million Washington Examiner · Jenny Goldsberry
- Apple to pay $50 million for faulty MacBook Pro keyboard design BGR · Yoni Heisler
- Apple reaches US$50m settlement over defective MacBook keyboards iTnews · Jonathan Stempel
- Apple agrees to $50M settlement in MacBook butterfly keyboard lawsuit AppleInsider · Malcolm Owen
- Apple settles lawsuit over its reviled ‘butterfly’ keyboard for $50 million Engadget · Jon Fingas
- Apple's Rubbish Butterfly Keyboard Costs It $50 Million In A Lawsuit Settlement Redmond Pie · Oliver Haslam
- Butterfly Keyboard Lawsuit Settlement Michael Tsai
- Apple Agrees to Pay $50 Million USD in Class-Action Lawsuit Over Faulty MacBook Keyboards iPhone in Canada Blog · Nehal Malik
- Apple agrees to pay $50M to settle lawsuit over flawed keyboards on older MacBooks TechCrunch · Kyle Wiggers
- Have MacBook keyboard problems? Apple may owe you some money Digital Trends · Alan Truly
- Apple will pay $50 million in settlement over defective butterfly MacBook keyboards iDownloadBlog.com · Evan Selleck
- Apple to pay $50m settlement for rotten butterfly keyboards The Register · Tobias Mann
- Apple to Pay $50 Million to Settle Butterfly Keyboard Lawsuit Thurrott · Laurent Giret
- Apple to pay $50 million settlement over MacBook butterfly keyboard lawsuit MacDailyNews
- Apple Butterfly Keyboard Settlement to Cost Tech Giant Up to $50 Million The Mac Observer · Jeff Butts
- Apple Denies Any Wrongdoing in $50M Butterfly Keyboard Settlement Tom's Hardware · Mark Tyson
- Apple will settle butterfly keyboard lawsuit for $50 million The Verge · Mitchell Clark
- Apple Reaches Settlement in U.S. Over Butterfly Keyboards Pixel Envy · Nick Heer
- Apple forced to cash out $50 million for allegedly selling MacBooks with faulty keyboards 9to5Mac · José Adorno
- Apple Invents & Wins a Patent for future Keyboards with keys that could be Dynamically Adjusted based on user preferences Patently Apple · Jack Purcher
- Apple agrees to pay $50M to settle a class-action lawsuit that claimed Apple knew and concealed that the butterfly keyboards on MacBooks were prone to failure Patently Apple
Discussion
-
@flaggedfordepot
@flaggedfordepot
on x
It was such a shit keyboard. I don't think $50 Million is enough. I CRUd machines that had their keyboard replaced at least 3 times. https://www.wsj.com/...
-
@roncharles
Ron Charles
on x
“The tech giant denied all of the allegations made in the lawsuit. Apple didn't respond.” Just like the “s” and the “Shift” keys on my MacBook. https://www.wsj.com/...
-
@joannastern
Joanna Stern
on x
Appl to Pay $50 Million in Sttlmnt Ov Buttfly Kyboad https://www.wsj.com/...
-
@caseyjohnston
Casey Johnston
on x
WE DID IT TEAM https://www.reuters.com/...
-
@kifleswing
Kif
on x
This butterfly keyboard settlement will apply nationwide, not just in 7 states, according to attorney for plaintiffs and a close reading of the settlement and preliminary brief https://www.cnbc.com/...
-
@rsgnl
Joe Rossignol
on x
Good. The butterfly keyboard sucked. I literally upgraded my MacBook Pro because my keyboard had sticky + broken keys and I was fed up. Apple shockingly stuck with the butterfly keyboard for like 4 years despite lots of complaints. I am so happy with the design of Macs nowadays. …
-
@baxiabhishek
Abhishek Baxi
on x
Battery-gate, bend-gate, and now butterfly-gate. Apple's trinity of putting out inferior products but getting by because it's Apple. https://twitter.com/...
-
@scottnover
Scott Nover
on x
My shift key sucks https://twitter.com/...
-
@dlberes
Damon Beres
on x
Dang. Couple things about this: - $50 million is .2% of Apple's most recent $25+ billion quarterly *profit* - Apple gets to deny any wrongdoing per terms of the settlement - Even the most affected consumers will see a maximum payout of $325; a fraction of the cost of a MacBook ht…
-
@peterdkramer
Peter D. Kramer
on x
As a butterfly-keyboard sufferer from a small state, I want to know: Will @apple offer us a similar consideration? I'd love $400 & 4 years' more worth of repairs—& I'm not sure that even so I'd feel fully compensated. https://finance.yahoo.com/...